🍕 Best Non-Veg Neapolitan Pizza in Jamaica Plain, MA
In Jamaica Plain, when the irresistible craving for authentic non-veg Neapolitan pizza strikes, NY Bagel & Coffee Co. stands as the go-to neighborhood favorite. We’re not just serving pizza — we’re delivering a culinary tradition rooted in patience and craftsmanship. Our dough is fermented for a full 72 hours, allowing the flavors to deepen and the texture to develop naturally. Each ball of dough is then hand-stretched with care and baked in an 800°F stone oven, producing a beautifully blistered crust that’s crisp on the outside yet light, airy, and tender within — the unmistakable signature of true Neapolitan mastery.
Every pie is generously adorned with premium, hand-selected meats, farm-fresh vegetables bursting with flavor, and Italian-imported cheeses that melt into a luscious, savory layer. The result is a pizza that balances richness and freshness in every bite. Whether you’re strolling along Centre Street, taking in the shimmering waters of Jamaica Pond, or wandering through the lush landscapes of the Arnold Arboretum, our pizza is always within reach — ready for dine-in indulgence, quick takeout, or speedy, piping-hot delivery straight to your door.
Order Now
📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States
📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937
📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com
🛒 Order Online
Order Now
⭐ Why Jamaica Plain Locals Love Our Non-Veg Neapolitan Pizza
Authentic Craft – Our pizzas start with hand-tossed dough made fresh daily, slow-fermented for flavor depth, then stone-oven baked at intense heat for that perfect Neapolitan char. Each pie is a blend of time-honored Italian tradition and skilled local craftsmanship.
Fresh Ingredients – We source crisp, seasonal produce from trusted local farms and pair it with Italian-imported cheeses and premium cured meats. Every topping is selected for maximum freshness and flavor, creating a pizza that tastes vibrant and full in every bite.
Perfect Texture – Each pizza emerges from our stone oven with a crispy, golden exterior that gives way to a light, airy interior — that magical contrast that keeps Neapolitan lovers coming back again and again.
Quick Delivery – From Forest Hills to Hyde Square, and every block in between, we deliver your pizza piping hot and fresh so you can enjoy that just-baked aroma and texture at home, work, or wherever you are in Jamaica Plain.
Neighborhood Favorite – Whether it’s family dinners, romantic date nights, or a solo treat after a long day, our pizza has become a local tradition — a place where great food and community come together.
🍽 Signature Non-Veg Neapolitan Pizzas in Jamaica Plain
Double Meat Deluxe – $17.99
A hearty feast of savory sausage and thick-cut ham, layered generously over zesty tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of smoky, salty, and cheesy goodness, baked to golden perfection.
BBQ Chicken Neapolitan – $16.99
Tender grilled chicken smothered in a tangy, smoky BBQ glaze, topped with sweet red onions and bubbling mozzarella. A classic favorite with that irresistible charred BBQ depth.
Bacon Lover’s Margherita – $15.99
A fresh Margherita base of vine-ripened tomatoes, fragrant basil, and silky mozzarella, crowned with crispy bacon for the ultimate savory twist on a classic.
Bacon Lover’s Dream – $15.99
A robust tomato base meets luxuriously creamy Mozzarella di Bufala, creating a rich, mouthwatering canvas. Piled high with double the crispy smoked bacon for extra crunch and smoky indulgence, then crowned with a savory blend of sharp Parmesan and nutty Romano cheeses.
Ham & Pineapple Napoli – $15.99
The perfect sweet-and-savory balance — juicy ham paired with golden pineapple chunks, layered over mozzarella and finished with a subtle chili oil drizzle for a gentle heat.
The Steakhouse – $15.99
Succulent strips of juicy steak mingle with sautéed onions and earthy mushrooms, all brought together with a rich balsamic reduction drizzle for a refined, gourmet flavor.
