Best Bagel Shop in Watertown, MA

Finding a truly fresh bagel shop in Watertown, MA can feel like a search for New York authenticity right in your neighborhood. Bagel lovers know the difference between store-bought bagels and those made by hand, and at NY Bagel & Coffee Co., we bring that authentic New York–style flavor to Watertown every single day.

Our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and stone-baked — the traditional process that creates the perfect balance of a chewy inside and crisp golden crust. From classic plain, sesame, and everything bagels to loaded sandwiches stacked with fresh eggs, cheese, smoked salmon, or vegan spreads, we’ve got something for everyone.

We’re not just about bagels — our freshly brewed coffee, specialty cream cheeses, and hearty breakfast sandwiches make us the go-to café for students, families, and professionals in Watertown. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bagel on the way to work, ordering delivery for the office, or stopping in with friends, we make sure every bite tastes fresh and satisfying.

With affordable pricing, convenient takeout, and reliable delivery across Watertown and nearby towns, NY Bagel & Coffee Co. has quickly become a favorite for locals seeking comfort food with a New York twist.

📍 Restaurant Info – NY Bagel & Coffee Co.

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

Why Choose Our Bagel Shop in Watertown, MA?

🥯 Authentic Hand-Rolled, Kettle-Boiled Bagels

At NY Bagel & Coffee Co., every bagel is made using the classic New York process — hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and stone-baked. This gives our bagels the chewy inside and crispy golden crust that Watertown bagel lovers crave. Unlike factory-made versions, each bagel is crafted fresh daily, ensuring unmatched quality.

🍳 Perfect Morning Stop for Watertown Professionals

Watertown has a growing community of professionals and commuters who start their mornings early. Our shop opens at 6:00 AM, making it the perfect stop for a fresh breakfast before heading to work. From egg-and-cheese bagels to smoked salmon classics, we help fuel your busy day.

☕ Fresh Coffee & Bagel Pairings

We know a bagel is best enjoyed with a cup of hot coffee. That’s why our menu features freshly brewed coffee, iced lattes, cappuccinos, and teas that pair perfectly with our bagels. Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast or sitting down to relax, we make mornings in Watertown better.

🌱 Vegan & Vegetarian-Friendly Options

Watertown is home to many health-conscious and plant-based eaters. We offer vegan cream cheese spreads, veggie-loaded bagels, and plant-based sandwiches that deliver big flavor without compromise. Our menu ensures everyone in the family finds something they love.

🚴 Fast Takeout & Delivery Across Watertown

Whether you’re working from home, studying, or hosting a gathering, we provide reliable delivery across Watertown. Our packaging keeps bagels warm and intact, while our takeout service is designed for quick, no-hassle pickups.

👨‍👩‍👧 Family-Friendly Atmosphere

Families in Watertown love visiting us for weekend breakfasts and casual meals. Our generous portions, affordable pricing, and kid-friendly menu items make us a go-to spot for bagel lovers of all ages.

🎉 Catering for Watertown Events

From office meetings at Arsenal Yards to family gatherings at home, our catering service makes group orders easy. With platters of fresh bagels, cream cheeses, and sandwiches, we’re the trusted choice for events in and around Watertown.

Bagel Shop in Watertown & 19 Nearby Neighborhoods

🥯 Bagel Shop in Allston, MA

Just minutes from Watertown, Allston residents love our hand-rolled bagels for quick breakfasts and late-night bites. Perfect for students, professionals, and families craving authentic New York–style flavor.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Cambridge, MA

Cambridge foodies and students from Harvard and MIT trust us for fresh, affordable bagels, sandwiches, and coffee. We deliver fast across Central, Harvard, and Kendall Square.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Brookline, MA

Families in Brookline enjoy our healthy, vegetarian-friendly bagel sandwiches and spreads. A perfect option for weekend brunch or a quick, satisfying takeout meal.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Somerville, MA

