🥐 Best In-House Bakery in Brookline, MA

If you’re in Brookline and searching for a fresh, flaky, flavorful pastry, look no further than NY Bagel & Coffee Co. Nestled right off Harvard Street and minutes from Coolidge Corner, our bakery is your go-to destination for made-from-scratch, baked-on-site goodness—served warm, daily, and always with love.

Whether you’re swinging by after yoga at the JCC, grabbing breakfast before the Green Line, or strolling with a coffee on Beacon Street, our pastry case is waiting with the scent of real butter, cinnamon, and sweet indulgence. No frozen dough, no delivery trucks—just Brookline’s best pastries, baked in-house every morning.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🍪 Why Brookline Locals Rave About Our Bakery

From college students to families, early risers to sweet tooths—our Brookline location has something for everyone. Here’s what sets our bakery apart:

Everything Baked In-House

From mixing bowls to the oven, it all happens here in our Brookline kitchen.

Small Batch, Big Flavor

No mass production. Just honest baking with real ingredients and zero shortcuts.

Sweet & Savory Selections

Think cinnamon rolls, croissants, spinach pastries, and gourmet muffins—all ready by 7:30 AM.

Perfect Pairings

Enjoy your treat with a cup of locally roasted drip coffee, cold brew, or creamy cappuccino.

Local Vibes

Grab a seat, sip your latte, and enjoy the cozy, community feel right in the heart of Brookline.

🧁 Brookline Favorites – Straight From Our Oven

🍥 Cinnamon Roll – $4.99

A pillowy-soft, buttery roll generously swirled with cinnamon sugar and baked to golden perfection. Finished with a rich, creamy vanilla icing glaze that melts into every warm bite. Pure comfort in pastry form.

🧁 French Toast Muffin – $4.99

Soft and buttery with cozy hints of cinnamon, nutmeg, and a touch of maple, this muffin captures the essence of classic French toast. Topped with a delicate sugar crust for extra warmth and sweetness.

🫐 Blueberry Muffin – $4.99

A moist, tender muffin packed with plump, fresh blueberries and just the right amount of natural sweetness. A timeless favorite that pairs perfectly with a hot cup of coffee.

🥐 Spinach Ricotta Savory Croissant – $5.25

A golden, flaky butter croissant filled with creamy ricotta cheese, tender spinach, and a light blend of herbs. Perfectly balanced for a savory breakfast or light lunch.

🍫 Chocolate Chip Muffin – $4.99

Soft and moist, this muffin is generously loaded with rich semi-sweet chocolate chips. Each bite delivers warm, gooey chocolate goodness wrapped in a fluffy muffin base.

🥐 Chocolate Croissant – $4.99

A traditional French pastry, delicately flaky and filled with smooth, melted dark chocolate. Light, buttery, and irresistibly rich—a Parisian café classic.

🍪 Monster Chocolate Chip Cookie – $4.99

Thick, chewy, and golden-brown, this oversized cookie is packed with chunks of semi-sweet chocolate chips for the ultimate chocolate lover’s dream.

🍏 Apple Chausson (Turnover) – $4.99

Layers of delicate puff pastry envelope a warm, sweet apple compote filling, subtly spiced with cinnamon. A flaky and fruity delight.

💚 Pistachio Muffin – $4.99

A moist, nutty muffin crafted with real ground pistachios and hints of almond extract. Topped with crushed pistachios for added texture and flavor.

🍌 Banana Walnut Muffin – $4.99

Made with ripe bananas and crunchy chopped walnuts, this moist and hearty muffin offers a perfect balance of sweetness and nuttiness.

🍫 Choco Gem Brownie – $4.99

A rich, fudgy brownie base topped with colorful chocolate candy gems. Soft, chewy, and loaded with chocolaty fun in every bite.

🍫 Chocolate Walnut Brownie – $4.99

Dense and decadent, this classic chocolate brownie is packed with chunks of crunchy walnuts for a satisfying texture contrast.

