NY Bagel and Coffee Co

đŸ„Ż Best Artisan Sandwich in Jamaica Plain, MA

Tucked into the heart of Jamaica Plain, New York Bagel & Coffee Co brings big-city flavor to one of Boston’s most laid-back, vibrant neighborhoods. From the first smell of fresh-baked bagels in the morning to the last lunch rush of the afternoon, we’re where locals stop when they want real food done right.

Whether you’re kicking off your day near Centre Street, fueling up after a jog around Jamaica Pond, or need a pick-me-up after a class at JP Centre/South, our shop is your neighborhood hub for artisan sandwiches, bold flavors, and rich, smooth coffee.

We’re known for:

  • Hand-rolled bagels baked fresh daily
  • Hearty sandwich builds stacked with premium meats, veggies, and house-made spreads
  • All-day breakfast and lunch that satisfies every craving
  • Quick service with a friendly JP vibe

Fast, flavorful, and unforgettable—this is your new go-to spot in JP.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

đŸ„Ș What Makes Our Sandwiches the Best in Jamaica Plain?

At New York Bagel & Coffee Co, we bring bold flavor and community spirit to every bite. Jamaica Plain isn’t just where we serve sandwiches—it’s where we celebrate flavor, freshness, and local vibes.

Here’s why JP locals keep coming back:

Handcrafted sandwiches layered on our daily fresh-baked, hand-rolled bagels

Premium meats like roast beef, grilled chicken, prosciutto, and crispy bacon

House-made spreads that pack a punch

Chipotle mayo, garlic aioli, and chive cream cheese

Plenty of plant-powered choices

From vegan bagels and sauces to creative vegetarian combos

Gluten-free options that don’t sacrifice flavor or texture

Perfect for any time of day

Grab-and-go mornings, midday work breaks, or a laid-back weekend brunch

Whether you’re walking the dog near Jamaica Pond, heading to Green Street Station, or meeting friends by Centre Street, we’re here to serve up sandwiches that are hot, hearty, and unforgettable.


📋 Signature Sandwiches Loved in JP

The Great Wall of China – $14.45

A bold, meaty masterpiece stacked with roast beef, pastrami, Swiss and Gouda cheeses, pickles, brown mustard, and creamy Russian dressing—delivering a savory, smoky, and tangy flavor punch in every bite.

Dragon Boat – $13.99

A hearty combo of turkey breast, bacon, and American cheese, topped with crisp lettuce, banana peppers, and spicy horseradish sauce—finished with golden tater tots for a fun, crunchy finish.

The Yellow Mountains – $14.45

Savor the smoky goodness of pastrami and bacon, with sweet red onions, Muenster cheese, fresh tomato, sprouts, and spicy boom boom sauce—a fiery twist on a classic deli-style sandwich.

The Pearl River – $15.99

Flavor flows with juicy chicken breast, crispy bacon, smooth chive cream cheese, grilled onions and peppers, tangy banana peppers, and a mix of provolone and Muenster—topped with boom boom sauce and crunchy sea salt chips.

The Shanghai Tower – $14.99

Stacked high with savory prosciutto, crispy bacon, sautĂ©ed onions and peppers, provolone, Swiss, and Parmesan, plus fresh lettuce, sprouts, tomato, and bold chipotle mayo—a skyscraper of flavor.

Lantern – $14.45

A trio of deli favorites—roast beef, turkey, and bacon—layered with melted Swiss and cheddar, crisp lettuce, tomato, and smoky chipotle mayo for a rich, savory bite.

The West Lake – $15.99

A spicy and creamy fusion of roast beef, ham, jalapeño cream cheese, grilled onions and peppers, smooth provolone and Gouda, with fresh tomato, lettuce, red pepper paste, and crispy chips.

Laba – $14.45

Indulge in layers of roast beef, ham, and bacon with creamy Dill Havarti, nutty Gouda, crisp lettuce, crunchy pickles, spicy jalapeños, and a tangy Parmesan peppercorn dressing.

Nu River – $15.99

A bold mix of chicken, roast beef, zesty chive cream cheese, smooth Dill Havarti, sweet and spicy peppers, banana peppers, smoky BBQ sauce, and pepper paste—topped with crunchy chips.

The Nanya River – $15.99

A savory blend of prosciutto, chicken, and bacon, with creamy plain cream cheese, tangy feta, nutty Parmesan, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, red onion, and smoky chipotle mayo.

Double Ninth – $14.45

Packed with layers of turkey, pepperoni, and roast beef, plus sweet onions, bold Swiss and smoked cheddar, tied together with tangy brown mustard and creamy ranch dressing.

Spring – $14.45

A fresh and hearty mix of turkey, pork sausage, creamy plain cream cheese, shredded Parmesan, crisp lettuce, sprouts, juicy tomato, and flavorful red pepper spread—perfect for lighter appetites.