Spicy Meat Trio – $18.99
A bold blend of pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, kicked up with a sprinkle of crushed red pepper. Perfect for spice lovers who crave heat with their meaty indulgence.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza – $16.99
Silky Alfredo sauce replaces the traditional tomato base, topped with tender chicken, fresh spinach, and baked on a garlic-infused crust for a creamy, comforting bite.
Rustic Sausage & Peppers – $16.99
A classic Italian favorite — seasoned sausage, colorful bell peppers, and sweet onions, baked to release warm, rustic flavors reminiscent of old-world kitchens.
Honey Bacon Chicken – $17.99
Juicy grilled chicken and smoky bacon meet a luscious drizzle of golden honey, creating a sweet-and-savory harmony that’s simply addictive.
Truffle Steak Pizza – $16.99
A luxurious combination of steak and wild mushrooms, topped with fresh arugula and finished with a fragrant truffle oil drizzle for an indulgent touch.
Meat Lovers Special – $19.99
A bold, flavor-packed creation piled high with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon — every bite a satisfying, protein-rich indulgence for true carnivore fans.
Buffalo Chicken Napoli – $16.99
Spicy Buffalo chicken paired with tangy red onions and melted mozzarella, finished with a creamy ranch swirl for a cool, zesty balance.
Smoky BBQ Bacon & Ham – $17.99
A smoky BBQ base loaded with tender ham, crispy bacon, sweet onions, and melted cheese — a rich, hearty BBQ-lover’s dream.
The Carnivore – $20.99
The ultimate meat-lover’s fantasy — pepperoni, bacon, ham, chicken, sausage, and steak stacked high for a pizza that’s as indulgent as it is satisfying.
Crispy Bacon Bliss – $14.99
A rich tomato base layered with creamy Mozzarella di Bufala creates a luscious foundation, while crispy smoked bacon adds a bold, savory crunch. Finished with a generous sprinkle of sharp Parmesan and nutty Romano cheeses.
Grilled Chicken Delight – $14.99
A vibrant tomato base pairs beautifully with delicate, creamy Mozzarella di Bufala, while tender grilled chicken brings a juicy, smoky depth. Topped with a flavorful blend of sharp Parmesan and rich Romano cheeses.
Protein Power Chicken – $15.99
A tangy, vibrant tomato base pairs with creamy Mozzarella di Bufala, creating the perfect backdrop for double the tender, juicy grilled chicken. Each bite offers a rich blend of smoky flavor and melty, gooey cheese, finished with a generous sprinkle of sharp Parmesan and nutty Romano cheeses.
🍕 What Jamaica Plain Locals Are Saying
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – Laura K., Centre Street
“The Centre Street Meat Feast is pure comfort in every bite — the crust is airy yet chewy, the meats taste like they were sliced fresh that morning, and the cheese melts into every corner. It’s my go-to when I need a hearty, satisfying dinner.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – Marcus P., Jamaica Pond Area
“The Truffle Arugula Steak pizza is basically fine dining on a crust. The earthy truffle aroma, tender steak strips, and fresh peppery arugula make every bite taste gourmet — I’d happily serve this at a dinner party.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – Renee T., Hyde Square
“I order the Buffalo Ranch Chicken almost every week. The heat from the Buffalo sauce blends perfectly with the cool, creamy ranch, and the chicken is always tender and juicy. It’s addictive in the best way possible.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – Omar L., Forest Hills
“Delivery was lightning fast — and my Honey BBQ Chicken Bacon pizza arrived still piping hot, with that smoky-sweet BBQ aroma filling the room before I even opened the box. Worth every bite.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – Priya S., Arborway
“The Rustic Sausage & Peppers pizza took me straight back to my trip to Italy. The sweet onions, colorful peppers, and perfectly seasoned sausage tasted like something straight out of a family kitchen in Naples.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – David H., Stony Brook
“I built my own pizza with extra pepperoni, jalapeños, and double mozzarella — and wow. The toppings were generous, the cheese was perfectly gooey, and the stone-oven crust had that irresistible smoky edge.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – Ella M., Green Street
“The BBQ Chicken Neapolitan is my Friday night ritual. The sauce has just the right tang, the chicken is juicy, and the crust is perfection. Bonus — they never skimp on the cheese.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – Carlos V., Egleston Square
“Their Meat Lovers Special is a feast for carnivores. Every slice is stacked high with flavorful meats, yet it’s never greasy. The balance between toppings, cheese, and crust is spot-on.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – Sofia L., South Street
“Tried the Ham & Pineapple Napoli and was pleasantly surprised. The sweetness of the pineapple with the saltiness of the ham, plus that subtle chili oil drizzle, made for a flavor combo I can’t stop thinking about.”
