Fresh Baked Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

If you’re searching for fresh baked bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA, look no further than NY Bagel & Coffee Co, where authentic flavor meets tradition. We bring the iconic taste of New York–style bagels to the heart of Boston, offering locals, students, and families the perfect start to their day.

Our bagels are hand-rolled, boiled, and baked fresh every morning to achieve that classic chewy inside and crisp golden crust. From plain and sesame to everything and multigrain, each bite delivers true quality. Pair your favorite bagel with our wide selection of cream cheese spreads, hearty breakfast sandwiches, or freshly brewed coffee for a complete and satisfying meal.

We also take pride in catering to all dietary preferences with vegan-friendly and health-conscious options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a delicious breakfast or brunch. Whether you’re on your morning commute, enjoying a weekend brunch with friends, or ordering catering for an office meeting, we make sure every order is prepared fresh and served with care.

At NY Bagel & Coffee Co, bagels aren’t just breakfast—they’re a daily ritual. Stop by today and taste why we’re a local favorite in Jamaica Plain and Greater Boston.

Restaurant Info

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

✅ Why Choose Our Bagel Shop in Jamaica Plain, MA?

When residents of Jamaica Plain crave authentic bagels, they look for freshness, flavor, and convenience. At NY Bagel & Coffee Co, we deliver all of that and more. Here’s why locals love us:

🥯 Authentic New York–Style Bagels
Every bagel is hand-rolled, boiled, and baked daily, giving you that perfect chewy bite with a crisp golden crust—just like in New York.

🌱 Fresh & Wholesome Ingredients
We only use high-quality flour, fresh toppings, and rich spreads. From classic cream cheese to fresh vegetables, every ingredient is carefully sourced for taste and quality.

☕ Coffee & Breakfast Done Right
Our menu isn’t just bagels—we also serve freshly brewed coffee, cappuccinos, lattes, and hearty breakfast sandwiches to make your mornings complete.

🌍 Options for Everyone
From vegan tofu spreads to multigrain and whole wheat bagels, our menu is designed to be inclusive for every lifestyle and dietary preference.

🚴 Fast Takeout & Delivery in Jamaica Plain
Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast on the way to work or ordering delivery for your family, we ensure your food arrives hot, fresh, and right on time.

👨‍👩‍👧 Trusted by Families, Students & Professionals
Affordable, filling, and always consistent—our bagels have become a daily ritual for locals, making us a community favorite in Jamaica Plain and beyond.

📍 Fresh Baked Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA & Nearby Areas

At NY Bagel & Coffee Co, our convenient Boston location allows us to serve fresh bagels, coffee, and breakfast across Jamaica Plain and Greater Boston. Here’s a look at the nearby neighborhoods and cities we proudly serve:

🥯 Bagels in Roxbury, MA – Just minutes from Jamaica Plain, Roxbury residents enjoy our hot bagels and coffee, making us a favorite stop for commuters and students.

🥯 Bagels in Brookline, MA – Families and professionals in Brookline love our weekend brunch options, catering platters, and fresh New York–style bagels.

🥯 Bagels in Dorchester, MA – From busy mornings to family breakfasts, Dorchester locals count on our bagels and breakfast sandwiches for a fresh, filling start to the day.

🥯 Bagels in Roslindale, MA – Our freshly baked bagels and vegan spreads are a hit in Roslindale, where families and young professionals love our quick delivery.

🥯 Bagels in Mission Hill, MA – Popular with students from nearby colleges, our bagels and coffee make the perfect grab-and-go breakfast in Mission Hill.

🥯 Bagels in Hyde Park, MA – Residents of Hyde Park enjoy our catering platters for office meetings and events, as well as fresh takeout for family brunches.

🥯 Bagels in Mattapan, MA – From everything bagels to classic cream cheese, Mattapan locals rely on us for hot, oven-fresh bagels delivered daily.

🥯 Bagels in West Roxbury, MA – Known for hearty breakfast sandwiches and coffee, our bagels are a weekend favorite for families in West Roxbury.

🥯 Bagels in Allston, MA – Students and young professionals in Allston love our affordable bagel sandwiches, fresh coffee, and easy online ordering.

🥯 Bagels in Brighton, MA – Just next door, Brighton customers stop by daily for classic New York–style bagels, coffee, and quick breakfast takeout.

🥯 Bagels in South Boston, MA – South Boston locals trust us for reliable delivery, bringing fresh bagels and coffee straight to their doorstep every morning.

🥯 Bagels in Back Bay, Boston, MA – Professionals in Back Bay love our convenient bagel and coffee combos, perfect for busy workdays and office catering.

🥯 Bagels in Fenway–Kenmore, MA – With so many students nearby, our bagels are a top choice for late-morning brunches and energizing coffee before classes.