💬 What JP Customers Are Saying

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Alexa G. – Jamaica Plain

“I always stop here after my morning walks around Jamaica Pond. Their Pearl River sandwich is next-level—savory, fresh, and super filling. Pair it with an iced latte and it’s the perfect start to the day. JP needed a spot like this!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Dan L. – Hyde Square

“This has quickly become my go-to lunch spot. The vibe is relaxed, the service is quick, and the Shanghai Tower sandwich? Absolute fire. So much flavor, so well balanced—it hits every time. Glad it’s walking distance!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Maria V. – Centre Street

“I’m vegetarian and I never feel limited here. They’ve got so many bold plant-based options that actually taste amazing. Bonus points for the friendly, fast staff—they remember your name and your order. That’s what keeps me coming back.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jordan P. – Forest Hills

“Exactly what Jamaica Plain needed—real, satisfying food made with care. I recommend the Dragon Boat to everyone I know. It’s spicy, crispy, and super satisfying. You can tell they put thought into every sandwich.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rachel T. – Stony Brook

“Found this gem while walking home from the Stony Brook T stop—now I’m addicted. The East Village Veg is my go-to, and their cold brew is strong and smooth. It’s the perfect combo for busy mornings.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Cameron S. – JP Resident

“The outdoor seating is a game-changer in good weather. Great people-watching spot while I crush a bagel sandwich and scroll. Every bite feels fresh, and the staff always greets me with a smile. Love the energy here.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Lena M. – South Street

“Hands down the best breakfast sandwiches in JP. The bagels are soft but with a perfect chew, and the fillings are generous. It’s my Sunday ritual now. Also, their coffee is way better than the chains around.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Noah K. – Egleston Square

“I’m gluten-free and this place still delivers. Their gluten-free bagels hold up and don’t fall apart, and I love how I can customize everything. Not easy to find that kind of care at other sandwich shops.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tessa D. – Boylston Street

“This place is so much more than a bagel shop. The combos are creative, the ingredients are top-notch, and everything feels homemade. I brought my parents here last weekend and now they’re hooked too.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Marcus J. – JP Center

“I love how this spot brings the community together. Everyone from dog walkers to students to parents shows up here. Great music, fresh food, fast service—it checks all the boxes. JP just got tastier.”


❓ FAQs – Jamaica Plain Location

1ïžâƒŁ Where is your Jamaica Plain shop located?

We’re located right off Centre Street, in the heart of Jamaica Plain, just a short walk from Jamaica Pond and Green Street Station. Whether you’re out for a morning stroll or headed to work, we’re an easy and delicious stop along your route.

2ïžâƒŁ Do you offer vegan or gluten-free options in JP?

Absolutely! We cater to a variety of dietary preferences with vegan bagels, plant-based spreads, vegetarian sandwich builds, and gluten-free bagel options—so everyone in JP can enjoy bold, satisfying flavors.

3ïžâƒŁ Is there outdoor seating available?

Yes, we offer outdoor patio seating (weather permitting), so you can soak up the neighborhood energy while enjoying your coffee or sandwich al fresco. It’s a local favorite during spring and fall weekends.

4ïžâƒŁ Can I order online in Jamaica Plain?

Definitely! Use our online ordering system for quick pickup or delivery. We’re available on all major platforms, making it easy to enjoy your favorites without waiting in line.

5ïžâƒŁ Do you serve coffee too?

Yes! We roast our beans in-house and serve everything from rich hot drip coffee to iced lattes, cold brew, and specialty espresso drinks. Whether you need a caffeine kick or a chill sip, we’ve got you covered.

6ïžâƒŁ Do you serve breakfast all day?

We do! At New York Bagel & Coffee Co in JP, you can get your egg sandwiches, cream cheese bagels, and morning favorites any time we’re open. No rush—just real, fresh comfort food.

7ïžâƒŁ What kind of sandwiches do you serve?

Our menu includes artisan sandwiches stacked with everything from crispy bacon and smoked turkey to spicy tofu and fresh veggies—all served on your choice of bagel or specialty bread.

8ïžâƒŁ Is your food made fresh?

Always. We bake our bagels fresh every day and build each sandwich to order with quality meats, fresh produce, and house-made spreads. No shortcuts, no pre-packaged meals.

9ïžâƒŁ Are you family-friendly?

Yes! Our kid-friendly menu, cozy vibe, and fast service make us a great spot for parents and little ones alike—perfect for a quick bite before or after a day at the playground or pond.

🔟 What makes your JP location special?

Our Jamaica Plain shop reflects the community—diverse, welcoming, and full of flavor. Whether you’re vegan, gluten-free, or a sandwich traditionalist, we serve something bold for everyone, always with friendly service and neighborhood pride.

 

đŸ›ïž Stop By Jamaica Plain’s Favorite Sandwich Spot

If you’re in Jamaica Plain and craving a sandwich that goes beyond the ordinary, make your way to New York Bagel & Coffee Co — where bold flavor, quality ingredients, and fast service come together under one neighborhood roof.

We’re proud to be JP’s favorite spot for handcrafted sandwiches, fresh-baked bagels, and satisfying meals that hit the spot whether it’s breakfast, brunch, or a midday refuel. Every bite is made with care — from our hearty signature builds to our classic egg sandwiches and vegan-friendly options.

Whether you’re on a lunch break, out for a weekend stroll, or just need coffee and comfort food that delivers, you’ll find something crave-worthy here.

📍 Stop by our Jamaica Plain location or
đŸ“Č Order online to skip the line and enjoy the flavors you love, fast. 

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now