🥯 Best Cream Cheese Spreads in Jamaica Plain, MA

Right in the heart of Jamaica Plain, where community meets creativity, NY Bagel & Coffee Co delivers the bold, hand-whipped cream cheese spreads that locals crave. Nestled near the Jamaica Pond, Centre Street, and the Arnold Arboretum, our shop is your go-to for fresh NYC-style bagels topped with spreads that are anything but ordinary.

Whether you’re grabbing breakfast before a bike ride along the Southwest Corridor, planning a picnic in the park, or need a reliable brunch option for your weekend crew, our variety of cream cheese spreads will upgrade your bagel game. We blend each batch daily with real ingredients—nothing artificial, ever—and offer a rotating lineup of sweet, savory, spicy, and vegan-friendly options to suit every palate in JP.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

💡 Why Jamaica Plain Chooses NY Bagel & Coffee Co

✅ Unmatched Freshness, Every Morning

Our spreads are whipped in-house daily using real ingredients—never frozen, never mass-produced.

✅ Local, Community-Driven Vibes

Rooted in Jamaica Plain’s vibrant food culture, we proudly serve neighbors, families, and early risers with warmth and speed.

✅ Options for Every Craving

From classic plain to jalapeño, whitefish, and vegan, our cream cheese lineup fits every flavor preference and dietary need.

✅ Bagels Baked NYC-Style

Authentic hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels—the perfect canvas for every schmear.

✅ Perfectly Located in the Heart of JP

Near Centre St, Jamaica Pond, Stony Brook, and the Arboretum, we’re easy to reach whether you’re walking, biking, or driving.

✅ Fast, Friendly, Local Service

Our team knows your order, greets you by name, and delivers fast service without sacrificing quality.

✅ Catering, Pickup & Delivery Available

Bringing the brunch to you—our bulk tubs and catering platters make hosting easy and delicious.

🧁 Cream Cheese Spread Menu – Jamaica Plain Favorites

Chives Spread – $10.45

A creamy, herb-forward delight made with fresh-cut chives. Adds a mild zing and smooth finish—perfect on a warm, toasted everything bagel.

Smoked Salmon / Lox (for two sandwiches) – $11.45

Delicately sliced, premium-quality lox that brings a buttery texture and ocean-fresh flavor. Ideal for building the classic New York bagel sandwich.

Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese – $11.45

A rich, velvety cream cheese infused with savory smoked salmon—for those who love a deep, briny bite with creamy undertones.

Jalapeño Cream Cheese – $10.45

Turn up the heat! This smooth and spicy schmear delivers a jalapeño kick that pairs beautifully with bagels, breakfast sandwiches, or wraps.

Strawberry Cream Cheese – $10.45

Sweet, fruity, and silky-smooth, this strawberry-infused cream cheese is a fan favorite for both morning indulgence and sweet snack moments.

Mixed Vegetables Cream Cheese – $10.45

Colorful, crunchy, and flavor-packed, this veggie-loaded spread is both wholesome and delicious. A go-to for garden lovers.

Acme White Fish Salad – $12.99

Crafted with care, this light and flaky white fish salad offers a delicate seafood flavor—amazing on a toasted bagel or as a protein-packed dip.

Albacore Wild Tuna Smoked Salad – $12.99

Made with wild-caught albacore tuna and a hint of smokiness, this salad is nutritious, savory, and great on rye or whole wheat.

Plain Cream Cheese – $7.99

Simple, classic, and endlessly versatile. This smooth, rich spread complements everything from sesame bagels to bacon-egg sandwiches.

Vegan Cream Cheese – $10.75

A plant-based alternative that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture. Perfect for dairy-free diets, with a luxuriously creamy mouthfeel.

💬 10 Real Testimonials from Jamaica Plain Customers

Dana R. – Centre St

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“I didn’t expect to find bagels this legit in JP, but NY Bagel has blown me away. The chive cream cheese is pure perfection—creamy, herby, and packed with flavor.”

Niko M. – Green St

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“I’m always hunting for solid vegan options, and their vegan cream cheese hits every mark—creamy, flavorful, and never chalky. Total win.”

