🥯 Best Cream Cheese Spreads in Watertown, MA

In vibrant Watertown, where rich history meets a lively community, NY Bagel & Coffee Co is proud to serve up authentic, hand-whipped cream cheese spreads that turn every bagel into a delicious experience. Whether you’re starting your day near Arsenal Yards, grabbing a quick bite by Watertown Square, or enjoying a weekend stroll along the Charles River, our spreads bring the bold, creamy taste of NYC’s finest delis right to your neighborhood.

Each batch is crafted fresh daily using high-quality, natural ingredients—no artificial flavors, no shortcuts—just smooth, rich spreads in savory, sweet, spicy, and vegan-friendly varieties to satisfy every palate in Watertown.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

💡 Why Watertown Locals Choose NY Bagel & Coffee Co

🥯 Genuine NYC-style bagels

Made the traditional way—hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh every morning. Each bite delivers that iconic chewy crust and soft, flavorful interior that bagel lovers crave. No shortcuts, just real New York quality right here in Watertown.

🧀 Bold, house-made cream cheese spreads

Whipped up daily using premium ingredients and packed with flavor. From classic plain to jalapeño, chive, or vegan options, our spreads are designed to elevate your bagel into something unforgettable.

🌱 Vegan and vegetarian-friendly choices

For every lifestyle. Whether you’re plant-based, health-conscious, or just love fresh ingredients, we’ve got delicious options to suit your diet—without sacrificing flavor.

🚀 Fast, friendly service

For busy mornings and tight lunch breaks. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite before work, fueling up for a study session, or ordering for the family, we keep things quick, smooth, and satisfying.

🎉 Catering and party trays

Bring the flavor to your event—perfect for office meetings, school functions, weekend brunches, or celebrations with friends and neighbors. Hassle-free, crowd-pleasing, and always fresh.

📍 Conveniently located

Near Arsenal Yards and Watertown Square, making it easy to swing by before your commute, on your lunch break, or during a weekend stroll. We’re your neighborhood bagel spot, ready when you are.

🏃‍♂️ Perfect for any occasion

On-the-go breakfasts or laid-back weekend brunches—whether you’re in a rush or ready to relax, we’ve got the bagel + spread combo to match your vibe.

🧁 Cream Cheese Spread Menu – Watertown Favorites

Chives Spread – $10.45

A creamy, herb-forward delight made with fresh-cut chives. Adds a mild zing and smooth finish—perfect on a warm, toasted everything bagel.

Smoked Salmon / Lox (for two sandwiches) – $11.45

Delicately sliced, premium-quality lox that brings a buttery texture and ocean-fresh flavor. Ideal for building the classic New York bagel sandwich.

Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese – $11.45

A rich, velvety cream cheese infused with savory smoked salmon—for those who love a deep, briny bite with creamy undertones.

Jalapeño Cream Cheese – $10.45

Turn up the heat! This smooth and spicy schmear delivers a jalapeño kick that pairs beautifully with bagels, breakfast sandwiches, or wraps.

Strawberry Cream Cheese – $10.45

Sweet, fruity, and silky-smooth, this strawberry-infused cream cheese is a fan favorite for both morning indulgence and sweet snack moments.

Mixed Vegetables Cream Cheese – $10.45

Colorful, crunchy, and flavor-packed, this veggie-loaded spread is both wholesome and delicious. A go-to for garden lovers.

Acme White Fish Salad – $12.99

Crafted with care, this light and flaky white fish salad offers a delicate seafood flavor—amazing on a toasted bagel or as a protein-packed dip.

Albacore Wild Tuna Smoked Salad – $12.99

Made with wild-caught albacore tuna and a hint of smokiness, this salad is nutritious, savory, and great on rye or whole wheat.

Plain Cream Cheese – $7.99

Simple, classic, and endlessly versatile. This smooth, rich spread complements everything from sesame bagels to bacon-egg sandwiches.

Vegan Cream Cheese – $10.75

A plant-based alternative that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture. Perfect for dairy-free diets, with a luxuriously creamy mouthfeel.

