🥯 Best Artisan Sandwiches in Brookline, MA

Located in the heart of Brookline, MA—just steps from Coolidge Corner, Washington Square, and Harvard Street—New York Bagel & Coffee Co is your neighborhood café for bold flavors and warm service.

We’re known for our freshly baked New York–style bagels, hearty artisan sandwiches, and house-roasted coffee that hits the spot every time. Whether you’re a Boston University student, a Longwood Medical Area commuter, or a local family out for a weekend walk, our shop is here to serve you something delicious—morning, noon, or afternoon.

Our menu offers everything from classic breakfast bagels and savory melts to vegan-friendly builds and spicy, sauce-packed signature sandwiches. Fast, friendly, and full of flavor, we’re proud to be Brookline’s go-to café for daily fuel and local connection.

Stop in and see why our bagels and sandwiches have become a local favorite — made fresh, served fast, and crafted with care.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

Why Brookline Locals Love Our Artisan Sandwiches

At New York Bagel & Coffee Co – Brookline, our sandwiches are more than just meals — they’re handcrafted creations made to satisfy every appetite and lifestyle.

Each sandwich starts with fresh-baked bagels or soft artisan rolls, then layered with premium deli meats, melty cheeses, crisp farm-fresh veggies, and our signature house-made sauces. Whether you’re craving bold and spicy, warm and savory, or clean and plant-based, there’s something on the menu that hits just right.

We proudly cater to vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free diets — making us one of the most inclusive sandwich cafés in Brookline. Locals swing by for breakfast sandwiches, power up during lunch breaks, or unwind with a cozy bite and a hot drink on weekends.

This is the sandwich spot Brookline counts on — fresh, fast, full of flavor, and always made with care.

📋 Brookline Favorites – Artisan Sandwich Menu

The Great Wall of China – $14.45

A bold, meaty masterpiece stacked with roast beef, pastrami, Swiss and Gouda cheeses, pickles, brown mustard, and creamy Russian dressing—delivering a savory, smoky, and tangy flavor punch in every bite.

Dragon Boat – $13.99

A hearty combo of turkey breast, bacon, and American cheese, topped with crisp lettuce, banana peppers, and spicy horseradish sauce—finished with golden tater tots for a fun, crunchy finish.

The Yellow Mountains – $14.45

Savor the smoky goodness of pastrami and bacon, with sweet red onions, Muenster cheese, fresh tomato, sprouts, and spicy boom boom sauce—a fiery twist on a classic deli-style sandwich.

The Pearl River – $15.99

Flavor flows with juicy chicken breast, crispy bacon, smooth chive cream cheese, grilled onions and peppers, tangy banana peppers, and a mix of provolone and Muenster—topped with boom boom sauce and crunchy sea salt chips.

The Shanghai Tower – $14.99

Stacked high with savory prosciutto, crispy bacon, sautéed onions and peppers, provolone, Swiss, and Parmesan, plus fresh lettuce, sprouts, tomato, and bold chipotle mayo—a skyscraper of flavor.

Lantern – $14.45

A trio of deli favorites—roast beef, turkey, and bacon—layered with melted Swiss and cheddar, crisp lettuce, tomato, and smoky chipotle mayo for a rich, savory bite.

The West Lake – $15.99

A spicy and creamy fusion of roast beef, ham, jalapeño cream cheese, grilled onions and peppers, smooth provolone and Gouda, with fresh tomato, lettuce, red pepper paste, and crispy chips.

Laba – $14.45

Indulge in layers of roast beef, ham, and bacon with creamy Dill Havarti, nutty Gouda, crisp lettuce, crunchy pickles, spicy jalapeños, and a tangy Parmesan peppercorn dressing.

Nu River – $15.99

A bold mix of chicken, roast beef, zesty chive cream cheese, smooth Dill Havarti, sweet and spicy peppers, banana peppers, smoky BBQ sauce, and pepper paste—topped with crunchy chips.

The Nanya River – $15.99

A savory blend of prosciutto, chicken, and bacon, with creamy plain cream cheese, tangy feta, nutty Parmesan, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, red onion, and smoky chipotle mayo.

Double Ninth – $14.45

Packed with layers of turkey, pepperoni, and roast beef, plus sweet onions, bold Swiss and smoked cheddar, tied together with tangy brown mustard and creamy ranch dressing.

Spring – $14.45

A fresh and hearty mix of turkey, pork sausage, creamy plain cream cheese, shredded Parmesan, crisp lettuce, sprouts, juicy tomato, and flavorful red pepper spread—perfect for lighter appetites.

