Best NY Bagels in Fenway, Boston – Freshly Baked Daily

When you think of the best NY bagels in Fenway, Boston, there’s one name that stands out — NY Bagel and Coffee Co.

Located just minutes from Fenway Park, this local favorite brings the authentic New York bagel experience right to Boston. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, ensuring that every bite delivers the perfect balance of crunch and chew. Pair it with rich espresso or cold brew, and you’ve got the ultimate Fenway breakfast.

If you’ve been searching for “authentic NY bagels near Fenway Park”, “best bagels in Boston MA”, or “bagel breakfast near me in Fenway” — your search ends here.

🏪 About NY Bagel and Coffee Co

Name: NY Bagel and Coffee Co
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134 (Serving Fenway, Boston & nearby areas)
Phone: +1 617-870-7937
Website: ny-bagel-coffee-co.square.site

At NY Bagel and Coffee Co, we’re proud to serve Boston’s most authentic New York–style bagels to Fenway locals, students, and visitors. Each bagel is crafted by hand, boiled to perfection, and baked using traditional NY techniques.

Our goal is simple — to make sure Fenway residents and Boston commuters can enjoy the true taste of New York without ever leaving Massachusetts.

🥯 Why Locals Call Us the Best NY Bagels in Fenway

Here’s why we’re the go-to destination for authentic NY bagels near Fenway Park and Kenmore Square:

🥯 Authentic NY Recipe: We hand-roll, kettle-boil, and bake our bagels daily following old-school New York methods.
🧈 Premium Ingredients: From unbleached flour to pure malt syrup — every bagel is made from scratch using quality ingredients.
☕ Perfect Coffee Pairings: Enjoy bagels with our freshly brewed espresso, cold brew, or signature caramel latte — roasted locally in Boston.
🥓 Made-to-Order Bagel Sandwiches: Choose from Bacon Egg & Cheese, Avocado Egg, or Lox Bagels — made fresh for breakfast or lunch.
🏙️ Ideal Fenway Location: Just minutes from Fenway Park, BU, and Kenmore Square — perfect for fans, students, and professionals.
🚚 Delivery & Pickup Ready: Whether you’re in Fenway, Back Bay, Brookline, or Cambridge, we deliver NY-style bagels right to your door.
💛 Local & Family-Owned: We’re a community café that values hospitality and handcrafted food — not a chain.

🍩 Our Most Loved Menu Items

Boston loves our bagels — here’s what Fenway locals and Red Sox fans can’t stop ordering:

🥯 Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese – Crispy, flavorful, and loaded with sesame, garlic, and onion.
🥓 Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel – A classic NY breakfast favorite that fuels Fenway mornings.
🍳 Avocado Egg Bagel Sandwich – A healthy and satisfying option for Boston students and gym-goers.
🐟 Lox Bagel Sandwich – Smoked salmon, cream cheese, and red onion — a timeless NYC combination.
🍩 Blueberry & Cinnamon Raisin Bagels – Sweet, soft, and ideal for a quick snack near Fenway Park.
🧇 Belgian Waffles & Pastries – Perfect for dessert lovers or coffee breaks.
☕ Iced Caramel Latte & Mocha Cold Brew – Local favorites for Boston’s busy mornings.

Whether you’re walking to Fenway Park, studying near Boston University, or working in Kenmore Square, our NY-style bagels are the perfect grab-and-go meal.

🚚 Easy Online Ordering: Delivery & Pickup Options

Skip the line — order your bagels online for fast delivery or pickup anywhere in Fenway, Boston, or nearby neighborhoods.

🛵 Order NY Bagels for Delivery

We’ve partnered with top delivery platforms so you can enjoy our bagels hot and fresh:
👉 DoorDash – NY Bagel and Coffee Co
👉 UberEats – NY Bagel and Coffee Co
👉 ChowNow – NY Bagel and Coffee Co

🧾 Pickup Your Order Fresh

Order ahead and skip the wait — your bagel will be ready when you arrive.
👉 Order Online at ny-bagel-coffee-co.square.site

We’re just a short drive from Fenway Park, Brookline Avenue, and Boston University, making us a convenient stop for locals, visitors, and students alike.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Reviews from Our Local Customers

1️⃣ “Real NY Bagels in Fenway that taste just like Manhattan!”

