🥯 Best Artisan Sandwiches & Bagels in Allston, MA

Searching for the best breakfast café in Allston, MA? Look no further than New York Bagel & Coffee Co. — your neighborhood hub for hand-rolled New York–style bagels, artisan-made sandwiches, and locally roasted coffee that hits just right.

Nestled in the heart of Allston Village and just steps from Boston University, our café is the go-to stop for students, artists, musicians, commuters, and anyone craving bold flavors and fresh, feel-good food. Whether you’re fueling up before a class, taking a break from the studio, or grabbing a bite after hopping off the Green Line, we’ve got something satisfying for every kind of morning, lunch, or late-day coffee break.

Come see why locals call us Allston’s favorite spot for bagels, sandwiches, and coffee — made fresh daily, served with heart.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🥪 Why Allston Loves Our Artisan Sandwiches

At New York Bagel & Coffee Co in Allston, we believe sandwiches should never be ordinary. That’s why our artisan sandwiches are made-to-order with real care, using only the freshest, high-quality ingredients that pack every bite with bold, satisfying flavor. From thinly sliced premium deli meats and farm-fresh veggies to melty cheeses and signature spreads, every sandwich is layered with intention — served on a warm, fluffy New York–style bagel or soft sandwich roll baked to perfection.

We’re proud to offer something for everyone in Allston’s diverse, vibrant community. Whether you’re looking for vegan, vegetarian, or gluten-free sandwich options, we’ve got choices that don’t compromise on taste. Grab a lunch that fuels your next class at Boston University, power through your creative hustle with a quick bite between meetings, or recharge after a walk along Harvard Avenue — all while enjoying food that’s made fresh, never pre-packed.

These aren’t your average deli sandwiches. They’re Allston’s favorite for a reason — handcrafted, full of flavor, and made just the way you like it.

📋 Allston Favorites – Artisan Sandwich Menu Highlights

The Great Wall of China – $14.45

A bold, meaty masterpiece stacked with roast beef, pastrami, Swiss and Gouda cheeses, pickles, brown mustard, and creamy Russian dressing—delivering a savory, smoky, and tangy flavor punch in every bite.

Dragon Boat – $13.99

A hearty combo of turkey breast, bacon, and American cheese, topped with crisp lettuce, banana peppers, and spicy horseradish sauce—finished with golden tater tots for a fun, crunchy finish.

The Yellow Mountains – $14.45

Savor the smoky goodness of pastrami and bacon, with sweet red onions, Muenster cheese, fresh tomato, sprouts, and spicy boom boom sauce—a fiery twist on a classic deli-style sandwich.

The Pearl River – $15.99

Flavor flows with juicy chicken breast, crispy bacon, smooth chive cream cheese, grilled onions and peppers, tangy banana peppers, and a mix of provolone and Muenster—topped with boom boom sauce and crunchy sea salt chips.

The Shanghai Tower – $14.99

Stacked high with savory prosciutto, crispy bacon, sautéed onions and peppers, provolone, Swiss, and Parmesan, plus fresh lettuce, sprouts, tomato, and bold chipotle mayo—a skyscraper of flavor.

Lantern – $14.45

A trio of deli favorites—roast beef, turkey, and bacon—layered with melted Swiss and cheddar, crisp lettuce, tomato, and smoky chipotle mayo for a rich, savory bite.

The West Lake – $15.99

A spicy and creamy fusion of roast beef, ham, jalapeño cream cheese, grilled onions and peppers, smooth provolone and Gouda, with fresh tomato, lettuce, red pepper paste, and crispy chips.

Laba – $14.45

Indulge in layers of roast beef, ham, and bacon with creamy Dill Havarti, nutty Gouda, crisp lettuce, crunchy pickles, spicy jalapeños, and a tangy Parmesan peppercorn dressing.

Nu River – $15.99

A bold mix of chicken, roast beef, zesty chive cream cheese, smooth Dill Havarti, sweet and spicy peppers, banana peppers, smoky BBQ sauce, and pepper paste—topped with crunchy chips.

The Nanya River – $15.99

A savory blend of prosciutto, chicken, and bacon, with creamy plain cream cheese, tangy feta, nutty Parmesan, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, red onion, and smoky chipotle mayo.

Double Ninth – $14.45

Packed with layers of turkey, pepperoni, and roast beef, plus sweet onions, bold Swiss and smoked cheddar, tied together with tangy brown mustard and creamy ranch dressing.

Spring – $14.45

A fresh and hearty mix of turkey, pork sausage, creamy plain cream cheese, shredded Parmesan, crisp lettuce, sprouts, juicy tomato, and flavorful red pepper spread—perfect for lighter appetites.

