🥯 Best Cream Cheese Spreads in Allston, MA

Looking for the best bagel spreads in Allston? You’ve found your spot. At New York Bagel & Coffee Co, we take our schmears seriously—crafting bold, creamy, flavor-packed options that elevate any bagel, sandwich, or snack.

Whether you’re craving the spice of jalapeño, the luxury of smoked salmon, or a sweet strawberry indulgence, we’ve got a schmear for every palate. Made fresh and served with love, our spreads are the secret to the perfect bite—day or night.

Located near Harvard Ave, just steps from BU campus and Packard’s Corner, we’re your neighborhood go-to for the most flavorful spreads in town. Fast pickup, friendly service, and mouthwatering options await.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🌟 Why Allston Locals Love Our Spreads & Schmears

Big flavors, bold choices

From chive and veggie to strawberry and smoked fish, our spread lineup is built for flavor lovers who don’t settle for boring. Each one is smooth, satisfying, and freshly prepped daily.

Perfect pairings for bagels & beyond

Toast up an everything bagel or stack your breakfast sandwich—our spreads go great with anything. Pro tip: try jalapeño cream cheese with your bacon-egg-cheddar combo.

Vegan & dairy-free options

Going plant-based? Our vegan cream cheese delivers the same rich texture and taste as the classic—no dairy, no compromise.

Convenient, quick, and delicious

Whether you’re rushing between classes or grabbing breakfast before work, our grab-and-go system means your order’s ready fast—and always fresh.

Catering & custom trays available

Hosting a meeting, brunch, or weekend hang? Build a bagel tray with our most-loved spreads, from lox cream cheese to white fish salad. Allston-approved and share-ready.

🧁 Spreads & Schmears Menu – Allston Favorites

Chives Spread – $10.45

A creamy, herb-forward delight made with fresh-cut chives. Adds a mild zing and smooth finish—perfect on a warm, toasted everything bagel.

Smoked Salmon / Lox (for two sandwiches) – $11.45

Delicately sliced, premium-quality lox that brings a buttery texture and ocean-fresh flavor. Ideal for building the classic New York bagel sandwich.

Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese – $11.45

A rich, velvety cream cheese infused with savory smoked salmon—for those who love a deep, briny bite with creamy undertones.

Jalapeño Cream Cheese – $10.45

Turn up the heat! This smooth and spicy schmear delivers a jalapeño kick that pairs beautifully with bagels, breakfast sandwiches, or wraps.

Strawberry Cream Cheese – $10.45

Sweet, fruity, and silky-smooth, this strawberry-infused cream cheese is a fan favorite for both morning indulgence and sweet snack moments.

Mixed Vegetables Cream Cheese – $10.45

Colorful, crunchy, and flavor-packed, this veggie-loaded spread is both wholesome and delicious. A go-to for garden lovers.

Acme White Fish Salad – $12.99

Crafted with care, this light and flaky white fish salad offers a delicate seafood flavor—amazing on a toasted bagel or as a protein-packed dip.

Albacore Wild Tuna Smoked Salad – $12.99

Made with wild-caught albacore tuna and a hint of smokiness, this salad is nutritious, savory, and great on rye or whole wheat.

Plain Cream Cheese – $7.99

Simple, classic, and endlessly versatile. This smooth, rich spread complements everything from sesame bagels to bacon-egg sandwiches.

Vegan Cream Cheese – $10.75

A plant-based alternative that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture. Perfect for dairy-free diets, with a luxuriously creamy mouthfeel.

💬 What Our Customers Are Saying – Allston Edition

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Lena G. – Harvard Ave

“The chive spread here is absolutely unreal. I always get it on a warm, toasty everything bagel, and it hits every time—herby, creamy, and packed with fresh flavor. Best part? They never skimp on the schmear. It’s generous and perfectly balanced—makes my mornings.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Marcus T. – BU Student Village

“The jalapeño cream cheese is my go-to spread. It’s got just the right level of spice—bold, not overwhelming—and pairs perfectly with a bacon and egg bagel sandwich. You can tell they care about flavor. These guys know how to build a bagel.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Sophie M. – Brighton Ave

“As a vegan, I’ve tried a lot of plant-based cream cheeses, but theirs is seriously next level. The vegan cream cheese is smooth, rich, and honestly better than most dairy versions I’ve had. Huge bonus that they actually make it taste indulgent.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Noah B. – Packard’s Corner