🥯 Bagels in Cambridge, MA – Harvard and MIT students, along with local families, choose our bagels for an authentic New York taste right in Cambridge.

🥯 Bagels in Somerville, MA – Known for quick delivery, we’re a go-to spot for Somerville residents who crave hot bagels, hearty spreads, and strong coffee.

🥯 Bagels in Medford, MA – Medford locals enjoy our fresh-baked bagels with vegan and multigrain options, making us a hit among health-conscious customers.

🥯 Bagels in Newton, MA – Families and professionals in Newton love our catering services, with bagels, spreads, and coffee perfect for gatherings.

🥯 Bagels in Quincy, MA – From morning commuters to weekend brunches, Quincy residents count on us for oven-fresh bagels and delicious breakfast sandwiches.

🥯 Bagels in Chelsea, MA – Our freshly baked bagels and rich coffee keep Chelsea customers coming back for breakfast and easy takeout options.

🍱 Popular Bagels & Sandwiches at NY Bagel & Coffee Co

Our bagels and sandwiches are baked fresh daily, hand-crafted for authentic flavor, and made to satisfy every craving. Here are some of our customer favorites:

🥯 Popular Bagels

Plain Bagel – A classic New York–style bagel with a chewy center and golden-brown crust. Simple, timeless, and perfect any time of day.
💲3.10

Everything Bagel – Topped with sesame, poppy, garlic, onion, and salt for bold flavor in every bite. A customer favorite.
💲3.10

Sesame Bagel – Soft and chewy inside with toasted sesame seeds on top for a nutty, satisfying crunch.
💲3.10

Asiago Bagel – Rich, cheesy flavor baked into every bite with melted asiago for a savory bagel experience.
💲3.10

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel – Sweet cinnamon swirls with plump raisins for a warm, comforting taste.
💲3.10

Onion Bagel – Topped with savory onion pieces, adding a flavorful kick to this classic bagel.
💲3.10

Whole Wheat Bagel – A hearty, fiber-rich bagel with nutty flavor, perfect for a healthier start to the day.
💲3.10

Multigrain Bagel – Packed with grains and seeds, this wholesome bagel is a filling, nutritious option.
💲3.10

🥪 Bagel Sandwiches – Breakfast

1 Gordon Street: Bagel & Cream Cheese – Fresh-baked bagel topped with smooth cream cheese. A simple classic.
💲5.45

2 Chester Street: Make Your Own Breakfast Sandwich – Build your perfect sandwich with fresh eggs, spreads, and toppings.
💲9.99

3 Braintree Street – Egg whites, cream cheese, avocado, tomato, cucumber, sprouts & Parmesan Peppercorn dressing.
💲10.25

4 Ashford Street – Eggs, cream cheese, ham, turkey, cucumber, tomato, sprouts, feta & black pepper.
💲10.99

5 Adamson Street – Eggs, chive cream cheese, turkey, bacon, cheddar, swiss & honey Dijon.
💲10.45

6 Alcott Street – Eggs, veggie spread, bacon, roast beef, American cheese & BBQ sauce.
💲10.45

7 Everett Street – Eggs, sausage, ham, chive smear, provolone & chipotle mayo.
💲10.45

8 Alcorn Street – Eggs, jalapeño smear, sausage, bacon, cheddar, tomato, jalapeños & spicy sauce.
💲10.45

9 Kelton Street – Smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, cucumber, onions, sprouts & capers.
💲13.45

10 Armington Street – Acme smoked salmon, salmon spread, lettuce, onion, cucumber, sprouts & peppercorn dressing.
💲14.99

11 Cambridge Street – Choice of bagel, eggs or egg whites, and cheese (cheddar, provolone, swiss, or American).
💲8.45

11a Yellow River White Fish Salad – Bagel filled with white fish salad, tomato, onion, capers & cracked black pepper.
💲13.99

11b Amur River Tuna Salad – Tuna salad, tomato, onion, capers, mozzarella & chili paste on a fresh bagel.
💲13.99

🌱 Bagel Sandwiches – Vegan

12 Franklin Street – Vegan spread, cheddar, banana peppers, cucumber, tomato, lettuce, avocado & mustard.
💲12.99

13 Fuller Street – Vegan spread, sausage, cheddar, peppers, onion, jalapeños, lettuce & spicy sauce.
💲11.99

14 Holman Street – Hummus, tomato, lettuce, sprouts, banana peppers & avocado.
💲11.99

15 Holmes Street – Hummus, vegan spread, sausage, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, jalapeño & BBQ sauce.
💲12.99