From Davis Square to Union Square, Somerville residents love our bagel shop for reliable delivery and hearty breakfast platters that keep mornings energized.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Boston, MA

We proudly serve Boston with authentic bagels baked fresh daily. Whether you’re in Back Bay, Downtown, or Fenway, our delivery ensures a warm, delicious breakfast anytime.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Watertown, MA

Right here in Watertown, our bagel shop is a local favorite for families, professionals, and students alike. Freshly baked bagels, hearty sandwiches, and hot coffee daily.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Arlington, MA

Arlington residents enjoy our classic plain, sesame, and everything bagels, along with plant-based sandwich options that cater to all tastes and diets.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Medford, MA

Popular among Tufts University students, our bagel delivery in Medford brings comfort food right to your doorstep — perfect for study sessions or group breakfasts.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Newton, MA

Newton families count on us for catering, weekend brunch, and healthy bagel sandwich options. We’re the go-to shop for quick, fresh, and satisfying meals.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Belmont, MA

Belmont locals love our fresh cream cheese flavors and hearty breakfast bagels. Perfect for early mornings, school lunches, or weekend gatherings.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Waltham, MA

From tech professionals to students, Waltham residents enjoy our fast takeout and delivery. Our bagels fuel busy mornings and late-night cravings.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Jamaica Plain, MA

Known for its artsy vibe, JP loves our bagels for brunch and casual gatherings. We deliver fresh, hot bagels and sandwiches right to your neighborhood.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Roslindale, MA

Roslindale families rely on us for weekend breakfasts and catering platters. Fresh bagels with delicious spreads are perfect for group dining at home or work.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Dorchester, MA

Dorchester residents enjoy our flavorful bagel sandwiches with fresh coffee. We deliver quickly across the area, making mornings easy and delicious.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Chelsea, MA

Chelsea customers love our affordable pricing and fresh bagel combos. Whether for workday lunches or weekend brunch, our delivery is always reliable.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Everett, MA

Everett locals trust us for hot bagels and hearty breakfast sandwiches delivered fresh. Perfect for busy families, commuters, and weekend brunch lovers.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Malden, MA

Malden’s growing foodie scene embraces our New York–style bagels. With vegan spreads, signature sandwiches, and delivery, we’re a community favorite.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Revere, MA

Revere residents enjoy our bagels by the beach or at home. Fresh, hot, and made daily, our bagels are perfect for quick breakfasts or family brunches.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Quincy, MA

From Quincy Center to Marina Bay, customers love our wide selection of bagels and sandwiches. We’re the top choice for delivery and catering across the city.

🥯 Bagel Shop in Fenway-Kenmore, MA

Students and professionals in Fenway-Kenmore rely on us for fresh bagels before classes, Red Sox games, or office hours. Always fresh, fast, and flavorful.

Popular Menu Highlights – NY Bagel & Coffee Co.

🥯 Bagels Menu

Plain Bagel

A classic, simple bagel with a chewy texture and a golden-brown crust.
The images shown are for illustration purposes only and may not be an exact representation of the product.
💲 $3.10

Everything Bagel

A bagel covered in a mix of seeds, onion, garlic, and salt for a burst of flavor.
The images shown are for illustration purposes only and may not be an exact representation of the product.
💲 $3.10

Sesame Bagel

A bagel topped with sesame seeds, adding a nutty flavor and crunch.
The images shown are for illustration purposes only and may not be an exact representation of the product.
💲 $3.10

Asiago Bagel

A bagel infused with asiago cheese, providing a rich and savory flavor.
The images shown are for illustration purposes only and may not be an exact representation of the product.
💲 $3.10

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel

A sweet bagel infused with cinnamon and dotted with plump raisins.
The images shown are for illustration purposes only and may not be an exact representation of the product.
💲 $3.10

Onion Bagel

A bagel topped with onion pieces for a savory kick.
The images shown are for illustration purposes only and may not be an exact representation of the product.
💲 $3.10