“I keep coming back for the smoked salmon cream cheese—it’s rich, silky, and full of savory depth. I use it not only on my bagels, but also as a dip at home. It’s one of those flavors you start craving randomly. Totally worth every cent.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jess K. – Commonwealth Ave

“I hosted a brunch and picked up their veggie cream cheese and white fish salad—both were total hits. Everything tasted fresh, homemade, and flavorful. My guests couldn’t stop asking where I got it. A true Allston hidden gem for entertaining or treating yourself.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Alex R. – Allston Village

“Their strawberry cream cheese is everything I want in a sweet spread. It’s not too sugary or artificial—just creamy, fruity perfection. Slathered on a toasted cinnamon raisin bagel, it’s my weekend favorite. Comfort food with a twist.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Priya N. – BU East

“As someone who eats mostly vegetarian, I love how many dairy-free and meat-free options they offer. The lox is always fresh and high quality when I do indulge. Super appreciate the variety—it makes eating here easy and exciting.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jared P. – Boston Landing

“The tuna salad here doesn’t get enough hype. It’s smoky, rich, and absolutely loaded with flavor—makes an unforgettable bagel sandwich. One bite and you’ll wonder why you haven’t been ordering it all along. Low-key one of their best.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Emily C. – Brighton

“Fast service, friendly faces, and consistently flavorful food. I grab a plain cream cheese bagel almost every morning and it never disappoints. Toasted just right with a hearty spread—it’s become a part of my daily rhythm.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Daniel S. – Union Square

“This place nails the NYC bagel experience. Chewy bagels with a crisp crust, and spreads that are packed with flavor. My holy trinity? Chive, Jalapeño, and Lox cream cheeses. If you’re in Allston, you won’t find better.”

🧂 Spreads & Schmears – FAQs (Allston)

Are your spreads made in-house daily?

Yes! All our cream cheese spreads and salads are made fresh in-house every day to ensure maximum flavor, quality, and creaminess. You’ll taste the difference from the very first bite.

What’s the difference between lox and smoked salmon cream cheese?

Great question! Our lox (smoked salmon slices) are served whole, perfect for building sandwiches, while our smoked salmon cream cheese blends that savory fish directly into a rich, velvety spread.

Is the vegan cream cheese really dairy-free?

Absolutely. Our vegan cream cheese contains no dairy, no lactose, and no animal products—just a creamy, satisfying texture and clean flavor that’s perfect for any plant-based diet.

Are there gluten-free options to pair with your spreads?

While our bagels contain gluten, we offer gluten-free alternatives such as sliced cucumbers or lettuce wraps upon request—ideal for enjoying spreads like our white fish or tuna salad without the bread.

Can I get more than one spread on the same bagel?

Yes! You can mix and match two spreads on one bagel—like half jalapeño, half chive—or even build a layered sandwich with different textures and flavors. Just ask when you order.

Do you offer schmear trays for catering or brunch parties?

We do! Our spread & bagel trays are perfect for gatherings—whether you’re hosting brunch, a baby shower, or a BU study group. Choose up to 4 spreads and pair them with a variety of sliced bagels.

What is the most popular spread at your Allston location?

It’s a tie between our jalapeño cream cheese for spice lovers and smoked salmon cream cheese for those craving a rich, savory bagel experience. But honestly? They all have a fan following.

Are the veggie and chive spreads vegetarian-friendly?

Yes—both our Mixed Vegetable and Chives cream cheese spreads are 100% vegetarian and made without any animal byproducts.

Can I buy spreads to-go without ordering a bagel?

Definitely. All of our spreads are available in 8 oz containers to-go—perfect for stocking your fridge or bringing to a brunch. Just ask for it at the counter or order online.

What makes your spreads better than store-bought brands?

Freshness, flavor, and creativity. Unlike mass-produced brands, our spreads are hand-mixed daily, made with real ingredients, and designed to pair perfectly with our bagels and sandwiches. One bite and you’ll know it’s not from a tub.

📢 Let’s Get Schmearing – Allston Style

Whether you’re starting your day, hosting a brunch, or just craving something creamy and bold, NY Bagel & Coffee Co in Allston has the spread for you. From sweet to spicy to seafood-rich, our schmears are made fresh, packed with flavor, and served fast.

Stop by near Harvard Ave or order ahead for pickup and delivery across Allston, Brighton, and the BU campus.

Great bagels are just the start—come for the spreads. 🥯