🥯 Best Artisan Sandwiches & Bagels in Arlington, MA

Looking for the best breakfast café in Arlington, MA? At New York Bagel & Coffee Co, we proudly bring the bold, authentic taste of New York–style bagels and artisan coffee to the heart of Arlington. Step into our cozy café and experience the aroma of freshly baked bagels, sizzling handcrafted sandwiches, and locally roasted coffee that starts your day right.

Whether you’re a busy commuter grabbing breakfast on the go, a student needing a mid-day recharge, or a local craving a weekend brunch spot near Arlington Center, our doors are always open. With a menu built on fresh ingredients, friendly service, and a welcoming vibe, we’re more than just a coffee shop — we’re your go-to neighborhood café in Arlington.

Come taste why we’re considered a local favorite for bagels, sandwiches, and coffee in Arlington, MA.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

Why Choose Our Artisan Sandwiches in Arlington, MA?

When it comes to artisan sandwiches in Arlington, we don’t cut corners — we build each one with purpose, passion, and premium ingredients. Every sandwich at New York Bagel & Coffee Co is a flavorful experience, made to order with hand-selected deli meats, crisp farm-fresh vegetables, signature house sauces, and your choice of our famous bagels or freshly baked sandwich rolls.

From our vegan and vegetarian options to gluten-free sandwiches crafted with care, we cater to every dietary preference without compromising on flavor. Whether you’re planning a team lunch in Arlington, picking up something hearty before a hike on the Minuteman Bikeway, or craving a comforting sandwich on a rainy afternoon, our menu has something that fits the moment.

We’re proud to serve the Arlington, MA community with real ingredients, bold combinations, and the kind of quality that keeps locals coming back. Every bite speaks to our commitment to flavor, freshness, and local love.

📋 Local Favorites: Artisan Sandwich Menu Highlights

The Great Wall of China – $14.45

A bold, meaty masterpiece stacked with roast beef, pastrami, Swiss and Gouda cheeses, pickles, brown mustard, and creamy Russian dressing—delivering a savory, smoky, and tangy flavor punch in every bite.

Dragon Boat – $13.99

A hearty combo of turkey breast, bacon, and American cheese, topped with crisp lettuce, banana peppers, and spicy horseradish sauce—finished with golden tater tots for a fun, crunchy finish.

The Yellow Mountains – $14.45

Savor the smoky goodness of pastrami and bacon, with sweet red onions, Muenster cheese, fresh tomato, sprouts, and spicy boom boom sauce—a fiery twist on a classic deli-style sandwich.

The Pearl River – $15.99

Flavor flows with juicy chicken breast, crispy bacon, smooth chive cream cheese, grilled onions and peppers, tangy banana peppers, and a mix of provolone and Muenster—topped with boom boom sauce and crunchy sea salt chips.

The Shanghai Tower – $14.99

Stacked high with savory prosciutto, crispy bacon, sautéed onions and peppers, provolone, Swiss, and Parmesan, plus fresh lettuce, sprouts, tomato, and bold chipotle mayo—a skyscraper of flavor.

Lantern – $14.45

A trio of deli favorites—roast beef, turkey, and bacon—layered with melted Swiss and cheddar, crisp lettuce, tomato, and smoky chipotle mayo for a rich, savory bite.

The West Lake – $15.99

A spicy and creamy fusion of roast beef, ham, jalapeño cream cheese, grilled onions and peppers, smooth provolone and Gouda, with fresh tomato, lettuce, red pepper paste, and crispy chips.

Laba – $14.45

Indulge in layers of roast beef, ham, and bacon with creamy Dill Havarti, nutty Gouda, crisp lettuce, crunchy pickles, spicy jalapeños, and a tangy Parmesan peppercorn dressing.

Nu River – $15.99

A bold mix of chicken, roast beef, zesty chive cream cheese, smooth Dill Havarti, sweet and spicy peppers, banana peppers, smoky BBQ sauce, and pepper paste—topped with crunchy chips.

The Nanya River – $15.99

A savory blend of prosciutto, chicken, and bacon, with creamy plain cream cheese, tangy feta, nutty Parmesan, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, red onion, and smoky chipotle mayo.

Double Ninth – $14.45

Packed with layers of turkey, pepperoni, and roast beef, plus sweet onions, bold Swiss and smoked cheddar, tied together with tangy brown mustard and creamy ranch dressing.

Spring – $14.45

A fresh and hearty mix of turkey, pork sausage, creamy plain cream cheese, shredded Parmesan, crisp lettuce, sprouts, juicy tomato, and flavorful red pepper spread—perfect for lighter appetites.

