🌳Best Finger Foods in Jamaica Plain, MA

New York Bagel & Coffee Co is JP’s low-key go-to for crispy, crave-worthy Finger foods that hit the spot—every single time. Whether you’re cooling down from a dog walk in the Arnold Arboretum, heading to a weekend movie at Coolidge Corner Theatre, or breaking up your work-from-home routine, we’re here with fast, bold flavor that keeps locals coming back.

From hand-cut fries to spicy Cajun tots, Parmesan truffle fries, and crunchy kettle chips, every side is made fresh to order, never greasy, and packed with the kind of comfort you can’t get from the usual fast-food chains. Vegan-friendly options? We’ve got them. Quick pickup or app delivery? Easy. Craving something crispy before your next picnic or porch hang? We’ve got just the box for it.

Stop by for a solo snack, group order, or shareable tray—hot, fast, and flavorful is how we do it in JP. 👉 Order online, swing through Centre Street, or grab-and-go on your way to Jamaica Pond.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🌟 Why Jamaica Plain Locals Love Our Finger Foods

✅ Quick bites made for busy days in JP

Whether you’re running errands on Centre Street, catching up with friends in Hyde Square, or just need a fast flavor fix, our Finger foods are made fresh and fast—no fuss, all taste.

✅ Vegan-friendly snacks that don’t skimp on flavor

From our Classic Fries to Kettle Chips, we’ve got options that are totally plant-based and totally crave-worthy.

✅ Bold flavors in every bite

Choose from Cajun-spiced heat, Parmesan truffle indulgence, or keep it classic with a golden, crispy crunch. There’s something for every mood.

✅ Perfectly portioned for solo snacking or group munching

Grab a single box for yourself or share a tray with friends at the park or on your stoop. Our sides scale up for hangouts or chill nights in.

✅ JP’s favorite side stop

Loved by families, dog-walkers, students, and park regulars, we’re the go-to for fast snacks with real flavor—served hot and hassle-free.

✅ Fast pickup and easy delivery, always

Order ahead and skip the line, or stay in and let us come to you via Uber Eats, DoorDash, or Grubhub—smooth, fast, and always fresh.

🍴 Finger Foods Menu – Small Bites, Big Flavor

Looking for easy-to-serve, flavor-packed snacks? Our Finger food trays are perfect for brunches, baby showers, office lunches, or casual family get-togethers. Each tray features bite-sized treats like lox bagel bites, cheesy mini sliders, crispy hash rounds, and more.

Tater Tots (Parmesan Truffle) – $6.99

Crispy, golden potato tots drizzled with rich truffle oil and topped with finely grated Parmesan cheese, finished with a touch of fresh herbs. A luxurious upgrade to a comfort classic.

Tater Tots (Classic) – $4.99

Hot, crunchy potato tots served fresh from the fryer. Lightly salted and paired with tangy ketchup for that nostalgic, satisfying bite.

Tater Tots (Cajun) – $5.99

Crisp and golden potato tots tossed in a fiery Cajun spice blend, delivering a bold, smoky flavor profile. Comes with a cool dipping sauce to balance the heat.

French Fries (Parmesan Truffle) – $6.99

Hand-cut potato fries, double-fried to perfection, then finished with earthy truffle oil and a generous sprinkle of nutty Parmesan cheese—an irresistible, gourmet side.

French Fries (Cajun) – $5.99

Crispy and golden fries tossed in our signature Cajun seasoning, offering layers of spice, garlic, and smoky paprika in every bite. Perfect with any sandwich or wrap.

French Fries – $5.75

Crispy, golden fries perfectly seasoned to satisfy your everyday cravings. Each bite delivers a delightful crunch and balanced flavor, making them the ultimate go-to snack or side that never disappoints.

Nantucket Crisp (BBQ) – $2.99

Thin and crunchy potato chips coated with a sweet, tangy BBQ seasoning. Smoky and savory, they pack a punch in every handful.

Nantucket Crisp (Salt & Vinegar) – $2.99

Kettle-cooked potato crisps with sharp vinegar tang and balanced sea salt—a bold, crave-worthy classic that tingles the taste buds.

Nantucket Crisp (Sea Salt) – $2.99

Perfectly thin, ultra-crunchy chips lightly seasoned with pure sea salt. Simple, clean, and the ultimate anytime snack.

Chicken Wings – $10.99

Juicy, crispy bone-in wings, cooked to golden perfection and served piping hot, are paired with your choice of tender chicken wing style and signature sauce. Whether you crave tangy, spicy, or smoky, each bite bursts with bold, mouthwatering flavor that keeps you coming back for more.

Crispy Onion Rings – $9.99

Thick-cut, sweet onions are dipped in a light, flavorful batter and fried to crispy, golden perfection. With their satisfying crunch and tender, juicy center, these classic onion rings are perfect as a savory side or a standalone snack you’ll keep reaching for.

