Fresh Bagel Shop in Jamaica Plain, MA
There’s nothing quite like biting into a freshly baked bagel paired with a cup of hot coffee, and for residents of Jamaica Plain, the search for that authentic New York–style bagel ends with NY Bagel & Coffee Co. Our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily to deliver the perfect texture—crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and bursting with flavor.
At NY Bagel & Coffee Co., we believe in keeping things simple, fresh, and delicious. From classic plain and sesame to everything bagels loaded with flavor, there’s something for everyone. Pair your favorite bagel with house-made cream cheeses, smoked salmon, or a hot breakfast sandwich for a meal that’s hearty, satisfying, and made to order.
Whether you’re stopping by on your way to work, grabbing brunch with friends, or ordering online for delivery to Jamaica Plain, we make it easy to enjoy a fresh, flavorful bagel experience any time of the day. With extended hours and fast service, we’ve become a neighborhood favorite for students, families, and professionals alike.
Restaurant Info
📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States
📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937
📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com
🛒 Order Online
Order Now
🏆 Why Choose Us – Fresh Bagels for Jamaica Plain
🥯 1. Authentic New York–Style Bagels Close to Home
Residents of Jamaica Plain don’t have to travel far to enjoy a real New York–style bagel. Every bagel we serve is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, delivering that signature chewy bite and golden crust that sets us apart from ordinary bagel shops.
☕ 2. Perfect Bagel & Coffee Pairings
A bagel is only complete with the right cup of coffee. We brew fresh, premium coffee throughout the day, so whether you’re starting your morning commute in Jamaica Plain or grabbing a late-night snack, you’ll always get the perfect pairing of hot coffee and fresh bagels.
🧀 3. Variety That Fits Every Craving
From plain and sesame to everything bagels, cinnamon raisin, and more, we offer flavors and spreads for every palate. Add house-made cream cheese, smoked salmon, or an egg-and-cheese sandwich for a hearty meal that satisfies breakfast, brunch, or late-night hunger.
🕕 4. Convenient Hours for Busy Schedules
We’re open 7 days a week, 6:00 AM – 2:00 AM, making it easy for Jamaica Plain locals to grab breakfast on the go, pick up lunch, or enjoy a midnight snack. Our extended hours mean you never have to miss out on a fresh bagel when cravings hit.
🚗 5. Easy Ordering, Takeout & Delivery to JP
Whether you’re in Hyde Square, Forest Hills, or Centre Street, we make it simple to enjoy fresh bagels. With fast takeout, reliable delivery, and online ordering, Jamaica Plain residents can enjoy their favorite bagels without long waits.
👨👩👧 6. A Neighborhood Favorite with Community Spirit
Jamaica Plain is known for its strong community vibe, and we reflect that in everything we do. From warm customer service to consistent quality, we’ve become a trusted favorite for families, students, and professionals who want a dependable bagel shop nearby.
📍 Nearby Cities We Serve – Fresh Bagels Near Jamaica Plain
🥯 Allston, MA
Allston locals count on us for late-night bagel sandwiches and hot coffee. Just a short ride from Jamaica Plain, our fresh-baked bagels make the perfect snack for students and professionals on the go.
🥯 Cambridge, MA
From Harvard Square to Kendall, Cambridge residents love our authentic bagels and rich coffee. Whether it’s delivery or pickup, we bring the taste of New York–style bagels closer to students and professionals alike.
🥯 Brookline, MA
Families and commuters in Brookline enjoy our hand-rolled bagels and hearty breakfast sandwiches. Just minutes away from Jamaica Plain, it’s the perfect stop for weekend brunch or weekday mornings.
🥯 Somerville, MA
Somerville foodies love variety, and our bagels deliver. From everything bagels to cream cheese spreads, we offer fresh options daily, making us a go-to choice for students, families, and young professionals nearby.
🥯 Boston, MA
Right at the heart of Boston, our shop delivers bagels and coffee that fuel the city. From downtown offices to busy college campuses, our New York–style bagels are a favorite for quick breakfasts and catering.
🥯 Watertown, MA
Watertown residents appreciate fresh bagels made the traditional way. Perfect for grab-and-go breakfasts, bagel platters for the office, or weekend takeout paired with hot coffee and cream cheese spreads.
🥯 Arlington, MA
Arlington locals love our fresh bagels, coffee, and convenient delivery. Whether it’s a family breakfast, a study snack, or takeout on the way to work, we make bagels worth the short trip from Jamaica Plain.
🥯 Medford, MA
Close to Tufts University, Medford students and professionals enjoy our bagels as a filling breakfast or a quick late-night bite. Always fresh, flavorful, and served with rich, aromatic coffee to match.