💬 What Arlington Locals Are Saying – 10 Real Testimonials

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tom R. – Arlington Heights

“The Great Wall of China is my ultimate lunch fix — stacked with roast beef and pastrami, and that Russian dressing adds the perfect zing. I work long shifts at the hospital, and this sandwich keeps me full and focused for hours. It’s bold, juicy, and always hits the spot.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Maya C. – East Arlington

“Finally, a place in Arlington that takes gluten-free seriously! I get the Dragon Boat on a gluten-free bagel, and it’s still crispy, flavorful, and fresh. The combo of turkey, bacon, and those golden tater tots? Genius. I’ve never felt like I’m missing out here.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jake L. – Arlington Center

“The Yellow Mountains is exactly what I want in a deli-style sandwich — smoky bacon, tangy sauce, and fresh sprouts for crunch. The Muenster cheese melts beautifully. I work from home and walk over for lunch at least twice a week. Great energy, even better sandwiches.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Priya N. – Brattle Square

“I’m obsessed with the Shanghai Tower. You can taste the quality in every layer — the prosciutto, sautéed onions, and chipotle mayo make it feel gourmet but cozy. This isn’t your average deli; it’s artisan food with soul, right here in Arlington.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Daniel K. – Jason Heights

“The Pearl River sandwich is on another level. Chicken, bacon, grilled peppers, and cream cheese — and then they top it with sea salt chips? Who does that?! New York Bagel & Coffee Co totally nailed the mix of texture and flavor.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Leila S. – Lake Street Area

“The Nu River is my go-to for something spicy and filling. I love that it has both roast beef and chicken, plus BBQ and chive cream cheese. The crunchy chips are a fun surprise. Hands down the best artisan sandwich I’ve found in Arlington.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Sean P. – Arlington Reservoir Area

“You can tell they actually care about their ingredients — the meats are thick-cut, the veggies are crisp, and the sauces taste homemade. The Laba is a flavor bomb with roast beef, jalapeños, and peppercorn dressing. I bring my coworkers here every Friday.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Emily T. – Spy Pond

“I tried the Spring sandwich last weekend and it was so fresh and satisfying. The turkey and sausage combo with red pepper spread is perfect for brunch. I love that they use sprouts and good quality lettuce — makes it feel healthier without losing flavor.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Noah D. – Arlington Heights

“The West Lake is a wild ride — roast beef, ham, jalapeño cream cheese, and chips inside the sandwich! It’s spicy, creamy, and messy in the best way. If you like bold flavors, you have to try it. My new favorite sandwich in Arlington.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jasmine L. – East Arlington

“I usually go for turkey, but the Nanya River blew me away. Chicken, prosciutto, bacon, three kinds of cheese — it’s a full-on feast. The vibe at NY Bagel is warm and relaxed, and the staff always gets my customizations right. Love this spot!”

🙋‍♂️ FAQs – Sandwiches, Bagels & Coffee in Arlington, MA

1️⃣ What makes your sandwiches special in Arlington?

Our artisan sandwiches are built with premium deli meats, fresh veggies, bold sauces, and your choice of house-made bagels or soft rolls. Each one is crafted by hand, never pre-assembled, using locally sourced ingredients for unbeatable flavor. Arlington customers love the care and creativity in every bite.

2️⃣ Do you offer vegan and gluten-free meals in Arlington?

Absolutely! We offer vegan sandwich options made with plant-based proteins and fresh vegetables, and we also have gluten-free buns available daily. Whether you’re vegan, gluten-sensitive, or just health-conscious, there’s something delicious for you here in Arlington, MA.

3️⃣ Can I customize my sandwich?

Yes! We love creativity. Choose your bread (bagel or roll), protein, cheese, veggies, and sauce. You can build your own artisan masterpiece or tweak one of our signature sandwiches to suit your taste.

4️⃣ Is breakfast available all day?

Yes it is! Our breakfast sandwiches are served from the moment we open at 6:00 AM until closing. Arlington early birds and late risers alike can enjoy eggs, bacon, and bagels whenever hunger strikes.

5️⃣ What’s your most popular sandwich?

Locals rave about the Double Ninth – a triple-layer combo of turkey, roast beef, pepperoni, Swiss, and smoked cheddar, tied together with creamy ranch and tangy mustard. It’s big, bold, and packed with flavor.

6️⃣ Do you roast your coffee in-house?

We sure do. Our coffee is small-batch roasted for deep, smooth flavor and a satisfying finish. Whether you’re sipping an espresso or cold brew, it’s a perfect pairing with our hearty sandwiches — and a favorite among Arlington coffee lovers.

7️⃣ Can I order online and pick up near Arlington Center?

Yes! We’re just a short walk from Arlington Center, and our online ordering system is fast and easy. Simply order ahead, and we’ll have your artisan sandwich ready for pickup in minutes.

8️⃣ Do you offer catering in Arlington?

Yes, we cater! From corporate lunches to school meetings, our catering menu includes platters of artisan sandwiches, breakfast boxes, coffee, and more. Perfect for events throughout Arlington and surrounding areas.

9️⃣ Are your spicy sandwiches very hot?

We keep it flavorful, not overwhelming. Sandwiches like the Yellow Mountains and West Lake have a medium spice level, but if you’re craving more heat, we’re happy to kick it up a notch with extra sauces or jalapeños.

🔟 Is your café family-friendly?

Definitely! We offer kid-friendly menu options, cozy seating, and a relaxed atmosphere. Whether you’re grabbing lunch with the family or fueling up after a morning at Spy Pond, we’re your go-to spot in Arlington.

📞 Call-to-Action: Order Today from Arlington’s Favorite Bagel Café

Looking for handcrafted sandwiches, warm bagels, and bold coffee in Arlington? Stop by New York Bagel & Coffee Co — where fresh ingredients, friendly service, and bold flavors come together. Whether you’re craving a plant-based breakfast, a cheesy melt, or a meaty signature sandwich, we’ve got your new favorite meal waiting.
👉 Order online now or visit us in Arlington, MA — your local café is just around the corner!