🥯 Best Finger Foods in Coolidge Corner, MA

Located near Harvard Street and Beacon Street, New York Bagel & Coffee Co brings NYC bagel culture and Brookline flavor together in one crave-worthy spot. While our bagels and breakfast sandwiches get the headlines, our Finger foods are the local underdog hero.

From Cajun Tater Tots to Parmesan Truffle Fries, our sides are the perfect pairing for your sandwich—or a snack all their own.

Whether you’re:

Walking home from Coolidge Corner Theatre
Grabbing lunch after a shift at Longwood Medical
Meeting friends for coffee and a crunchy bite

You’ll find the perfect crispy, salty companion right here.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🌟 Why Coolidge Corner Chooses Our Finger Foods

✅ Locally Loved Recipes

Our flavor-forward fries and tots are anything but ordinary—seasoned with bold Cajun spice, Parmesan truffle, or classic sea salt. Every bite is a nod to comfort with a gourmet twist.

✅ Fast-Casual Vibe

Whether you’re hopping off the Green Line or squeezing in lunch between errands, our laid-back, counter-service style makes it easy to fuel up without slowing down.

✅ Made Fresh, Served Hot

No soggy reheats here. Each order is fried fresh when you order—hot, golden, and crispy, just the way Brookline likes it.

✅ Tastes Like Treats, Priced Like Sides

You’re getting premium toppings without the upscale markup. Truffle fries that feel indulgent—but cost less than your coffee.

✅ Kid-Friendly, Adult-Approved

Toddlers love our classic tots with ketchup. Foodies rave about the truffle fries with aioli. There’s something satisfying for every age group.

✅ Perfect After-Theatre Snack

Steps from the Coolidge Corner Theatre, we’re the ultimate post-movie bite. Skip the popcorn refill—grab crispy tots or fries with a twist instead.

✅ Easy to Order, Even Easier to Love

Dine in with friends, grab takeout on the go, or order via Uber Eats and DoorDash for that mid-movie craving. No hassle—just flavor.

🍴 Finger Foods Menu

Looking for easy-to-serve, flavor-packed snacks? Our Finger food trays are perfect for brunches, baby showers, office lunches, or casual family get-togethers. Each tray features bite-sized treats like lox bagel bites, cheesy mini sliders, crispy hash rounds, and more.

Tater Tots (Parmesan Truffle) – $6.99

Crispy, golden potato tots drizzled with rich truffle oil and topped with finely grated Parmesan cheese, finished with a touch of fresh herbs. A luxurious upgrade to a comfort classic.

Tater Tots (Classic) – $4.99

Hot, crunchy potato tots served fresh from the fryer. Lightly salted and paired with tangy ketchup for that nostalgic, satisfying bite.

Tater Tots (Cajun) – $5.99

Crisp and golden potato tots tossed in a fiery Cajun spice blend, delivering a bold, smoky flavor profile. Comes with a cool dipping sauce to balance the heat.

French Fries (Parmesan Truffle) – $6.99

Hand-cut potato fries, double-fried to perfection, then finished with earthy truffle oil and a generous sprinkle of nutty Parmesan cheese—an irresistible, gourmet side.

French Fries (Cajun) – $5.99

Crispy and golden fries tossed in our signature Cajun seasoning, offering layers of spice, garlic, and smoky paprika in every bite. Perfect with any sandwich or wrap.

French Fries – $5.75

Crispy, golden fries perfectly seasoned to satisfy your everyday cravings. Each bite delivers a delightful crunch and balanced flavor, making them the ultimate go-to snack or side that never disappoints.

Nantucket Crisp (BBQ) – $2.99

Thin and crunchy potato chips coated with a sweet, tangy BBQ seasoning. Smoky and savory, they pack a punch in every handful.

Nantucket Crisp (Salt & Vinegar) – $2.99

Kettle-cooked potato crisps with sharp vinegar tang and balanced sea salt—a bold, crave-worthy classic that tingles the taste buds.

Nantucket Crisp (Sea Salt) – $2.99

Perfectly thin, ultra-crunchy chips lightly seasoned with pure sea salt. Simple, clean, and the ultimate anytime snack.

Chicken Wings – $10.99

Juicy, crispy bone-in wings, cooked to golden perfection and served piping hot, are paired with your choice of tender chicken wing style and signature sauce. Whether you crave tangy, spicy, or smoky, each bite bursts with bold, mouthwatering flavor that keeps you coming back for more.

Crispy Onion Rings – $9.99

Thick-cut, sweet onions are dipped in a light, flavorful batter and fried to crispy, golden perfection. With their satisfying crunch and tender, juicy center, these classic onion rings are perfect as a savory side or a standalone snack you’ll keep reaching for.

Fried Okra – $9.99

Golden-fried okra bites, perfectly seasoned and irresistibly crunchy, bring the authentic Southern-style snack experience right to your plate. Each bite bursts with bold, savory flavors and a satisfying crispness that makes them a delightful treat any time of day.