Whole Wheat Bagel

Wholesome and hearty, our whole wheat bagel is a fiber-rich choice with deliciously nutty flavor.
The images shown are for illustration purposes only and may not be an exact representation of the product.
💲 $3.10

Multigrain Bagel

A hearty bagel made with a blend of various grains and seeds.
The images shown are for illustration purposes only and may not be an exact representation of the product.
💲 $3.10

🥯 Bagel Sandwiches Menu

🥓 Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches

Gordon Street : Bagel & Cream Cheese
Enjoy fresh-baked bagels with smooth cream cheese—the perfect bite any time of day!
💲 $5.45
Chester Street : Make Your Own Breakfast Sandwich
Build your perfect breakfast with our customizable sandwiches—fresh, tasty, and made just for you!
💲 $9.99
Braintree Street : Two Cage Free Egg White, Plain Cream Cheese, Avocado, Tomato, Cucumbers, Alfalfa Sprouts, Parmesan Peppercorn Dressing
Power up with egg whites, veggies, cream cheese, fresh avocado, juicy tomato, crisp cucumbers, crunchy alfalfa sprouts, and a zesty Parmesan Peppercorn drizzle!
💲 $10.25
Ashford Street : Two Cage Free Egg, Plain Smear, Ham, Turkey Breast, Cucumbers, Tomato, Alfalfa Sprouts, Crumbled Feta Cheese, Black Pepper
Craving something savory? Baby ham, roasted turkey, eggs, veggies, and Feta come together in every tasty bite.
💲 $10.99
Adamson Street : Two Cage Free Egg, Chives Cream Cheese, Oven Gold Turkey Breast & Smoked Bacon, Sharp Cheddar & Swiss Cheese with Honey Dijon
A bold mix of eggs, turkey, bacon, cheddar, swiss cheese, and honey Dijon.
💲 $10.45
Alcott Street : Two Cage Free Eggs, Mixed Vegetables Smear, Smoked Bacon & Roast Beef, Wisconsin American Cheese with BBQ Sauce
Eggs, veggie smear, smoky bacon, roast beef, Wisconsin cheese, and BBQ sauce in one bold bite!
💲 $10.45
Everett Street : Two Cage Free Eggs, Sausage, Ham, Chives Smear, Provolone Cheese, Chipotle Mayo
Eggs, sausage, ham, Provolone, chive smear, and chipotle mayo—perfect morning upgrade!
💲 $10.45
Alcorn Street : Two Cage Free Eggs, Jalapeño Smear, Spicy Sausage Patty & Smoked Bacon, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Tomato & Jalapeños with Sweet & Spicy Sauce
Turn up the heat with eggs, sausage, bacon, jalapeño smear, cheddar, tomato, jalapeños, and sweet-spicy sauce!
💲 $10.45
Kelton Street : Smoked Salmon, Plain Cream Cheese, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onions, Alfalfa Sprouts & Capers
Rich smoked salmon with cream cheese, fresh tomato, cucumber, and crisp veggies.
💲 $13.45
Armington Street : Acme Smoked Salmon, Smoked Salmon Spread, Lettuce, Red Onions, Cucumbers, Alfalfa Sprouts with Peppercorn Dressing
Acme smoked salmon with salmon spread, lettuce, onions, cucumbers, sprouts, and peppercorn dressing.
💲 $14.99
Cambridge Street : Choice Of Bagel | Choice Of Egg (Two Cage Free Egg or Egg White +$0.99) | Choice Of Cheese (White American, Sharp Cheddar, Provolone, or Swiss)
Pick your bagel, add eggs or egg whites, and top with your favorite cheese!
💲 $8.45

11a. The Yellow River White Fish Salad Sandwich
Scooped out bagel with white fish salad, tomatoes, onions, capers, and black pepper.
💲 $13.99