🥯 Newton, MA
Newton families rely on us for bagels that bring people together. From weekend brunches to weekday mornings, our shop delivers fresh, chewy bagels and hot coffee just a short drive from Jamaica Plain.
🥯 Belmont, MA
Belmont residents enjoy authentic bagels without the trip to New York. Our menu offers variety for every craving—plain, sesame, everything, and more—plus delicious cream cheese spreads and sandwiches.
🥯 Waltham, MA
In Waltham, students, families, and professionals all love our freshly baked bagels. Whether it’s delivery or takeout, our shop makes it easy to enjoy a hearty breakfast or late-night snack nearby.
🥯 Jamaica Plain, MA
Proudly serving our home neighborhood, Jamaica Plain locals know us as the go-to spot for bagels, sandwiches, and coffee. With extended hours, we’re here morning, noon, and late at night for your cravings.
🥯 Roslindale, MA
Roslindale residents enjoy our hand-crafted bagels and warm customer service. Just a few minutes from Jamaica Plain, we’re the perfect spot for a cozy breakfast or convenient delivery at home.
🥯 Dorchester, MA
From savory bagels to sweet options, Dorchester locals appreciate our variety and freshness. We offer fast delivery and late-night service, making it easy to enjoy bagels whenever hunger strikes.
🥯 Chelsea, MA
Chelsea foodies love our bagels for their authentic New York flavor. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast before work or ordering takeout for the family, we deliver fresh taste and fast service.
🥯 Everett, MA
Everett residents count on us for freshly baked bagels and strong coffee. Just a short drive or delivery away, we’re a reliable choice for a quick breakfast or a satisfying lunch.
🥯 Malden, MA
Malden locals enjoy our wide selection of bagels, sandwiches, and coffee. Perfect for commuters, students, and families, our menu brings a taste of New York–style bagels close to home.
🥯 Revere, MA
From breakfast runs to weekend family meals, Revere customers love our bagels for their authentic flavor and satisfying texture. Delivery and takeout make enjoying them easier than ever.
🥯 Quincy, MA
Quincy residents trust us for bagels baked fresh daily and coffee that’s always hot. Whether it’s for a quick breakfast, office catering, or a family weekend treat, we’ve got Quincy covered.
🥯 Fenway-Kenmore, MA
Students, professionals, and Red Sox fans in Fenway-Kenmore enjoy our bagels as the perfect grab-and-go meal. Hot, fresh, and packed with flavor, they’re ideal before class, work, or a game.
🍱 Popular Menu Highlights – Jamaica Plain
🥯 Freshly Baked Bagels
Plain Bagel – $2.25
Classic, chewy, and golden brown—our plain bagel is perfect on its own or as the base for any sandwich.
Everything Bagel – $2.75
Loaded with sesame, garlic, onion, and poppy seeds for a bold, savory bite that pairs well with any spread.
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel – $2.95
A slightly sweet option, packed with plump raisins and a hint of cinnamon—ideal for breakfast or a snack.
🧀 House-Made Cream Cheese Spreads
Classic Cream Cheese – $3.50
Smooth, rich, and creamy—our traditional spread is made fresh daily and a perfect match for any bagel.
Scallion Cream Cheese – $3.95
Creamy with a refreshing kick of green onions, this spread adds extra flavor to both plain and savory bagels.
Honey Walnut Cream Cheese – $4.25
Sweet and nutty with a touch of crunch, this spread turns any bagel into a treat.
🍳 Breakfast Sandwiches
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel – $6.99
A hearty classic—crispy bacon, fluffy eggs, and melted cheese stacked on your choice of bagel.
Smoked Salmon & Cream Cheese – $8.99
Fresh lox layered with cream cheese, tomato, red onion, and capers for the ultimate bagel sandwich.
Veggie Delight Bagel Sandwich – $6.50
Packed with fresh veggies, cheese, and your choice of spread—light yet filling, perfect for vegetarians.
☕ Coffee & Beverages
Freshly Brewed Coffee – $2.50 (S) / $3.25 (L)
Hot, aromatic, and brewed all day for the perfect pairing with your bagel.
Latte / Cappuccino – $4.50
Smooth espresso balanced with steamed milk—ideal for mornings or an afternoon pick-me-up.
Iced Coffee – $3.75
Bold, refreshing, and served cold. Customize it with milk, sugar, or flavors to your taste.
🥯 Specialty Combos
Bagel & Coffee Combo – $4.99
Your choice of bagel with a schmear plus a hot cup of freshly brewed coffee—perfect for mornings on the go.
Bagel Brunch Box (For 4) – $19.99
A mix of bagels, cream cheese spreads, and add-ons—great for families, brunch, or sharing at the office.
