🥯 Best Cream Cheese Spreads in Coolidge Corner, MA

In the heart of Coolidge Corner, where tree-lined streets meet the buzz of Brookline’s best brunch scene, New York Bagel & Coffee Co brings a bold taste of NYC right to your neighborhood. Whether you’re stepping out from a classic brownstone on Beacon Street, heading toward Trader Joe’s, or fueling up before a peaceful walk through Griggs Park, there’s one thing locals agree on—our bagels and spreads hit differently.

Here, the cream cheese isn’t just a side—it’s the main character. Crafted fresh every morning in-house, our spreads are rich, thick, and loaded with flavor. From the zing of real chives to the kick of jalapeños, the velvety texture of smoked salmon, or the surprising satisfaction of our dairy-free vegan option, every tub and every smear is made to elevate your bagel into a full-blown moment.

Whether you’re hosting brunch on Corey Hill, grabbing breakfast between errands, or picking up a few 8 oz tubs for a cozy weekend in, our spread selection adds something special to every bite. And in Coolidge Corner—where mornings start with flavor and community—you don’t just eat bagels. You start your day with something you crave, trust, and come back for.

NYC flavor. Brookline comfort. A spread for every story.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🧄 Bold Spreads. Local Love.

Why are we Coolidge Corner’s go-to for cream cheese spreads?

Freshly Made Daily

Each batch of spread is whipped fresh every morning, using real herbs, spices, fruits, and proteins. No shortcuts. No fillers. Just pure flavor.

Real NYC Flavor in Brookline

We’re built on New York deli roots, but proud to be part of Coolidge Corner’s food scene. Authentic, urban, and always a step above the ordinary.

Something for Everyone

From savory smoked salmon to sweet strawberry, dairy-free vegan to spicy jalapeño, our menu covers every craving.

Perfect for Brunch & Beyond

Heading to a brunch potluck in the neighborhood? Planning a family get-together near Amory Playground? Our 8 oz spreads and catering trays make entertaining easy.

Friendly Faces, Fast Service

We’re your neighbors. Whether you’re a regular or it’s your first visit, expect warm smiles and lightning-fast bagel building.

🧁 Spreads & Schmears Menu – Coolidge Corner Favorites

Chives Spread – $10.45

A creamy, herb-forward delight made with fresh-cut chives. Adds a mild zing and smooth finish—perfect on a warm, toasted everything bagel.

Smoked Salmon / Lox (for two sandwiches) – $11.45

Delicately sliced, premium-quality lox that brings a buttery texture and ocean-fresh flavor. Ideal for building the classic New York bagel sandwich.

Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese – $11.45

A rich, velvety cream cheese infused with savory smoked salmon—for those who love a deep, briny bite with creamy undertones.

Jalapeño Cream Cheese – $10.45

Turn up the heat! This smooth and spicy schmear delivers a jalapeño kick that pairs beautifully with bagels, breakfast sandwiches, or wraps.

Strawberry Cream Cheese – $10.45

Sweet, fruity, and silky-smooth, this strawberry-infused cream cheese is a fan favorite for both morning indulgence and sweet snack moments.

Mixed Vegetables Cream Cheese – $10.45

Colorful, crunchy, and flavor-packed, this veggie-loaded spread is both wholesome and delicious. A go-to for garden lovers.

Acme White Fish Salad – $12.99

Crafted with care, this light and flaky white fish salad offers a delicate seafood flavor—amazing on a toasted bagel or as a protein-packed dip.

Albacore Wild Tuna Smoked Salad – $12.99

Made with wild-caught albacore tuna and a hint of smokiness, this salad is nutritious, savory, and great on rye or whole wheat.

Plain Cream Cheese – $7.99

Simple, classic, and endlessly versatile. This smooth, rich spread complements everything from sesame bagels to bacon-egg sandwiches.

Vegan Cream Cheese – $10.75

A plant-based alternative that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture. Perfect for dairy-free diets, with a luxuriously creamy mouthfeel.