11b. Amur River Tuna Salad Sandwich
Scooped out bagel with tuna salad, tomatoes, onions, capers, chili paste, mozzarella, and black pepper.
💲 $13.99

🌱 Vegan Bagel Sandwiches

Franklin Street : Vegan Spread, Vegan Cheddar Cheese, Banana Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Lettuce, Avocado, Brown Mustard
Vegan spread, cheddar, veggies, avocado, and mustard for a plant-based boost!
💲 $12.99
Fuller Street : Vegan Spread, Plant Based Sausage, Vegan Cheddar Cheese, Green Peppers, Red Onions, Jalapeños, Lettuce, Crushed Peppers with Sweet & Spicy Sauce
Plant-based sausage, cheddar, peppers, jalapeños, lettuce, and sweet-spicy sauce!
💲 $11.99
Holman Street : Hummus, Tomato, Lettuce, Alfalfa Sprouts, Banana Peppers & Avocado
Light and creamy with hummus, tomato, sprouts, and avocado.
💲 $11.99
Holmes Street : Hummus & Vegan Spread, Plant Based Sausage, Vegan Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Jalapeño with Barbeque Sauce
Hummus, vegan spread, plant-based sausage, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and BBQ sauce.
💲 $12.99
Mansfield Street : French Fig Jam, Vegan Cream Cheese, Fresh Strawberry & Blueberry Topped with Vegan Honey
Sweet vegan delight with fig jam, cream cheese, berries, and vegan honey.
💲 $12.99
Holton Street : Vegan Cream Cheese, Vegan Nutella, Fresh Strawberry & Blueberry Topped with Powdered Sugar
Vegan Nutella, cream cheese, berries, and a dusting of powdered sugar!
💲 $12.99

🥗 Vegetarian Bagel Sandwiches

Ridgemont Street : Plain Cream Cheese, Cucumber, Green Pepper, Lettuce, Red Onion, Tomato, Provolone Cheese with Crushed Pepper Spread & Ranch
Cream cheese, veggies, Provolone, pepper spread, and ranch dressing.
💲 $12.99
Riverdale Street : Gouda, Dill Havarti, Provolone, Parmesan Cheese, Plant Based Sausage with Chipotle Mayonnaise
Loaded with four cheeses, plant-based sausage, and chipotle mayo!
💲 $13.99
Wilton Street : Chive Cream Cheese, Jalapeños, Green Peppers, Avocado, Lettuce, Pickle, Dill Havarti Cheese, Honey Mustard Topped with Sea Salt Potato Chips
Tangy, creamy, and crunchy with chips on top for a unique bite!
💲 $12.99
Windom Street : Fresh Mozzarella, Pesto, Tomato, Lettuce with Balsamic Vinaigrette
Fresh mozzarella, pesto, tomato, and lettuce with balsamic.
💲 $12.99
Arthur Street : Mixed Vegetable Cream Cheese, Dill Havarti Cheese, Red Onions, Green Peppers, Tomato, Alfalfa Sprouts & Avocado with Parmesan Peppercorn Dressing
Veggies, Havarti, avocado, and peppercorn dressing for a fresh bite!
💲 $12.99

Delivery & Takeout Information – NY Bagel & Coffee Co.

✅ Always Fresh, Never Stale

Every bagel you order is baked fresh the same day. We don’t serve pre-packaged or day-old bagels. Whether you choose delivery or takeout, you’ll always enjoy warm, chewy, golden-brown bagels straight from the oven.

✅ Fast Delivery Across Watertown & Nearby Towns

We understand mornings are busy. That’s why our delivery service covers Watertown and surrounding neighborhoods like Cambridge, Belmont, Newton, and Boston. On average, your bagels arrive within 30–45 minutes, hot and ready to eat.

✅ Secure & Eco-Friendly Packaging

Our packaging is designed to keep bagels warm and sandwiches intact. We use eco-friendly, recyclable materials that are spill-proof, so your cream cheese spreads and sandwiches arrive fresh and neat every time.