Bagel & Lox Platter – $24.99
A shareable platter with smoked salmon, assorted bagels, cream cheese, veggies, and capers—perfect for gatherings.
🚗 Delivery & Takeout – Fresh Bagels in Jamaica Plain
✅ 1. Freshly Baked Bagels Every Time
All of our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, ensuring you never receive a stale or pre-packaged product. Whether you order takeout or delivery, your bagels arrive with the same crisp crust and chewy texture you’d enjoy in-store.
✅ 2. Hot Coffee Delivered Right
We brew fresh coffee throughout the day and use spill-proof, insulated packaging for deliveries. This means your latte, cappuccino, or hot coffee will stay warm and flavorful—perfect alongside your favorite bagel, even on the go.
✅ 3. Full Menu Available for Takeout & Delivery
From plain bagels with cream cheese to hearty breakfast sandwiches and lox platters, our entire menu is available for pickup and delivery. You’ll never miss out on your favorite order just because you’re at home or the office.
✅ 4. Fast, Reliable, and Convenient
We know mornings in Jamaica Plain can be busy. That’s why we prioritize quick takeout service and reliable delivery partners, making sure your bagels and coffee reach you on time, fresh, and carefully packed.
✅ 5. Easy Online Ordering
With just a few taps, you can customize your bagel, add spreads, and order coffee online for pickup or delivery. No waiting in long lines—your order will be ready at your chosen time, prepared exactly how you like it.
✅ 6. Perfect for Families, Students & Offices
Our takeout and delivery options are designed for everyone—from solo breakfasts to family brunches, student study breaks, or office catering. Bagel boxes, cream cheese tubs, and coffee travelers make group orders easy to enjoy.
🏆 Why We Are the Best – NY Bagel & Coffee Co. Jamaica Plain
🥯 1. Authentic New York–Style Bagels
We stay true to tradition by hand-rolling, kettle-boiling, and baking each bagel fresh daily. This process creates the signature chewy texture and golden crust that Jamaica Plain residents love—far superior to supermarket or chain alternatives.
☕ 2. Fresh Coffee Brewed All Day
We believe a great bagel deserves equally great coffee. That’s why we brew fresh batches all day long, ensuring every cup is hot, aromatic, and perfectly balanced—whether it’s a morning boost or a late-night sip.
🧀 3. Endless Choices & Customization
From plain, sesame, and everything bagels to cinnamon raisin and specialty flavors, we offer a wide selection with house-made cream cheeses, lox, and sandwiches. Every customer can create a combination that fits their taste and lifestyle.
🕕 4. Convenient Hours for JP Lifestyles
Open daily from 6:00 AM to 2:00 AM, we’re here for early commuters, brunch lovers, students studying late, and families looking for a quick dinner solution. No matter your schedule, you can count on us.
🚗 5. Takeout, Delivery & Catering Made Simple
We make enjoying bagels stress-free with fast takeout, reliable delivery, and catering services for offices, schools, or family gatherings. Fresh bagels, spreads, and coffee travelers are always packed with care.
👨👩👧 6. Community-Focused & Family-Friendly
Jamaica Plain is known for its strong community, and we reflect that spirit. From friendly service to consistent quality, our shop is a neighborhood favorite where families, students, and professionals all feel at home.
💲 7. High Quality at Affordable Prices
We believe everyone deserves access to fresh, authentic bagels without overspending. That’s why we keep our prices reasonable, making us a go-to choice for everyday breakfasts, brunches, and late-night cravings.
🌟 8. Trusted by Loyal Customers
Our reputation speaks for itself—regulars and first-time visitors alike rave about our consistency, flavor, and service. Word of mouth has made us a staple in the Jamaica Plain community and beyond.