💬 What Our Coolidge Corner Customers Say

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Leah R. – Longwood Avenue
“Stopped in on my way to work at the hospital—got a poppy seed bagel with scallion cream cheese. Unreal. Bright, tangy, and super fresh. Now I’m hooked.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Arjun D. – Harvard Street
“I’m a bagel purist and usually skip spreads, but the smoked salmon cream cheese changed my mind. It’s next-level. Rich, flavorful, and no shortcuts.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tina G. – Washington Square
“The strawberry cream cheese has the perfect balance of sweet and creamy. My toddler calls it ‘pink magic’—safe to say it’s now a staple at home.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Malik H. – Amory Playground Area
“Picked up the whitefish salad for a Sunday brunch with friends—total crowd-pleaser. Salty, smoky, and just the right amount of texture.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel S. – Brookline Village
“I’m obsessed with the truffle spread—yes, there’s truffle cream cheese! It’s luxurious on a toasted everything bagel. Worth every bite.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Nate W. – Aspinwall Hill
“I didn’t expect to find New York-level bagels and spreads in Brookline—but wow. The jalapeño cream cheese is my go-to, and it hits every time. Creamy with just enough heat.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Emily T. – Griggs Park Area
“The vegan spread is a game-changer. It’s rich and tangy, not bland like most dairy-free options. I bring it to every brunch and no one even knows it’s vegan.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Victor C. – Brookline Hills
“I’m usually a plain bagel guy, but their chive cream cheese is something else. Fresh herbs, smooth texture—it takes a simple bagel to gourmet territory.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sasha K. – Summit Avenue
“Ordered tubs of lox and strawberry cream cheese for a baby shower—everyone was raving. Not one spread left. That says everything.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Zane P. – Brandon Hall
“The smoked salmon cream cheese has ruined me for all others. It’s that good. I’ve started picking up extras to freeze so I never run out.”

🧂 FAQs – Spreads & Schmears in Coolidge Corner

Do you make all your spreads in-house?

Yes! Every single spread is handcrafted fresh each morning right here in our kitchen using real ingredients—no preservatives, no shortcuts.

Is your vegan cream cheese both gluten-free and dairy-free?

Absolutely—our vegan cream cheese is 100% dairy-free and gluten-free, making it a favorite among plant-based and allergy-sensitive customers alike. And yes, it’s just as creamy and delicious as the original.

Can I buy your spreads in to-go containers?

Definitely! All our spreads are available in 8 oz tubs, perfect for home brunch, gifting, or simply snacking with crackers or veggies.

Are your smoked fish salads made with wild-caught seafood?

Yes—we use only wild-caught tuna and premium whitefish for our salads, giving you authentic NYC deli flavor with every bite.

Do you cater brunches and events in Brookline?

We sure do! Our bagel-and-schmear trays are a hit at house parties, business meetings, and weekend get-togethers across Brookline, Coolidge Corner, and Washington Square.

Can I get two spreads on one bagel?

Of course. Go half-and-half with sweet and savory combos or mix your faves—our team loves helping you build the perfect bite.

Do your spreads contain artificial flavors?

Never. We use fresh herbs, real fruit, and natural spices—what you taste is what you get.

Is the jalapeño cream cheese super spicy?

It has a nice kick, but it’s not overpowering—just the right balance of heat and creaminess to keep you coming back.

What spread do kids usually love?

Strawberry and plain cream cheese are kid-approved classics—mild, smooth, and perfect on any bagel.

Can I preorder my spreads and bagels for weekend pickup?

Absolutely. Call ahead or order online to skip the lines and guarantee your brunch favorites are ready when you are.

📍 Visit Us Near Coolidge Corner – Or Order Online Today

Whether you’re strolling through Coolidge Corner, heading home from Longwood, or brunching in Washington Square, New York Bagel & Coffee Co is your new go-to for bagels that hit different.

Stop in for a quick bite, grab a bagel box with your favorite schmears, or surprise your coworkers with bold, handcrafted spreads that go far beyond the basics. Smoked salmon, jalapeño, chive, vegan, and more—all made fresh, all full of flavor.

📦 Pickup & delivery available in Brookline, Coolidge Corner, Corey Hill, Washington Square, and Longwood.
🥯 Big flavor. NYC-style taste. Pure Brookline charm.