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ – James R., Jamaica Hills
“The gluten-free crust is a total game changer. Light, flavorful, and with the same smoky oven char as their regular pizzas — you’d never guess it was gluten-free.”
❓ FAQs – Best Non-Veg Neapolitan Pizza in Jamaica Plain
Where’s the best non-veg Neapolitan pizza in Jamaica Plain, MA?
At NY Bagel & Coffee Co., we craft our pizzas using authentic Neapolitan recipes, perfected with time-honored techniques and baked in an 800°F stone oven. Every pizza is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients to deliver a taste that’s as unforgettable as it is satisfying.
Do you deliver in Jamaica Plain?
Yes — from Forest Hills to Hyde Square, Jamaica Pond, and even the quieter corners near the Arnold Arboretum. Our delivery is designed to get your pizza to you piping hot and fresh every time.
Can I customize my pizza?
Absolutely. Choose your favorite meats, veggies, and cheeses, and we’ll craft it to your liking — whether you want something classic like pepperoni and mozzarella or adventurous like truffle oil and arugula.
Do you have gluten-free crust?
Yes — our gluten-free crust is baked in the same stone oven for that authentic char and crispness, so you can enjoy all the flavor of our pizzas without the gluten.
Where do your ingredients come from?
We proudly source fresh, locally grown vegetables and quality meats from nearby suppliers, while also importing authentic Italian cheeses and specialty items for that true Neapolitan taste.
How long does baking take?
Once your pizza goes into our 800°F stone oven, it’s ready in about 10–12 minutes — the high heat locks in flavor, crisps the crust, and perfectly melts the cheese.
Do you offer combo meals?
Yes — you can pair your pizza with sides like fresh salads, garlic knots, or even homemade desserts for a complete meal that hits every craving.
Are your meats halal-certified?
Some of our meats are halal-certified — just give us a quick call before ordering, and we’ll be happy to guide you through the available options.
Do you cater in Jamaica Plain?
Yes — we provide catering for family gatherings, office meetings, school events, and parties. Whether it’s a few pizzas or a full spread, we’ll bring the flavor to your event.
Can I pre-order?
Yes — order online or by phone to schedule your pickup or delivery exactly when you want it, perfect for busy evenings or planned events.
📍 Visit or Order Your Non-Veg Neapolitan Pizza in Jamaica Plain Today!
From Centre Street to the scenic shores of Jamaica Pond, NY Bagel & Coffee Co. is serving up authentic Neapolitan pizza that’s hot from the stone oven, freshly made to order, and bursting with bold, mouthwatering flavor in every slice. Whether you’re exploring the neighborhood or relaxing at home, each pizza arrives with that irresistible smoky aroma, perfectly blistered crust, and toppings so fresh you can taste the quality in every bite.
🛍 How to Order in Jamaica Plain
- Dine-In – Fresh from the stone oven to your table.
- Takeout – Quick pickup with minimal wait.
- Delivery – Hot pizza to your Jamaica Plain home.
- Online Ordering – Easy and fast.
- Pre-Scheduled Orders – Great for gatherings and special occasions.
📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com🛒 Order Online
Order Now