⭐ Customer Testimonials – Jamaica Plain Loves Our Bagels
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Laura M. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“I finally found a place in JP that serves bagels as good as New York. The plain bagel with scallion cream cheese was chewy, flavorful, and so fresh. Paired with a hot coffee, it made my morning. Definitely my new go-to breakfast spot.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Kevin R. – Boston, MA
“Ordered delivery to Jamaica Plain and was impressed with how quickly everything arrived. My everything bagel was still warm, the cream cheese perfectly packed, and my iced coffee tasted freshly brewed. The service is top-notch.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Samantha D. – Roslindale, MA
“I stopped by after a workout and grabbed a sesame bagel with lox. The bagel was perfectly chewy, the toppings fresh, and the staff so welcoming. It felt like a small piece of New York right here in JP.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Mark T. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“As someone who works late nights, the hours here are a lifesaver. Being able to grab a hot bagel sandwich and coffee at midnight makes this shop stand out. Consistently fresh and delicious, no matter the time.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel K. – Cambridge, MA
“I drove down to JP just to try NY Bagel & Coffee Co., and it was worth it! The cinnamon raisin bagel with honey walnut cream cheese was heavenly. Everything tastes homemade, and the staff clearly cares about quality.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Daniel S. – Dorchester, MA
“My office ordered a catering box for breakfast, and it was a hit. A variety of bagels, spreads, and a big coffee traveler—everyone kept asking where it was from. Delivery was right on time and beautifully packed.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Nina L. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“The vibe inside the shop is so warm and community-oriented. I had a veggie bagel sandwich with avocado, and it was both filling and fresh. It’s rare to find a place that feels like home while serving food this good.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Oscar H. – Brookline, MA
“I grew up in New York and have high standards for bagels. These are the real deal—chewy, flavorful, and baked perfectly. Every bite reminds me of home. Jamaica Plain is lucky to have this gem.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Lily C. – Quincy, MA
“I ordered takeout for brunch, and everything was ready right on time. My latte was hot, my bagel was fresh, and the staff even double-checked my order for accuracy. That kind of attention to detail makes me a loyal customer.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
James P. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“This has become my weekend tradition. I grab a coffee and an everything bagel with lox and sit outside to enjoy it. The quality is unbeatable, and the consistency keeps me coming back every week.”
❓ Frequently Asked Questions – Jamaica Plain Bagel Shop
1. Do you serve authentic New York–style bagels in Jamaica Plain?
Yes! Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily using traditional New York methods. This process gives them their signature chew and crust, making us the closest thing to a true New York bagel right here in JP.
2. What kind of bagel flavors do you offer?
We bake a wide variety every day—plain, sesame, poppy, everything, onion, garlic, cinnamon raisin, and specialty flavors. We also rotate seasonal favorites so there’s always something new for Jamaica Plain customers to enjoy.
3. Do you offer vegan or vegetarian options?
Absolutely. Many of our bagels are naturally vegan, and we offer toppings like avocado, veggies, hummus, and dairy-free spreads when available. Vegetarians love our egg-and-cheese sandwiches, lox platters, and veggie combos.
4. Can I order delivery in Jamaica Plain?
Yes! We deliver across Jamaica Plain and surrounding neighborhoods. Orders arrive hot, fresh, and carefully packed so you can enjoy the same quality at home as you would in our shop. Simply order online or call us.
5. Do you provide catering for events in JP?
We do! Our bagel boxes, cream cheese tubs, smoked salmon platters, and coffee travelers are perfect for office breakfasts, family brunches, or school events in Jamaica Plain. We recommend placing larger catering orders 24 hours in advance.
6. Are your bagels baked fresh throughout the day?
Yes. We bake multiple batches daily to keep up with demand, so whether you visit us at 7 AM or 11 PM, you’ll always find fresh bagels with the perfect balance of crust and chew.
7. Do you offer gluten-free bagels?
At this time, we don’t have certified gluten-free bagels due to cross-contact in the kitchen. However, we’re happy to build bagel-style sandwiches on wraps, lettuce, or other alternatives for customers avoiding gluten.
8. What are your opening hours for the JP location?
We’re open seven days a week, from 6:00 AM until 2:00 AM. Our extended hours mean Jamaica Plain residents can enjoy bagels for breakfast, brunch, dinner, or even a late-night snack after a long day.
9. Can I pre-order for pickup?
Yes! Customers in Jamaica Plain can order ahead online or by phone, choose their preferred pickup time, and have bagels, coffee, or sandwiches ready without waiting in line. Perfect for busy mornings or group orders.
10. What makes NY Bagel & Coffee Co. special in Jamaica Plain?
Unlike generic chain bakeries, we specialize in authentic, New York–style bagels paired with fresh-brewed coffee and house-made spreads. Add our welcoming service, affordable prices, and long hours, and it’s easy to see why we’re a favorite in JP.
📞 Visit or Order Today – NY Bagel & Coffee Co. Jamaica Plain
Craving a fresh, chewy New York–style bagel right here in Jamaica Plain? At NY Bagel & Coffee Co., every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked daily to perfection. Pair yours with our house-made cream cheeses, hearty sandwiches, or a steaming cup of coffee for the ultimate comfort meal.
Whether you’re grabbing breakfast on your commute, ordering lunch with friends, catering for the office, or enjoying a late-night snack, we’re here with fast service, extended hours, and the authentic taste you’ll love.
📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States
📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937
📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com
🛒 Order Online
Order Now
🕕 Opening Hours:
Mon – Sun: 6:00 AM – 2:00 AM
👉 [Order Now] and enjoy the best bagels Jamaica Plain has to offer—fresh, flavorful, and made just for you!