✅ Easy Online Ordering System

With just a few clicks, you can place your bagel order through our online platform. No phone calls needed. Simply choose your favorite bagels, add-ons, or sandwiches, and select delivery or pickup at checkout.

✅ Catering & Large Order Options

Planning a meeting, family brunch, or office event? We provide catering with bulk bagel platters, spreads, and sandwiches. Large orders are packaged carefully and delivered on time, making group dining stress-free and delicious.

✅ Takeout Made Simple

If you’re nearby, our takeout counter makes it easy to grab fresh bagels on the go. Place your order online or by phone, and it’ll be ready when you arrive — no waiting in long lines.

✅ Reliable Service You Can Count On

From weekday breakfasts to late-night cravings, our team ensures orders are accurate, fresh, and timely. Watertown residents trust us as their go-to bagel shop for consistent delivery and takeout every single day.

Why We’re the Best Bagel Shop in Watertown, MA

1. Authentic New York–Style Taste in Watertown

Not all bagels are created equal. At NY Bagel & Coffee Co., we follow the time-honored New York tradition — hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and stone-baked. This technique gives our bagels their signature chewy texture and crisp crust, setting us apart from chain cafés and grocery-store bagels in Watertown.

2. Freshly Baked Daily with Premium Ingredients

We never cut corners. Every bagel is baked fresh daily using high-quality flour, seeds, and toppings. From sesame to asiago, everything is made in small batches to guarantee flavor and freshness. Watertown customers know they’ll never get a stale or mass-produced bagel from us.

3. Wide Menu for All Diets & Tastes

Watertown is home to families, professionals, and students with diverse food preferences. That’s why we offer not just traditional bagels, but also vegan sandwiches, vegetarian spreads, protein-packed breakfast bagels, and sweet treats like cinnamon raisin. Everyone finds something they love here.

4. Convenient Delivery, Takeout & Catering

Whether you’re rushing to work, grabbing a quick breakfast, or hosting an event in Watertown, we’ve got you covered. Our fast delivery, easy takeout, and catering platters make us a flexible option for every occasion — from office meetings to Sunday brunches.

5. Trusted by the Watertown Community

We’ve quickly become a go-to breakfast and brunch spot in Watertown. Locals appreciate our generous portions, affordable prices, and consistent quality. From early-morning commuters to families enjoying weekend bagels together, our shop has earned the trust of the community.

⭐ Customer Testimonials – Best Bagel Shop in Watertown, MA

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Emily R. – Watertown, MA
“Finally, a bagel shop in Watertown that feels just like New York! The plain bagel with cream cheese was warm, chewy, and perfect. I stop by almost every morning before work — it’s my new routine.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
James T. – Newton, MA
“I ordered catering for our office meeting in Watertown, and everyone loved the variety. The sesame bagels with veggie spreads were fresh, and the packaging was neat. Delivery was on time too!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sophia K. – Belmont, MA
“As a vegetarian, I love that NY Bagel & Coffee Co. has so many plant-based sandwich options. The Franklin Street vegan bagel sandwich with avocado and vegan cheddar is my absolute favorite!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Michael L. – Watertown, MA
“Their breakfast sandwiches are unbeatable. I had the Ashford Street with eggs, turkey, and feta, and it was delicious. Great portion size, fair price, and fast service.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Priya S. – Cambridge, MA
“Bagels delivered to my apartment in under 40 minutes — still warm and soft. The cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese is heavenly. This is my go-to place for late study nights.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
David H. – Watertown, MA
“I grew up in New York, so I know what real bagels should taste like. This place nails it. The everything bagel here tastes exactly like home — chewy, flavorful, and fresh every single time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Anna M. – Boston, MA
“I tried the Kelton Street smoked salmon bagel, and it was amazing. Fresh fish, crisp veggies, and the bagel was baked perfectly. Easily the best bagel shop I’ve found near Boston.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Carlos D. – Arlington, MA
“My kids love their cinnamon raisin bagels, and I always grab a multigrain bagel with coffee on weekends. It’s become our family tradition to stop here every Sunday morning.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel B. – Watertown, MA
“The online ordering system is super easy, and the takeout is always ready when I arrive. The staff is friendly, and the bagels are consistently fresh. Five stars all the way.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Jonathan P. – Somerville, MA
“Ordered the Armington Street smoked salmon bagel sandwich — worth every penny. The flavors were bold, the ingredients fresh, and the portion was huge. This is a must-visit in Watertown.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – Bagel Shop in Watertown, MA