Jalapeño Cheese Poppers – $8.99

Fiery spicy jalapeños and gooey, melted cheese come together inside a seasoned, crispy shell for a snack that’s bold, cheesy, and utterly addictive. Choose your perfect flavor twist from Plain, zesty Masala, luxurious Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

Seasoned Eggplant Fries – $8.99

Crispy on the outside and tender within, these golden-seasoned eggplant fries deliver a unique twist that’s both surprising and delightful. Served with your choice of Plain, zesty Masala, luxurious Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

Seasoned Zucchini Fries – $8.99

Light, crispy, and perfectly herb-seasoned, these fries offer a fresh, flavorful twist on the classic favorite. Enjoy them your way with a choice of Plain, zesty Masala, rich Truffle, or Buffalo Garlic in Mild, Medium, or Spicy heat levels.

💬 What Customers Say in Coolidge Corner

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Maya D. – Brookline Ave

“These fries are straight-up addictive. I always get the Cajun ones—spicy, crispy, and not too greasy. It’s become my weekly ritual: bagel sandwich + fries. Total comfort meal.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jared L. – St. Paul Street

“Never thought I’d say this, but the best tots in Brookline are at a bagel shop. Seriously. They’re crispy, flavorful, and somehow better every time I go.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Allie K. – Harvard Street

“Where else can you get Parmesan Truffle Fries and local kettle chips in one stop? This place delivers on both cravings—fancy and classic.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tom R. – Coolidge Corner Theatre Staff

“We sneak out during shift breaks just to grab the Cajun tots. It’s the perfect quick bite—fast, hot, and packed with flavor. Definitely the staff favorite.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Lena B. – Longwood Medical Resident

“I’m on my feet all day, and this place is a lifesaver. The food’s quick, super fresh, and miles better than anything in the hospital cafeteria. The truffle tots are my go-to.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jon P. – Beacon Street

“Truffle tots that actually taste like truffle? Yes, please. They’re generous with the seasoning and the portion. I always leave full and satisfied.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Priya N. – Brookline High School Student

“Me and my friends come here after school all the time. We pool change for an order of classic tots—they’re hot, crispy, and way more fun than chips.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Samira T. – Washington Square

“The Cajun tots with dipping sauce are perfect for cold days. It’s spicy, crunchy comfort food done right. Always hits the spot.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Evan G. – Coolidge Corner South Side

“My hack: get a breakfast sandwich and add truffle fries. Best combo in town—rich, salty, and totally satisfying. Don’t sleep on it.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Julie W. – Corey Road

“The fries are always hot and crisp, never soggy. That perfect golden crunch is what keeps me coming back. It’s my guilty pleasure that I don’t even feel guilty about.”

❓ FAQ – Finger Foods at NY Bagel, Coolidge Corner

Are fries and tots made fresh or pre-frozen?

We make every order fresh—fried to golden perfection, right when you order. No pre-cooked batches, no limp fries. Just crispy, piping hot goodness every time.

Are the truffle fries vegetarian?

Yes! Our Parmesan Truffle Fries are made with vegetarian truffle oil and real grated Parmesan—no meat-based ingredients involved. Perfect for foodies who crave flavor and plant-friendly options.

Do you offer sauces for dipping?

Absolutely. From classic ketchup to spicy aioli and rotating house-made specials, our dips are designed to level up your snack game. Ask us what’s on today’s board!

Can I add fries or tots to a sandwich combo?

You bet. Just build your own combo at checkout—whether you’re ordering in-store or online. Add a side of Cajun tots or truffle fries to make it a meal worth remembering.

Are your Cajun spice blends gluten-free?

Our Cajun spice mix is gluten-free, but please note: we use a shared fryer, so there may be trace gluten. If you have celiac or severe sensitivity, it’s best to check with our staff before ordering.

Do you cater Finger foods for events?

Yes! We offer bulk trays of fries and tots, ideal for office lunches, school events, birthday parties, or casual get-togethers. Hot, crunchy, and ready to impress your crowd.

Are your chips locally sourced?

We proudly carry Nantucket Crisps, made right here in Massachusetts. It’s our way of supporting local makers while giving you next-level crunch in every bite.

Can I call ahead for a group order?

Definitely. Whether it’s a group snack run or a dorm movie night, you can call us in advance to pre-order large quantities and even schedule a specific pickup time.

Do you offer Finger food-only snack boxes?

Yes! Our Snack Pack is a crowd favorite—filled with tots, kettle chips, and your choice of dipping sauces. It’s the perfect shareable (or solo) snack for mid-day cravings.

How do I place an online order?

We’re live on Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Grubhub, or you can order directly from our website for pickup or delivery. Fast, easy, and always hot when it arrives.

📍 Visit or Order Online – Crisp Bites Await in Coolidge Corner

Looking for the best fries or tots in Brookline? New York Bagel & Coffee Co in Coolidge Corner is more than just a breakfast stop—it’s your go-to for crispy, craveable Finger foods with flavor that sticks.

Perfect for:

After-school snacks
Theatre nights
Study fuel
Doctor shift breaks
Or just…because you need truffle fries today