16 Mansfield Street – Fig jam, vegan cream cheese, berries & vegan honey. Sweet and fruity!
💲12.99

17 Holton Street – Vegan cream cheese, Nutella, strawberries, blueberries & powdered sugar.
💲12.99

🧀 Bagel Sandwiches – Vegetarian

18 Ridgemont Street – Cream cheese, cucumber, pepper, lettuce, onion, tomato, provolone, pepper spread & ranch.
💲12.99

19 Riverdale Street – Gouda, Havarti, provolone, parmesan, plant-based sausage & chipotle mayo.
💲13.99

20 Wilton Street – Chive cream cheese, jalapeños, avocado, veggies, Dill Havarti, mustard & sea salt chips.
💲12.99

21 Windom Street – Mozzarella, pesto, tomato, lettuce & balsamic vinaigrette.
💲12.99

22 Arthur Street – Veggie cream cheese, Dill Havarti, onion, peppers, tomato, sprouts, avocado & peppercorn dressing.
💲12.99

🛵 Bagel Delivery & Takeout in Jamaica Plain, MA

When the craving for fresh-baked bagels, hearty breakfast sandwiches, or a coffee pick-me-up strikes, NY Bagel & Coffee Co makes it easy with fast, reliable delivery and takeout across Jamaica Plain and nearby Boston neighborhoods. Every order is prepared fresh and handled with care so you can enjoy the same quality at home, at work, or on the go.

✅ Hot, Fresh & Oven-Baked Daily
Our bagels are hand-rolled, boiled, and baked fresh every morning. Whether you’re ordering a plain bagel, a salmon sandwich, or a vegan option, you’ll always receive it hot, soft, and delicious.

✅ Secure, Eco-Friendly Packaging
From bagels and spreads to iced coffee, every order is packed with sturdy, spill-proof containers to keep food warm and drinks safe until they reach you. No mess, no soggy bagels—just bakery-fresh taste.

✅ Perfect for Breakfast, Brunch & Catering
Need a quick grab-and-go breakfast? Hosting an office meeting? Planning a family brunch? Our delivery and takeout menu includes bagel platters, spreads, and beverages to suit any occasion.

✅ Vegetarian, Vegan & Health-Friendly Choices
We proudly serve multigrain, whole wheat, and vegan bagels, plus plant-based spreads and sandwiches. Everyone—no matter their diet—can enjoy our menu with confidence.

✅ Easy Online Ordering Anytime
Ordering is quick and stress-free. Simply visit our online ordering page, select your favorites, and choose takeout or delivery. Breakfast made simple, wherever you are.

🏆 Why NY Bagel & Coffee Co Is the Best in Jamaica Plain

✅ 1) True New York–Style, Done Right
Hand-rolled, boiled, and baked fresh daily for that iconic chewy interior and crisp golden crust. Every bagel starts with time-tested technique, not shortcuts—so the flavor and texture are spot-on every single morning.

✅ 2) Always Fresh, Made to Order
From plain to everything to cinnamon raisin, your bagel is sliced, schmear’d, and built when you order. Breakfast sandwiches are cooked to order so the eggs stay fluffy, the cheese melts perfectly, and the bagel stays warm and toasty.

✅ 3) Deep Menu + Easy Customization
Pick classics or go signature with our street-named sandwiches (Kelton, Ashford, Adamson & more). Swap bagels, choose your cheese, add veggies or sauces—your perfect combo is a couple of clicks away and tastes exactly how you like it.

✅ 4) Vegan & Health-Friendly Choices
Multigrain and whole-wheat bagels, dairy-free schmears, and plant-based sausage mean everyone at the table eats well. (We don’t offer certified gluten-free bagels, but we do have lighter, wholesome alternatives that still deliver great flavor.)

✅ 5) Coffee Program That Completes Breakfast
Freshly brewed coffee, iced coffee, lattes, and cappuccinos are dialed in to pair with bagels and sandwiches. Smooth, balanced, and barista-made—your caffeine and carb fix arrive perfectly in sync.

✅ 6) Designed for Delivery, Takeout & Catering
Spill-safe, heat-holding packaging keeps bagels warm and beverages secure. Whether it’s a solo breakfast, family brunch, or office platter, online ordering makes pickup and delivery across Jamaica Plain fast and reliable.

✅ 7) Generous Portions, Fair Prices, Friendly Vibes
Hearty sandwiches, quality ingredients, and pricing that respects your budget. Our team keeps lines moving with a smile—one reason families, students, and professionals in JP make us their daily ritual.

