🥯 Best Finger Foods in Brookline, MA

Just a short stroll from Coolidge Corner, Brookline Village, and the Longwood Medical Area, New York Bagel & Coffee Co is your go-to for more than just bagels—we serve up the crispiest, boldest Finger foods in town.

Whether you’re grabbing a mid-shift snack, picking up lunch after a morning walk through Amory Park, or need a salty side to pair with your sandwich, our menu delivers flavor, crunch, and comfort in every bite. From Parmesan Truffle Tots to Cajun Fries, everything is made fresh—no shortcuts, no soggy fries, just seriously snackable food.

Our location caters to Brookline professionals, students, and families alike—bringing that perfect blend of New York attitude and local quality to your daily routine.

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🌟 Why Brookline Locals Choose NY Bagel & Coffee Co for Finger Foods

✅ Freshly Made, Never Frozen

Our tater tots and hand-cut fries are made fresh throughout the day—never from a freezer bag. That means every bite is crispy, hot, and satisfying.

✅ Bold, Elevated Flavors

From truffle Parmesan to zesty Cajun spice, our menu isn’t your average side game. We bring a little gourmet flair to your everyday comfort food.

✅ Speed Meets Quality

We know Brookline moves fast. Whether you’re headed to class, walking home from the Green Line, or stepping out of a Longwood shift—our food is quick without compromise.

✅ Kid-Approved, Adult-Craved

Classic tots for the little ones. Truffle fries for the grown-ups. Our menu bridges cravings across all ages.

✅ Locally Loved Add-ons

We stock Nantucket Crisps and support other New England makers—because good taste should be local.

✅ Conveniently Located

Right near Coolidge Corner, Brookline Village, and Washington Square, we’re in the heart of your commute, weekend walk, or lunch break.

✅ Perfect for Grab & Go or Catering

From solo snacks to Finger food trays for your team or family, we scale up flavor without losing freshness.

✅ Consistency You Can Count On

One order or twenty—you’ll always get crunch, flavor, and care in every box.

🍟 Finger Foods That Hit the Spot

Looking for easy-to-serve, flavor-packed snacks? Our Finger food trays are perfect for brunches, baby showers, office lunches, or casual family get-togethers. Each tray features bite-sized treats like lox bagel bites, cheesy mini sliders, crispy hash rounds, and more.

Tater Tots (Parmesan Truffle) – $6.99

Crispy, golden potato tots drizzled with rich truffle oil and topped with finely grated Parmesan cheese, finished with a touch of fresh herbs. A luxurious upgrade to a comfort classic.

Tater Tots (Classic) – $4.99

Hot, crunchy potato tots served fresh from the fryer. Lightly salted and paired with tangy ketchup for that nostalgic, satisfying bite.

Tater Tots (Cajun) – $5.99

Crisp and golden potato tots tossed in a fiery Cajun spice blend, delivering a bold, smoky flavor profile. Comes with a cool dipping sauce to balance the heat.

French Fries (Parmesan Truffle) – $6.99

Hand-cut potato fries, double-fried to perfection, then finished with earthy truffle oil and a generous sprinkle of nutty Parmesan cheese—an irresistible, gourmet side.

French Fries (Cajun) – $5.99

Crispy and golden fries tossed in our signature Cajun seasoning, offering layers of spice, garlic, and smoky paprika in every bite. Perfect with any sandwich or wrap.

French Fries – $5.75

Crispy, golden fries perfectly seasoned to satisfy your everyday cravings. Each bite delivers a delightful crunch and balanced flavor, making them the ultimate go-to snack or side that never disappoints.

Nantucket Crisp (BBQ) – $2.99

Thin and crunchy potato chips coated with a sweet, tangy BBQ seasoning. Smoky and savory, they pack a punch in every handful.

Nantucket Crisp (Salt & Vinegar) – $2.99

Kettle-cooked potato crisps with sharp vinegar tang and balanced sea salt—a bold, crave-worthy classic that tingles the taste buds.

Nantucket Crisp (Sea Salt) – $2.99

Perfectly thin, ultra-crunchy chips lightly seasoned with pure sea salt. Simple, clean, and the ultimate anytime snack.

Chicken Wings – $10.99

Juicy, crispy bone-in wings, cooked to golden perfection and served piping hot, are paired with your choice of tender chicken wing style and signature sauce. Whether you crave tangy, spicy, or smoky, each bite bursts with bold, mouthwatering flavor that keeps you coming back for more.

Crispy Onion Rings – $9.99

Thick-cut, sweet onions are dipped in a light, flavorful batter and fried to crispy, golden perfection. With their satisfying crunch and tender, juicy center, these classic onion rings are perfect as a savory side or a standalone snack you’ll keep reaching for.

Fried Okra – $9.99

Golden-fried okra bites, perfectly seasoned and irresistibly crunchy, bring the authentic Southern-style snack experience right to your plate. Each bite bursts with bold, savory flavors and a satisfying crispness that makes them a delightful treat any time of day.