💬 10 Testimonials from Happy Watertown Customers

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Samantha B. – Arsenal Yards

“The jalapeño cream cheese is my morning wake-up call! It’s got just the right amount of heat—spicy but not overpowering—and it tastes incredible on their everything bagel. It’s the combo I look forward to every day.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ James R. – Watertown Square

“The lox spread is the real deal—fresh, smoky, and packed with flavor. Tastes just like the delis I used to visit in NYC. NY Bagel is my go-to spot when I want something classic and satisfying.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Emily K. – East Watertown

“I was so impressed by the vegan cream cheese—it’s incredibly smooth and flavorful, and you’d never know it’s dairy-free. Finally, a plant-based option that feels like a treat!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Michael D. – Watertown

“The chive spread is my favorite—bright, fresh, and herby. I grab it on a toasted sesame bagel every morning before work. It’s a little moment of joy to start the day.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Olivia M. – Watertown Neighborhood

“I ordered a catering tray for my office brunch, and it was a huge hit. The veggie cream cheese and whitefish salad got rave reviews—everyone asked where it was from!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Kevin L. – Watertown

“I’m a simple guy, and their plain cream cheese is done to perfection—thick, creamy, smooth, and just the right touch of tang. Classic, comforting, and always consistent.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tina F. – Watertown

“The strawberry cream cheese tastes like real fruit—fresh, sweet (but not too sweet), and completely addictive. It’s my go-to indulgence when I want something a little special.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ David H. – Arsenal Street

“The tuna salad spread is fantastic—smoky, rich, and super satisfying. I grab it for a quick lunch during the week and it never disappoints.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Hannah P. – Watertown

“I love how quick and friendly the service is. Even during the morning rush, they always get my order right and greet me with a smile. It’s a great neighborhood spot!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Chris W. – Watertown

“What I really appreciate is the variety—from vegan and vegetarian options to traditional classics, there’s something for everyone. NY Bagel truly caters to all tastes and diets.”

❓ Watertown Cream Cheese FAQs

Are your spreads made fresh daily?

Yes! Every morning, our team handcrafts each spread in-house using fresh, high-quality ingredients. We believe freshness is key to flavor, and we never settle for anything less than bold and creamy perfection.

Do you offer gluten-free bagels?

Absolutely! We offer delicious gluten-free bagels that don’t compromise on texture or taste. Just let us know when ordering, and we’ll make sure you get a gluten-free option that pairs perfectly with any spread.

Is your vegan cream cheese dairy-free?

Yes—it’s completely dairy-free, lactose-free, and 100% plant-based. Creamy, flavorful, and satisfying, our vegan cream cheese is a favorite among both plant-based eaters and curious foodies alike.

Can I buy spreads without a bagel?

Of course! All our spreads are available in convenient 8 oz containers for take-home enjoyment or delivery. Perfect for adding to your own meals or sharing at home.

Do you offer catering for events?

Yes, we do! Our catering trays come loaded with a variety of bagels and house-made spreads—ideal for breakfast meetings, birthday parties, and weekend brunches in Watertown. Hassle-free, crowd-pleasing, and always fresh.

Which spread is the spiciest?

If you like a little heat, our jalapeño cream cheese is the way to go. It’s got a bold, medium spice level that adds a flavorful kick without overpowering your palate.

Are your spreads vegetarian?

Yes! Many of our best-sellers—like chive, veggie, and strawberry—are completely vegetarian. We clearly label all options, and our team is happy to help you choose spreads that suit your dietary needs.

How long do spreads stay fresh?

Our spreads stay fresh for 5 to 7 days when properly sealed and refrigerated. For best taste, enjoy them while they’re at their peak!

Can I mix multiple spreads on one bagel?

Absolutely! We love when customers get creative. Mix and match flavors to build your perfect bagel—sweet and savory, spicy and smooth, or anything in between.

Do you deliver throughout Watertown?

Yes—we deliver to all of Watertown, including neighborhoods like Arsenal Yards, Watertown Square, and everything in between. Whether it’s breakfast for the office or brunch at home, we’ll bring your order right to your door.

📦 Order Today – Fresh Cream Cheese Spreads Delivered in Watertown

Whether you’re rushing to work, enjoying a peaceful stroll by the Charles River, or meeting up with friends at Arsenal Yards, NY Bagel & Coffee Co is your trusted local spot for bold, creamy, NYC-style cream cheese spreads that taste just like the ones you’d find in Manhattan—only fresher. Our spreads are made in-house every single day, using premium ingredients to ensure every bite is packed with flavor, texture, and that unmistakable New York flair.

🥯 Whether you swing by our welcoming shop or order online, we’ve made it easy to get your bagel fix—choose from quick pickup, convenient delivery, or full-service catering for offices, events, and get-togethers throughout Watertown. Let us add that perfect creamy touch to your bagel experience—one handcrafted spread, one delicious bite at a time!