🥯 Best Cream Cheese Spreads in Brookline, MA

Searching for the best cream cheese spreads in Brookline? You’ve just found your new favorite spot. At New York Bagel & Coffee Co, we whip up our handcrafted schmears fresh every single morning—using bold, real ingredients and a whole lot of care. No preservatives. No shortcuts. Just smooth, creamy flavor in every bite.

Whether you’re craving the smokiness of lox, the zing of jalapeño, or a sweet bite of strawberry, our spreads are crafted to transform any bagel or sandwich into something memorable. Choose from classics like plain and chive, or go adventurous with veggie or white fish salad—every option is made fresh, in-house, and served with a smile.

Conveniently located near Coolidge Corner and just steps from Brookline Village, we’re proud to be your go-to for NYC-style bagels and next-level cream cheese spreads. Perfect for grab-and-go breakfasts, midday cravings, or even brunch catering trays for your next get-together.

Once you try our schmears, you’ll know why Brookline keeps coming back.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🌟 Why Brookline Locals Love Our Spreads & Schmears

Flavor-forward & handmade

From chive to white fish, every spread is made fresh in-house with real ingredients and big flavor. You’ll never look at grocery-store tubs the same way again.

Perfect with bagels—and beyond

Layer onto a warm everything bagel, build the perfect breakfast sandwich, or scoop with veggies at lunch. These spreads were made to mix, match, and enjoy.

Vegan options done right

Our vegan cream cheese has all the creamy comfort of classic dairy, minus the compromise. 100% plant-based, 100% delicious.

Fast pickup, full satisfaction

Whether you’re on a Coolidge Corner coffee run or grabbing lunch before work, we’ll have your schmear-ready bagel hot and fast.

Catering that makes brunch better

Hosting in Brookline? We offer custom trays with our best-loved spreads—ideal for brunch parties, work events, or holiday mornings.

🧁 Spreads & Schmears Menu – Brookline Favorites

Chives Spread – $10.45

A creamy, herb-forward delight made with fresh-cut chives. Adds a mild zing and smooth finish—perfect on a warm, toasted everything bagel.

Smoked Salmon / Lox (for two sandwiches) – $11.45

Delicately sliced, premium-quality lox that brings a buttery texture and ocean-fresh flavor. Ideal for building the classic New York bagel sandwich.

Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese – $11.45

A rich, velvety cream cheese infused with savory smoked salmon—for those who love a deep, briny bite with creamy undertones.

Jalapeño Cream Cheese – $10.45

Turn up the heat! This smooth and spicy schmear delivers a jalapeño kick that pairs beautifully with bagels, breakfast sandwiches, or wraps.

Strawberry Cream Cheese – $10.45

Sweet, fruity, and silky-smooth, this strawberry-infused cream cheese is a fan favorite for both morning indulgence and sweet snack moments.

Mixed Vegetables Cream Cheese – $10.45

Colorful, crunchy, and flavor-packed, this veggie-loaded spread is both wholesome and delicious. A go-to for garden lovers.

Acme White Fish Salad – $12.99

Crafted with care, this light and flaky white fish salad offers a delicate seafood flavor—amazing on a toasted bagel or as a protein-packed dip.

Albacore Wild Tuna Smoked Salad – $12.99

Made with wild-caught albacore tuna and a hint of smokiness, this salad is nutritious, savory, and great on rye or whole wheat.

Plain Cream Cheese – $7.99

Simple, classic, and endlessly versatile. This smooth, rich spread complements everything from sesame bagels to bacon-egg sandwiches.

Vegan Cream Cheese – $10.75

A plant-based alternative that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture. Perfect for dairy-free diets, with a luxuriously creamy mouthfeel.