Jalapeño Cheese Poppers – $8.99

Fiery spicy jalapeños and gooey, melted cheese come together inside a seasoned, crispy shell for a snack that’s bold, cheesy, and utterly addictive. Choose your perfect flavor twist from Plain, zesty Masala, luxurious Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

Seasoned Eggplant Fries – $8.99

Crispy on the outside and tender within, these golden-seasoned eggplant fries deliver a unique twist that’s both surprising and delightful. Served with your choice of Plain, zesty Masala, luxurious Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

Seasoned Zucchini Fries – $8.99

Light, crispy, and perfectly herb-seasoned, these fries offer a fresh, flavorful twist on the classic favorite. Enjoy them your way with a choice of Plain, zesty Masala, rich Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

💬 Brookline Buzz – What Locals Are Saying

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Alexis R. – Coolidge Corner

“Honestly, I come here just for the Truffle Tots. They’re not your average café snack—these are crispy, rich, and have that deep truffle flavor you usually only get at sit-down restaurants. But here, they’re ready in minutes. It feels like Brookline’s best-kept secret, and I kind of love that.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Kevin J. – Brookline Village

“I originally came in just to grab a quick bagel on my lunch break, but the smell of the fries hit me the second I walked in. Ended up adding the Cajun Fries, and man, they didn’t disappoint. Spicy, flavorful, and actually crispy—not that soggy stuff you get elsewhere. Solid impulse decision.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Mira G. – Longwood Area

“Late-night shifts at the hospital can be brutal, and this place is my go-to pit stop on the way in. I grab a coffee and some classic tots, and I’m set. It’s fast, reliable, and gives me something warm to power through my shift. The kind of comfort food that doesn’t slow you down.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jason N. – Washington Square

“I live nearby and do takeout a couple times a week. What’s impressive is how well the fries travel—still crisp when I get home, and the portion size is perfect for snacking or pairing with a sandwich. You can tell they care about how the food holds up, even outside the shop.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Leila B. – Beacon Street

“The menu may be short, but every option hits. I love being able to upgrade my side when I get a sandwich—truffle tots one day, Nantucket chips the next. It’s like having a mini gourmet snack bar hidden inside a bagel shop. Total win.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tommy D. – Aspinwall Hill

“My kids are picky eaters, but they’re hooked on the classic tots here. We make a weekend stop part of our routine now. They love dipping them in ketchup, mustard, even maple syrup (don’t ask). It’s rare to find a place where the food is fast, fun, and actually hits for both kids and adults.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Cynthia L. – Brookline Hills

“I noticed right away that they carry local brands like Nantucket Crisps—and that’s the kind of detail I appreciate. It’s not just about good food; it’s about supporting local and offering something with personality. Adds that extra layer of charm to the whole experience.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Yusuf M. – St. Mary’s Street

“I came in for coffee and was shocked to find Parmesan Truffle Fries on the menu. At a bagel shop! Tried them once and now they’re a non-negotiable part of my order. Rich, savory, and perfectly seasoned. Who knew my favorite fries would come from a place known for bagels?”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Sonia P. – Chestnut Hill Ave

“After yoga, I need something fast but not heavy. This spot nails it. Their Cajun tots are just spicy enough to wake up your taste buds, and the iced coffee is strong and smooth. It’s my go-to recharge combo—keeps me energized without that sluggish feeling.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Dan W. – Brookline Reservoir

“Brookline has a lot of fancy spots, but what we were missing was something casual, quick, and crave-worthy. This place fills that gap. The Finger foods are always hot, never greasy, and the prices are fair. It’s the kind of neighborhood gem you end up going back to again and again.”

❓ FAQs – Finger Foods at NY Bagel Brookline

Are the tots and fries made fresh or frozen?

Absolutely fresh. Our Tater Tots and hand-cut Fries are made to order—never frozen. You’ll always get them hot, golden, and crispy, with just the right texture and seasoning. It’s part of why they’ve become a neighborhood favorite.

Do the truffle items contain actual truffle oil?

Yes, they do! We use real white truffle oil—not synthetic or flavored alternatives—on our Truffle Tots and Parmesan Truffle Fries. The result? An indulgent depth of flavor that’s rich, aromatic, and completely addictive.

Are there vegan-friendly options?

Definitely. Our Classic Fries, Cajun Fries, and Nantucket Crisps are 100% vegan. Just make sure to skip any cheese-based toppings or sauces. Great flavor doesn’t have to come with dairy.

Are your Cajun-seasoned items spicy?

They’ve got a kick, but nothing too intense. Our Cajun seasoning is more bold than blazing—expect a zesty, smoky flavor with a mild-to-medium heat that even spice-shy eaters can enjoy.

Do you offer combo meals with Finger foods?

Yes! You can easily upgrade any sandwich or bagel combo with your choice of Tater Tots, Fries, or Chips. It’s the perfect way to turn a quick bite into a craveable full meal.

Can I order a Finger food platter for events?

Absolutely. We offer custom Finger food trays for all kinds of gatherings—from casual house parties to office meetings and team lunches. Choose from an assortment of tots, fries, and chips. Just call ahead and we’ll make it happen.

Do you offer dipping sauces?

Of course! We’ve got ketchup, spicy mayo, and garlic aioli available upon request. Whether you’re team classic or team bold, we’ve got something to dip into.

Are your items gluten-free?

Our Fries and Chips are naturally gluten-free, but please note: we operate in a kitchen that handles wheat products. For guests with celiac or severe allergies, we recommend checking with staff when ordering.

What time of day are Finger foods available?

All day long! Whether it’s a mid-morning snack, lunch pairing, or late-afternoon pick-me-up, our Finger foods are hot and ready any time we’re open.

Is there parking nearby?

Yes. There’s metered parking throughout Coolidge Corner, plus public lots along Harvard Street and Beacon Street. We’re also easily walkable from the C Line and surrounding neighborhoods.

📞 Order Today – Your Brookline Finger Food Fix Starts Here

Whether you’re on your lunch break, finishing errands in Coolidge Corner, or grabbing takeout after work, New York Bagel & Coffee Co in Brookline has your crispy cravings covered. From truffle tots to seasoned fries, every order is made fresh and fast.

Dine in or grab-and-go. We also deliver throughout Brookline Hills, Washington Square, and Chestnut Hill.