The Everything Bagel in Fenway is crisp on the outside and chewy inside, delivering authentic New York flavor. Maria loved the fast and warm bagel delivery in Fenway, Boston, making it her go-to breakfast spot. Locals searching for fresh NY bagels near Fenway Park frequently rave about this café.
– Maria L., Fenway, Boston

2️⃣ “My go-to breakfast before class at Northeastern”

Ryan visits NY Bagel and Coffee Co in Fenway almost every morning. The Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel with Iced Latte is a perfect start to a busy day. Quick pickup and friendly staff make it one of the best NY-style bagels near Northeastern University in Fenway, Boston.
– Ryan P., Fenway, Boston

3️⃣ “The best Everything Bagel in Fenway – perfect every time”

Sophia has tried bagels across Back Bay, Kenmore, and Fenway, but nothing compares to this authentic NY bagel experience in Boston. Whether for delivery or pickup, the flavor and freshness are unmatched. Fenway locals consistently call it the top NY bagel shop near Kenmore Square.
– Sophia M., Back Bay

4️⃣ “Authentic NY flavor brought to Fenway”

Liam orders via DoorDash for Fenway delivery regularly. The Lox Bagel Sandwich arrives fresh, flavorful, and never soggy. For anyone searching for fresh NY-style bagels in Fenway or nearby Back Bay, this café brings Manhattan taste straight to Boston.
– Liam S., Fenway

5️⃣ “Hidden gem near Fenway Park”

Anya calls this café a Fenway Park favorite. The Blueberry Bagel with Cream Cheese paired with Caramel Latte has become her weekend ritual. Perfect for both locals and visitors searching for best bagels near Fenway Park, Boston, this hidden gem combines taste, freshness, and convenience.
– Anya F., Fenway, Boston

6️⃣ “Perfect breakfast spot for Fenway commuters”

James picks up his Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese before heading to work near Kenmore Square. The café’s fresh NY bagels in Fenway and speedy service make it a top choice for commuters, students, and Boston locals who want a quick, authentic New York breakfast.
– James R., Fenway

7️⃣ “NY Bagels with unmatched freshness in Fenway”

Samantha loves ordering the Avocado & Egg Bagel Sandwich for pickup in Fenway. With crispy crust, chewy center, and premium ingredients, it’s the best option for those searching for authentic NY-style bagels near Fenway Park or bagel delivery in Boston.
– Samantha T., Fenway

8️⃣ “Great bagels for office meetings in Fenway”

Our team regularly orders bagels for morning meetings in Fenway. The Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel and Lox Bagel Sandwich are always fresh, and delivery is punctual. Perfect for anyone searching for NY bagel catering in Fenway, Boston, or fresh bagels near Kenmore Square.
– Derek J., Fenway

9️⃣ “Neighborhood favorite for students and locals”

Emma stops by for her Blueberry Bagel and Iced Latte almost every morning. As one of the most authentic NY bagels in Fenway, it’s highly recommended for students from Northeastern University and locals who crave a genuine Manhattan bagel experience in Boston.
– Emma P., Fenway

🔟 “The ultimate NY bagel spot in Fenway”

Mark orders a dozen bagels for family and friends from this Fenway café. The Plain Bagel with Cream Cheese and Lox Sandwich are customer favorites. For anyone searching “fresh NY bagels near me in Fenway” or “best bagel delivery in Boston”, this is the ultimate stop.
– Mark S., Fenway

🗺️ Serving Fenway and Nearby Areas

We proudly serve:
Fenway, Kenmore, Back Bay, Boston University area, Cambridge, Brookline, and the Greater Boston area.

Searching for “fresh NY bagels near me in Fenway”, “bagel delivery in Boston”, or “best breakfast in Fenway MA”? You’ve found your new favorite spot.

❓ FAQs – Best NY Bagels in Fenway, Boston

Bagel Quality & Variety

1️⃣ Are your bagels really New York–style in Fenway, Boston?

Yes! Every bagel at NY Bagel and Coffee Co is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, just like in New York. Locals from Fenway, Kenmore, and Back Bay call them the most authentic NY bagels in Boston, with the perfect crispy crust and chewy center.

2️⃣ What’s the most popular NY bagel flavor in Fenway, Boston?

The Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese is a top favorite among Fenway residents. Other popular choices include the Lox Bagel Sandwich, Plain Bagel, and Avocado Egg Bagel, making it easy to find your perfect NY-style bagel near Fenway Park.

3️⃣ Do you offer vegan NY bagels in Fenway, Boston?

Yes! Our Plain, Sesame, and Cinnamon Raisin bagels are completely vegan and pair perfectly with dairy-free cream cheese. Fenway locals and students love having vegan bagel options in Boston without compromising on authentic NY bagel taste.

4️⃣ Are there gluten-free options in Fenway, Boston?

We are currently testing gluten-free bagels due to growing demand from Fenway and Back Bay customers. Our goal is to maintain the classic NY-style texture and flavor while offering safe and delicious gluten-free bagels in Boston.

5️⃣ What makes your bagels different from other Boston bagel shops?