💬 What Our Customers Are Saying – Brookline Edition

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jonah P. – Coolidge Corner

“Their smoked salmon cream cheese is legit—rich, smoky, and so smooth. Tastes like a deli spread straight from NYC. Add capers and red onions, and it’s perfect.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Priya N. – Brookline Hills

“I ordered a few 8 oz spreads for a family brunch—veggie, chive, and plain—and everyone was raving. Fresh, flavorful, and way better than store-bought.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Eli T. – Longwood Area

“I love that they let you go half-and-half on schmears. I get jalapeño and strawberry on a plain bagel for that spicy-sweet combo. It’s addictive.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rachel M. – Saint Paul Street

“I’m a regular for their plain cream cheese—sometimes the classic really is best. Smooth, not overly salty, and piled on thick. Always hits the spot.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ David S. – Brookline Village

“I do low-carb, and they’re great about serving spreads with lettuce wraps or cucumber slices. The staff is helpful, and the vegan options are just as good.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Isabelle G. – Brookline Village

“The white fish salad blew me away—delicate, smoky, and not too salty. I had it on a toasted everything bagel and immediately went back for an extra container to take home.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Nina A. – Aspinwall Hill

“I’m obsessed with their veggie cream cheese—packed with real chopped veggies and super creamy. It actually tastes fresh, not like the stuff from a tub. Total game-changer.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Kevin L. – Coolidge Corner

“I’ve tried a lot of bagel shops, and none do jalapeño cream cheese like this place. It’s bold, zesty, and has just the right heat. Toasted sesame + jalapeño = elite combo.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Fatima R. – Brookline High Area

“I hosted a brunch with a spread tray from here and the strawberry cream cheese was the first to go. Light, fruity, and not overly sweet—everyone was hooked.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Omar S. – Beacon Street

“Their lox cream cheese is unreal. So much flavor in every bite—way better than any chain. And they’re always generous with the spread. I tell all my coworkers to come here.”

🧂 Spreads & Schmears – FAQs (Brookline)

Are all your spreads made in-house daily?

Yes—every cream cheese spread and salad is hand-prepared fresh each morning in our Brookline kitchen. That means no tubs, no shortcuts—just unbeatable flavor, smooth texture, and freshness you can taste.

What’s the difference between lox and smoked salmon cream cheese?

Lox is premium sliced smoked salmon, perfect for layering on bagels and sandwiches. Smoked salmon cream cheese, on the other hand, is blended with real salmon into a creamy, savory spread—ideal when you want rich flavor in every bite.

Do you offer dairy-free spreads?

Absolutely. Our vegan cream cheese is 100% dairy-free and plant-based, with the same smooth, creamy texture as our classic spreads. A favorite among both vegans and the lactose-intolerant.

Can I build my own schmear combo?

Yes! You’re welcome to do half-and-half spreads on any bagel, or even layer multiple flavors inside a sandwich. Popular combos include chive + jalapeño or strawberry + plain.

Are your spreads gluten-free?

Yes—our cream cheese spreads are gluten-free, and we offer low-carb serving alternatives like lettuce wraps or cucumber slices if you’re avoiding bagels.

Do you offer catering in Brookline?

We do! Our bagel and schmear trays are a hit at brunches, baby showers, corporate meetings, and family events. Call ahead to customize your order for pickup or local delivery.

Which spreads are vegetarian?

All of them, except for lox, white fish, and tuna. Favorites like plain, chive, veggie, strawberry, and vegan are all 100% vegetarian and packed with flavor.

Can I order spreads to-go without a bagel?

Yes—all of our spreads are available in 8 oz containers, perfect for at-home snacking, gifting, or adding to your next brunch board.

Do you use artificial flavors or preservatives?

Never. We believe in real ingredients only—herbs, fruits, fish, and spices blended fresh each day. No fillers, no fake flavors, no compromise.

What’s Brookline’s top pick?

Local favorites include the jalapeño cream cheese for spice lovers, and the chive for that classic, herby richness. Paired with a toasted everything or sesame bagel, it’s peak Brookline comfort food.

📢 Let’s Get Schmearing – Brookline Style

From morning coffee runs to cozy weekend brunches, NY Bagel & Coffee Co in Brookline is your home for next-level cream cheese spreads. Whether you like it spicy, smoky, veggie-packed, or dairy-free, we’ve got the perfect schmear for your vibe.

Stop by near Coolidge Corner, or order ahead for pickup and delivery across Brookline, Washington Square, and Longwood.

Bagels bring the crunch. Schmears bring the soul. 🥯