Rachel C. – Forest Hills

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“The jalapeño spread is fire—literally and figuratively. Just spicy enough to wake me up, and it pairs like a dream with their toasted sesame bagel.”

Luis V. – South St

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“This is my go-to brunch spot before heading to the Arnold Arboretum. The white fish salad has that classic NY deli vibe that’s so hard to find.”

Jessie T. – Hyde Square

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“I threw a baby shower and ordered tubs of lox, chive, and veggie cream cheese. Every single guest asked where it was from. Huge hit.”

Marco G. – Boylston St

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“The spreads are next-level. You can taste the quality ingredients. The salmon cream cheese is especially rich and indulgent—like Sunday brunch in Manhattan.”

Elena F. – Stony Brook

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“I’m plant-based, and this spot has the best vegan cream cheese I’ve had in Boston. So smooth, flavorful, and satisfying—it’s hard not to eat it by the spoon.”

Devon P. – Amory St

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“I used to live in Brooklyn and missed that classic NY deli flavor. These bagels and spreads? They take me right back.”

Hannah L. – Jamaica Pond

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Grabbing a strawberry cream cheese bagel and walking around the pond is my weekend ritual. It’s simple joy, made better with real ingredients.”

Carlos B. – Jackson Square

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Flavor, texture, variety—these spreads deliver on all fronts. Plus, the staff is awesome. It’s my favorite local find this year.”

❓ Top 10 Jamaica Plain Cream Cheese Spread FAQs

Can I buy spreads without ordering a bagel?

Absolutely! All our cream cheese spreads are available in 8 oz containers—perfect for keeping in the fridge, taking to brunch, or serving up as a last-minute party hero. Just walk in or order ahead online.

Are the spreads made in-house?

Yes. Every single spread is made fresh in-house, daily. We use high-quality ingredients and whip everything from our jalapeño cream cheese to the white fish salad right here in our kitchen.

Do you offer vegan and dairy-free options?

We do! Our vegan cream cheese is 100% dairy-free, gluten-free, and made in a separate prep zone to prevent cross-contamination. It’s rich, creamy, and a top pick among plant-based regulars in JP.

Which spread is best for first-timers?

If you’re new here, we suggest starting with the chive cream cheese for a classic herby flavor or the smoked salmon cream cheese for that indulgent NY deli taste.

Can I mix two spreads on one bagel?

Definitely. Go half and half—it’s a great way to try both a sweet and a savory flavor in one bite. Customers love combos like strawberry + jalapeño or chive + lox.

Are the spreads gluten-free?

Yes—all our cream cheese spreads are naturally gluten-free. Just pair them with your favorite gluten-free bagels, crackers, or bread at home if needed.

Do you offer catering or large orders?

We do! Whether you’re planning a baby shower, office breakfast, or weekend brunch, we’ve got you covered. We offer bulk spread tubs, bagel-and-schmear platters, and full-service catering across Jamaica Plain.

What are your best-selling spreads in JP?

Local favorites include the jalapeño cream cheese, lox spread, and our beloved vegan cream cheese. These are the flavors our JP regulars keep coming back for.

Is the white fish salad smoky?

Yes—it’s made with real smoked whitefish, giving it that robust, savory deli flavor you’d expect from a classic NY bagel shop. Perfect on a toasted sesame or everything bagel.

Can I order online for pickup or delivery in JP?

Absolutely. We offer online ordering for both pickup and local delivery throughout Jamaica Plain—perfect for lazy Sundays, busy mornings, or surprise guests.

📍 Stop By or Order Online – Jamaica Plain’s Favorite Schmears Await

Whether you’re walking to Jamaica Pond, commuting through Stony Brook, or relaxing on your porch in Hyde Square, NY Bagel & Coffee Co is your source for the boldest, freshest spreads in JP. Our handcrafted cream cheeses and authentic bagels bring NYC flavor right to your neighborhood.

🥯 Spread happiness. Spread flavor. Right here in Jamaica Plain.

📦 Order now for pickup or delivery throughout JP, including Forest Hills, Green St, Centre St, and more.