⭐ Customer Testimonials – Best Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

At NY Bagel & Coffee Co, we’re proud to be the go-to spot for fresh baked bagels and coffee in Jamaica Plain. Here’s what our happy customers are saying:

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel P. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“I stop by here almost every morning before work. Their plain bagel with veggie cream cheese is always fresh, soft inside, and perfectly toasted. The coffee is just as good, making it my favorite breakfast stop in JP.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Marcus T. – Roxbury, MA
“I ordered a catering platter for my office and everyone was blown away by the variety. From asiago bagels to smoked salmon sandwiches, everything was flavorful and neatly packed. Will definitely order again for meetings.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sophia D. – Brookline, MA
“As someone from New York, I’m picky about bagels. These are the real deal! The chewy texture and golden crust are authentic. The lox bagel was outstanding—made me feel like I was back home.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
David K. – Boston, MA
“Ordered delivery for brunch, and my food arrived warm, fresh, and beautifully packaged. The Franklin Street vegan sandwich was full of flavor and filling. This place is my go-to for weekends.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Priya S. – Dorchester, MA
“I love that they offer whole wheat and multigrain options. As someone who prefers healthier choices, I never feel limited here. Their veggie-packed bagels are both wholesome and tasty.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
John L. – Mission Hill, MA
“Their 5-Adamson Street sandwich is incredible—eggs, turkey, bacon, cheese, and honey Dijon all packed into one hearty bagel. It kept me full all morning. Portions are generous too!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Emily R. – Roslindale, MA
“My kids adore the cinnamon raisin bagels, and I can’t get enough of the jalapeño cheddar options. It’s rare to find a bagel shop with so many choices that everyone in the family is happy.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Carlos M. – Allston, MA
“Quick service, friendly staff, and some of the best iced coffee I’ve had around Boston. Paired with a fresh everything bagel, it’s the perfect grab-and-go breakfast for my busy mornings.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Nina G. – Hyde Park, MA
“I’m vegan, and finding plant-based breakfast options can be tough. Their Holman Street sandwich with hummus, avocado, and sprouts is my absolute favorite. Delicious and guilt-free!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
James H. – Cambridge, MA
“Every time I order from NY Bagel & Coffee Co, the food is consistent, flavorful, and fresh. From classic plain with cream cheese to the smoked salmon special, the quality never disappoints.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – Fresh Baked Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

At NY Bagel & Coffee Co, we want every customer in Jamaica Plain to enjoy a smooth and delicious experience—whether you’re dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery. Here are answers to the most common questions:

Do you offer bagel delivery in Jamaica Plain?
✅ Yes! We deliver hot, fresh bagels and coffee throughout Jamaica Plain and nearby areas including Roxbury, Brookline, Dorchester, and Roslindale. Orders are carefully packed to ensure everything arrives warm, fresh, and ready to enjoy.
How do I place an order online?
✅ It’s easy! Just visit our online ordering page, choose your bagels, sandwiches, or coffee, and checkout for delivery or takeout. Ordering ahead saves time and guarantees your bagel is ready when you are.
Are your bagels baked fresh daily?
✅ Absolutely! Every bagel is hand-rolled, boiled, and baked each morning for authentic New York–style taste. We never use frozen or pre-made dough, so you always get that perfect chewy inside and golden crust.
Do you have vegetarian and vegan options?
✅ Yes! We offer a variety of vegetarian and vegan-friendly choices, including hummus bagels, plant-based sausage sandwiches, dairy-free spreads, and whole wheat or multigrain bagels.
Can I customize my bagel sandwich?
✅ Definitely. You can choose your bagel base, pick eggs or egg whites, add cheese, spreads, veggies, or protein. Our menu is designed to give you full flexibility to build the bagel sandwich you’re craving.
Do you provide catering for offices or events?
✅ Yes! We specialize in catering platters with bagels, cream cheese spreads, sandwiches, and fresh coffee. Perfect for office breakfasts, college gatherings, or family events in Jamaica Plain and Greater Boston.
What beverages do you serve with bagels?
✅ Alongside our bagels, we serve freshly brewed coffee, lattes, cappuccinos, iced coffee, and fresh-squeezed orange juice. Each is crafted to perfectly complement your bagel or breakfast sandwich.
Do you have healthy or gluten-friendly choices?
✅ We offer whole wheat and multigrain bagels as nutritious options. While we don’t bake certified gluten-free bagels, many of our sandwiches and spreads are lighter and health-friendly for mindful eaters.
Can I schedule my bagel order in advance?
✅ Yes! You can pre-schedule your takeout or delivery online. This is especially convenient for office meetings, weekend brunches, or making sure your morning order is ready right when you need it.
What makes NY Bagel & Coffee Co stand out from other bagel shops?
✅ Unlike many bakeries, we specialize in true New York–style bagels, baked fresh daily, paired with a wide menu of vegan, vegetarian, and hearty options. Add in fast delivery, friendly service, and top-quality coffee, and it’s easy to see why locals trust us.

📞 Visit or Order Today