💬 What Allston Locals Are Saying – Real Reviews

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Sarah B. – BU Student Area

“The Dragon Boat on a gluten-free bagel is shockingly good. Tater tots inside a sandwich? Genius. It’s my go-to between classes.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Marcus H. – Harvard Ave Creative District

“The Great Wall of China sandwich never disappoints. It’s packed, flavorful, and seriously filling — perfect after a long studio session.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Leah S. – Allston Village

“I love the Yellow Mountains sandwich — the heat is just right. It’s spicy without overpowering, and everything feels so fresh.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jamal R. – Green Line Commuter

“The Pearl River sandwich is pure comfort. The combo of cream cheese, bacon, and chips gives it that crispy, creamy bite I crave.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Nina K. – Gallery District Resident

“As a vegan, I really appreciate the build-your-own sandwich option. The ingredients are always fresh, and the staff is super helpful.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Eli F. – Boston University Staff

“The Shanghai Tower feels like a gourmet sandwich without the wait. Prosciutto, layered cheeses, and that chipotle mayo? Total flavor bomb.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tina M. – Student Housing Area

“The Lantern is my weekly tradition — smoky, savory, and always satisfying. The vibe here is great for a solo lunch or meet-up.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Oscar R. – Allston Streets

“West Lake is wild — jalapeño cream cheese and chips inside? It’s crunchy, spicy, and totally addictive. I’m hooked.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Dana P. – Near Packard’s Corner

“The Double Ninth is my messy favorite — big, bold, and better than any deli sandwich I’ve found in Allston.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Zara T. – Community Center Area

“This is my spot for breakfast and lunch. The coffee is always smooth, and the sandwiches hit every time. So glad it’s near BU.”

🙋‍♀️ 🙋‍♀️ FAQs – Sandwiches, Bagels & Coffee in Allston, MA

1️⃣ What sets your sandwiches apart in Allston?

Our artisan sandwiches are handcrafted to order using only the freshest ingredients — including premium deli meats, melted cheeses, crisp vegetables, and signature house-made sauces. Served on our New York–style bagels or pillowy sandwich rolls, each sandwich is built for bold flavor and next-level freshness that Allston locals can’t get enough of.

2️⃣ Do you offer vegan and gluten-free options?

Absolutely! We offer a variety of vegan-friendly ingredients and gluten-free buns, so everyone — from students to health-conscious foodies — can enjoy a sandwich that suits their lifestyle without compromising on taste.

3️⃣ Can I customize my sandwich?

Yes — we encourage it! Build your own from scratch or customize one of our signature creations. Choose your bread, protein, veggies, sauces, and extras. Whether you’re picky or adventurous, we’ve got you covered.

4️⃣ Is breakfast served all day?

Definitely. Our breakfast menu is available from 6:00 AM until close every day. Enjoy bagel sandwiches, eggs, hash browns, and smooth locally roasted coffee—morning, noon, or night.

5️⃣ What’s the most popular sandwich in Allston?

The Double Ninth is a fan favorite. It’s loaded with turkey, roast beef, pepperoni, two cheeses, and a bold blend of sauces. Hearty, flavorful, and seriously satisfying.

6️⃣ Is your coffee roasted in-house?

Yes — we roast our beans in small batches to ensure a bold, smooth flavor in every cup. Whether hot or iced, our coffee pairs perfectly with your bagel or sandwich.

7️⃣ Can I order online in Allston?

Yes! Online ordering is easy and convenient, with pickup available near Allston Village, the Green Line, and Boston University campus. Your favorite sandwich is just a few clicks away.

8️⃣ Do you offer catering in Allston, MA?

We do! Whether it’s a BU department lunch, a local business meeting, or a creative event near Harvard Avenue, we provide catering with sandwich platters, coffee boxes, and breakfast packages — all made fresh and delivered on time.

9️⃣ Are your spicy sandwiches too hot?

Not at all. Most of our spicy options are medium heat, with just enough kick. Prefer it hotter? Just let us know — we’re happy to add jalapeños, hot sauce, or spicy cream cheese.

🔟 Is your café family-friendly?

Definitely. We offer kid-friendly options, cozy seating, and a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere that’s perfect for students, professionals, families, and friends alike.

📞 Call to Action: Stop by Allston’s Favorite Bagel & Sandwich Café

Craving a freshly made artisan sandwich, a perfectly toasted New York–style bagel, or a smooth cup of small-batch roasted coffee in Allston, MA? Look no further than New York Bagel & Coffee Co — where bold flavors, friendly service, and a welcoming neighborhood vibe come together in every bite and every sip.

Whether you’re on your way to class at Boston University, taking a break near Allston Village, or exploring the art scene off Harvard Avenue, we’re here to fuel your day with food that satisfies.

👉 Order online now for quick pickup or stop by our Allston café — we’re ready to serve up your next favorite meal!