1. Do you offer bagel delivery in Watertown, MA?

✅ Yes! We provide fast and reliable delivery across Watertown and nearby towns like Belmont, Newton, Cambridge, and Boston. Orders usually arrive within 30–45 minutes, fresh and warm. Whether it’s breakfast for one or catering for a group, we make sure your bagels are delivered right on time.

2. Are your bagels baked fresh daily in Watertown?

✅ Absolutely. All of our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh every single morning. We don’t serve frozen or factory-made bagels. When you order from our Watertown location, you can taste the difference in every bite — soft, chewy, and perfectly golden.

3. Do you have vegetarian or vegan bagel options?

✅ Yes, we offer a full range of vegetarian and vegan-friendly bagels and sandwiches. Popular vegan favorites include the Franklin Street bagel sandwich with avocado and vegan cheddar. We also provide vegan cream cheese spreads, hummus, and plant-based sausages for flavor-packed options.

4. Can I customize my bagel sandwich in Watertown?

✅ Definitely! You can build your own sandwich by choosing the type of bagel, eggs, spreads, cheese, and toppings. Whether you want a simple egg-and-cheese combo or a loaded sandwich with smoked salmon and veggies, our menu is designed for flexibility and personal taste.

5. How long does bagel delivery usually take in Watertown?

✅ Most orders within Watertown are delivered in 30–45 minutes. During peak morning hours or large catering requests, it may take a little longer, but we always ensure your bagels arrive hot, fresh, and neatly packaged. Our goal is to serve you breakfast on time, every time.

6. Do you offer catering services in Watertown, MA?

✅ Yes! We specialize in catering for offices, schools, and family events in Watertown. Our catering menu includes platters of assorted bagels, cream cheese spreads, breakfast sandwiches, and beverages. Perfect for meetings, birthday parties, or weekend brunch gatherings.

7. Are there gluten-free options available at your Watertown location?

✅ While our signature bagels are made traditionally with wheat flour, we do offer gluten-free and multigrain options for customers with dietary preferences. If you’re sensitive to gluten, let us know while ordering and we’ll guide you to the best alternatives on our menu.

8. Can I pre-schedule my bagel order for pickup or delivery?

✅ Yes, pre-scheduling is one of the most convenient features we offer. You can order ahead for morning pickup on your way to work or schedule a delivery for a specific time. This is especially useful for office lunches, school events, or weekend family brunches.

9. What makes your bagel shop different from others in Watertown?

✅ Unlike grocery-store bagels or chain cafés, we follow the authentic New York process — hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh. Add to that our wide variety of vegan, vegetarian, and specialty sandwiches, plus reliable delivery across Watertown. That’s what makes us stand out.

10. Do you serve more than just bagels in Watertown?

✅ Yes! While bagels are our specialty, we also serve fresh coffee, iced lattes, teas, breakfast platters, and delicious spreads. Our smoked salmon sandwiches, vegan options, and signature cream cheese flavors make us more than just a bagel shop — we’re a full breakfast café experience.

📞 Visit or Order Today – NY Bagel & Coffee Co.

Looking for the freshest, most authentic bagels in Watertown, MA? Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast, grabbing takeout for the office, or planning a family brunch, NY Bagel & Coffee Co. is your go-to spot.