Our bagels stand out for their authenticity and quality. Unlike many chain stores in Boston, we follow traditional New York boiling and baking methods, using premium ingredients, ensuring every bagel is fresh, flavorful, and truly NY-style in Fenway, Boston.

❓ Ordering & Delivery

6️⃣ Where can I order NY bagels online in Fenway, Boston?

You can easily order online via DoorDash, UberEats, or ChowNow. Simply search “NY Bagel and Coffee Co Fenway” to get your favorite fresh NY bagels delivered in Fenway, Kenmore, or Back Bay within minutes.

7️⃣ Do you offer pickup in Fenway, Boston?

Yes! Skip the line by ordering ahead at ny-bagel-coffee-co.square.site. Pickup is convenient for students, professionals, and Fenway residents, ensuring your fresh NY bagel breakfast in Boston is ready when you are.

8️⃣ Do you deliver to nearby areas like Back Bay or Kenmore?

Absolutely! Our delivery service covers Fenway, Kenmore, Back Bay, Cambridge, and nearby Boston neighborhoods. Enjoy fresh NY-style bagels from our café without leaving home or office.

9️⃣ How long does delivery take in Fenway, Boston?

On average, delivery takes 30–45 minutes depending on traffic. Our delivery partners ensure NY bagels in Fenway, Boston arrive warm and fresh for locals and students alike.

🔟 Is there a minimum order for NY bagel delivery in Fenway, Boston?

No minimum! Order one bagel or a full dozen and have it delivered anywhere in Fenway or nearby Boston neighborhoods. Perfect for breakfast, lunch, or office catering in Boston.

❓ Menu & Experience

1️⃣1️⃣ What beverages pair best with NY bagels in Fenway, Boston?

Pair your bagel with locally roasted coffee, espresso, or cold brew. Fenway favorites include the Caramel Latte and Mocha Cold Brew, perfect for enjoying your NY bagel breakfast in Boston.

1️⃣2️⃣ Do you offer catering in Fenway, Boston?

Yes! We provide bagel catering for offices, schools, and events in Fenway, Boston University, and nearby areas. Fresh NY-style bagels, sandwiches, and coffee make any event memorable.

1️⃣3️⃣ Can I customize my bagel sandwich in Fenway, Boston?

Absolutely! Choose your bagel base, fillings, and toppings to create the perfect NY-style bagel sandwich in Fenway. Our customization options are popular among students, commuters, and local families in Boston.

1️⃣4️⃣ Do you serve sweet treats in Fenway, Boston?

Yes — in addition to bagels, enjoy Belgian waffles, muffins, cookies, and pastries. Fenway locals love pairing sweet treats with freshly brewed coffee for breakfast or afternoon snacks in Boston.

1️⃣5️⃣ Are there combo meals or breakfast deals in Fenway, Boston?

Yes! Our bagel + coffee combos are a Fenway favorite, especially among students, professionals, and commuters. Enjoy fresh NY bagels with a perfect drink at great value in Boston.

❓ Location & Hours

1️⃣6️⃣ Where are you located in Fenway, Boston?

We’re at 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, just minutes from Fenway Park, Kenmore Square, and Boston University. A convenient spot for dine-in, pickup, or delivery of NY bagels in Fenway.

1️⃣7️⃣ What are your business hours in Fenway, Boston?

Open 7:00 AM to 5:00 PM daily, serving fresh NY bagels for breakfast, lunch, and coffee breaks to Fenway residents and visitors.

1️⃣8️⃣ Is there parking near your Fenway café?

Yes — both street and public parking are available. Fenway locals and students find it convenient for pickup of fresh NY bagels in Boston.

1️⃣9️⃣ Can I find NY Bagel and Coffee Co on Google Maps in Fenway, Boston?

Absolutely! Search “NY Bagel and Coffee Co Fenway” on Google Maps or Apple Maps for directions, reviews, and full menu details.

2️⃣0️⃣ Do you offer bulk or wholesale orders in Fenway, Boston?

Yes! We supply large orders for offices, schools, and local businesses in Fenway and Boston. Contact us via phone or email to place bulk NY bagel orders for events or daily needs.

📍 Visit or Order Today

Enjoy the freshest NY Bagels in Fenway, Boston at:

NY Bagel and Coffee Co
📍 Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States
📞 Phone: +1 617-870-7937
💻 Order Online: ny-bagel-coffee-co.square.site
🚚 Delivery Partners: DoorDash, UberEats, ChowNow

Whether you’re in Fenway, Back Bay, Kenmore, or Cambridge, NY Bagel and Coffee Co is your local home for fresh, authentic NY bagels baked daily with love.

Discover Authentic NY Bagels Across Massachusetts