💬 What Brookline Locals Say – Testimonials

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rachel T. – Coolidge Corner

“Sandwiches here are next-level. The Yellow Mountains is the perfect combo of savory and spicy. Easily one of the best lunch spots in Brookline.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Leo M. – Brookline Village

“Love coming here before work. The coffee is strong, the bagels are always fresh, and the Great Wall sandwich is a beast. Fills me up every time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Nina D. – Beacon Street

“Best sandwich shop near me! Great vegan options and super friendly staff. The vibes are always warm, and everything is made fresh.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Omar F. – BU South Campus

“Brookline needed this! The Dragon Boat is an absolute must. Crunchy tots inside a sandwich? Genius. Always my top pick.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Sarah K. – Washington Square

“Super quick service and always consistent. My go-to lunch spot between classes or errands. Highly recommend the Pearl River.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Daniel W. – Longwood Area

“Love that I can order online and swing by during my break. The sandwiches are stacked and flavorful — especially the Pearl River.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jules A. – St. Paul Street

“They’ve nailed the NY bagel café vibe. Every sandwich feels like something special. Cozy space, great tunes, and friendly folks behind the counter.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Melissa C. – Brookline High

“My kids and I come here every Sunday morning. They go for the breakfast bagels, and I’m all about the West Lake sandwich. Always fresh, always delicious.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Henry L. – Brookline Booksmith Regular

“Perfect pit stop after browsing the shelves. I grab a coffee and a custom sandwich on an everything bagel—hits the spot every time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Alicia M. – Corey Hill

“I’m gluten-free and it’s hard to find quality GF sandwiches. This place nails it. Awesome bread, tons of flavor, and the staff gets it.”

❓ FAQs – Bagels, Sandwiches & Coffee in Brookline, MA

1️⃣ What makes your sandwiches different from others in Brookline?

At New York Bagel & Coffee Co – Brookline, we don’t just make sandwiches — we craft them. Every order is made fresh with premium deli meats, melty cheeses, house-made sauces, and farm-fresh veggies, all layered on our signature bagels or fresh sandwich rolls. Our flavor-forward combinations and generous portions set us apart in Brookline’s bustling food scene.

2️⃣ Do you have gluten-free and vegan choices?

Yes! We offer a variety of gluten-free buns and vegan ingredients, including plant-based proteins, dairy-free spreads, and fresh veggies, so everyone — no matter their dietary needs — can enjoy a full-flavored, satisfying meal.

3️⃣ Can I customize my sandwich or bagel order?

Absolutely. We’re all about making it yours. Pick your bagel or roll, choose from classic or bold meats, cheeses, spreads, veggies, and sauces. Whether you want to build something totally unique or tweak a house favorite, we’ve got you covered.

4️⃣ Do you roast your coffee beans in-house?

We do — right here in Brookline. Our small-batch coffee roasting process brings out bold, smooth flavors in every cup. Whether you’re grabbing a morning brew or pairing it with your lunch sandwich, our coffee is designed to impress.

5️⃣ Do you deliver in Brookline?

Yes! We offer fast local delivery and easy online ordering from our Brookline café. Whether you’re near Coolidge Corner, Washington Square, or somewhere in between, we’ll bring bagels, sandwiches, and coffee right to your door.

6️⃣ Do you serve breakfast sandwiches all day?

Definitely. Craving a bacon, egg & cheese on a fresh everything bagel at 3 PM? No problem. Our full breakfast menu, including sandwiches, bagels, muffins, and coffee, is available from open to close every day.

7️⃣ Do you offer catering services in Brookline?

Yes — and it’s a hit! We provide bagel boxes, sandwich platters, coffee cambros, and more for school functions, office meetings, community events, and private parties throughout the Brookline area. Just tell us what you need — we’ll handle the rest.

8️⃣ What are your most popular sandwiches in Brookline?

Favorites here include the Double Ninth (a flavor-packed meat-lover’s dream), the Pearl River (with its zesty, savory layers), and the Lantern (a spicy vegetarian favorite). Locals love the bold flavors and creative combinations.

9️⃣ Is your café family-friendly?

Very much so. We offer a relaxed, welcoming space, kid-friendly menu options, and plenty of room for strollers or families dining together. It’s a great spot for casual meals with little ones in tow.

🔟 Can I dine in or just take out?

Both! We have cozy indoor seating if you want to enjoy your sandwich with a fresh cup of coffee, or quick grab-and-go service if you’re on the move. Whether it’s dine-in, takeout, or delivery, we’re built for your day.

☕ Brookline’s Favorite Bagel & Sandwich Café

At New York Bagel & Coffee Co – Brookline, we’re serving up more than just sandwiches — we’re delivering bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and the kind of hand-rolled bagels that keep you coming back.

From crispy-on-the-outside, chewy-on-the-inside bagels to stacked artisan sandwiches and smooth, house-roasted coffee, everything we make is crafted with care and served with heart. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast on the go, meeting a friend for lunch, or just need a midday pick-me-up, we’ve got you covered.

👉 Order online, stop by, or grab a seat and stay awhile.
Your next favorite sandwich (and cup of coffee) is waiting — right here in Brookline, MA.