Fried Okra – $9.99

Golden-fried okra bites, perfectly seasoned and irresistibly crunchy, bring the authentic Southern-style snack experience right to your plate. Each bite bursts with bold, savory flavors and a satisfying crispness that makes them a delightful treat any time of day.

Jalapeño Cheese Poppers – $8.99

Fiery spicy jalapeños and gooey, melted cheese come together inside a seasoned, crispy shell for a snack that’s bold, cheesy, and utterly addictive. Choose your perfect flavor twist from Plain, zesty Masala, luxurious Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

Seasoned Eggplant Fries – $8.99

Crispy on the outside and tender within, these golden-seasoned eggplant fries deliver a unique twist that’s both surprising and delightful. Served with your choice of Plain, zesty Masala, luxurious Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

Seasoned Zucchini Fries – $8.99

Light, crispy, and perfectly herb-seasoned, these fries offer a fresh, flavorful twist on the classic favorite. Enjoy them your way with a choice of Plain, zesty Masala, rich Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

💬 Jamaica Plain Raves – 10 Testimonials

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Shanice A. – Centre Street

“The Parmesan Truffle Tots are my guilty pleasure after yoga at the Arboretum. Crispy, golden, and way too easy to devour—dangerously good!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Luis R. – Hyde Square

“Every time I ride around the Pond, I reward myself with the Cajun fries. They’ve got just the right heat. Always hot, always satisfying.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Amira T. – Jamaica Street

“Finally—a bagel spot with legit sides! The fries and tots are crispy, flavorful, and never greasy. Total upgrade from the usual snack.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Ben F. – Forest Hills

“I work from home nearby and pick up lunch here weekly. My go-to? Truffle fries + an iced coffee. Always hits the spot.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Monica D. – South Street

“My daughter is obsessed with the tots—and I love that they’re fresh, not soggy or oily. It’s our weekend ritual.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Desmond C. – Green Street T

“Grabbed a box of Cajun tots on the way downtown. Hands down the best quick snack I’ve had all week.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rina S. – Franklin Park

“I always bring a tray of tots and kettle chips to park picnics. Everyone ends up asking, ‘Where’d you get these?’”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Thomas V. – Stony Brook

“This place is JP’s best-kept secret for Finger foods. Everything’s fresh, full of flavor, and served fast.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Kayla N. – Centre/South

“I come in at least once a week. The crispy tots, quick service, and friendly staff make this spot unbeatable.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Leo M. – Eliot Street

“Forget the chains—these fries and tots taste homemade and hand-crafted, not mass-produced. Real comfort food done right.”

❓ FAQs – Finger Foods in Jamaica Plain

Do I have to order a sandwich to get Finger foods?

Not at all. Our fries, tots, and kettle chips are just as crave-worthy on their own as they are alongside a sandwich. Whether you’re in for a full meal or just a snack, you’re covered.

Are your fries hand-cut?

Yes—always fresh-cut in-house and fried to crispy perfection. No frozen shortcuts, ever.

Is the Cajun spice very spicy?

It’s got a flavorful, well-balanced kick—not too hot, just enough heat to keep things interesting. A crowd favorite for a reason.

Do you offer vegan options?

Absolutely. Our Classic Tots, Classic Fries, and Nantucket Kettle Chips are all vegan-friendly, made without dairy or animal products.

Is there parking nearby?

Yes! Street parking is usually available around Centre Street and adjacent side roads. Quick pickup? Totally doable.

Do you deliver to Jamaica Pond or Forest Hills?

Yes—we deliver throughout Jamaica Plain via Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Grubhub, so your snacks can come to you.

Can I customize my order with sauces?

You bet. Choose from classic ketchup, spicy aioli, chipotle mayo, or ask us about other options available in-store.

Are the tots gluten-free?

The ingredients are gluten-free, but they’re made in shared fryers, so we recommend caution for those with severe gluten allergies.

Can I order bulk for gatherings?

Yes! Hosting a porch party, picnic, or office hang? Order trays of fries or tots—just give us a heads-up so we can crisp them fresh.

Are these Finger foods good cold?

They’re best hot and fresh, but still tasty later. If you’re saving them for later, a quick reheat brings the crisp right back.

📍 Jamaica Plain, Come Snack With Us

From scenic strolls at Arnold Arboretum to chill afternoons by Jamaica Pond, New York Bagel & Coffee Co is your go-to pit stop for craveable comfort. Whether you’re squeezing in a snack between errands, biking through Centre Street, or fueling up before a picnic, our fresh-made fries, tots, and crispy chips deliver bold flavor without the wait.

✅ Quick, hot, and made-to-order
✅ Vegetarian-friendly, kid-approved, totally addictive
✅ Perfect for solo bites or sharing with the crew

👉 Order online, swing by, or grab a hot box on your way to the park—it’s Finger food done right, JP-style.