🥐 French Croissant – $3.99

A beautifully baked, traditional French croissant with a flaky exterior and soft, buttery center. Light, crisp, and freshly made every morning.

🥜 Grandmama’s Peanut Butter Cookie – $4.99

A nostalgic treat made with rich, creamy peanut butter, baked to golden perfection. Soft inside with a subtle crisp edge and deeply nutty flavor.

🍫🍥 Chocolate & Cinnamon Twist – $4.99

A flaky, twisted pastry layered with gooey chocolate and fragrant cinnamon sugar. Sweet, spiced, and perfect for sharing—or not!

🍥 Crunchy Cinnamon Swirl – $4.99

Crisp on the outside and swirled with rich cinnamon sugar, this golden pastry delivers crunch, sweetness, and warm spice in every bite.

🌰 Almond Croissant – $4.99

A buttery croissant filled with sweet almond cream and topped with lightly toasted sliced almonds. Rich, nutty, and indulgent.

🍎 Heavenly Apple Caramel Cookie – $4.99

Soft and chewy with chunks of real apple and gooey pockets of caramel, this cookie delivers sweet, fall-inspired flavor in every bite.

💬 What Brookline Customers Are Saying

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Daniel K. – Grad Student

“My morning routine always starts here—the French toast muffin is ridiculously good, with that sweet, spiced flavor and crisp top. Paired with an iced latte, it’s my daily dose of joy. With its quiet energy and local charm, this spot is truly a Brookline gem.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Mei L. – Coolidge Corner Resident

“I’ve tried cinnamon rolls all over Boston, and this one is next-level. So soft, gooey in the middle, and never dry or microwaved like at chain cafés. You can taste the freshness. I’m lucky it’s just a block away from Coolidge Corner.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Adam G. – Brookline Dad

“If you like savory, you have to try the spinach ricotta croissant. It’s golden, flaky, and filled with cheesy goodness—better than any breakfast sandwich in the area. I love knowing everything here is baked fresh in-house. This place sets the bar.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Riya P. – Remote Worker

“I bring my laptop and post up here in the mornings. It’s cozy, quiet, and super work-friendly, with solid Wi-Fi. I rotate through the pastries, but the brownie is my guilty pleasure—rich, fudgy, and big enough to split (but I never do).”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tessa H. – Weekend Walker

“Every Sunday, I take a long walk through Brookline and always end up here. The pistachio muffin is soft, flavorful, and just the right amount of sweet. It’s become part of my weekend rhythm—this bakery pulls me in every time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Luis J. – Brookline High Alumnus

“Back visiting my hometown, and I had to swing by. Still the same warm service and fresh-baked quality I remember from years ago. I grabbed an iced coffee and a banana walnut muffin, and it was just like old times. Feels like home.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Nina V. – Visiting from Boston

“I popped in for a quick bite and ended up staying longer just for the relaxed vibe and friendly staff. Everything tastes homemade and real—no artificial flavors or shortcuts. The monster cookie was gooey in the middle and loaded with chocolate. Totally worth the detour from Boston.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Zara M. – Matcha Lover

“I’m picky about my matcha, and theirs is smooth, earthy, and not overly sweet—which is rare. Paired it with a blueberry muffin and I was in heaven. Cozy indoor seating made it a perfect solo morning spot.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jon D. – Harvard Street Commuter

“I grab a pastry and drip coffee here almost every morning. The service is lightning fast, and everything is fresh, not pre-packaged. It’s one of those places where you feel like a regular, even if you’re in and out.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Clare W. – New Mom & Coffee Fanatic

“Found this place on a stroller walk, and now I’m hooked. The almond croissant is flaky and filled just right, and they were so kind and welcoming—even with a baby in tow. Love that it’s Brookline-local and feels like a true neighborhood spot.”

❓ FAQs – In-House Bakery in Brookline, MA

1️⃣ Is everything really baked in-house?

Absolutely! Every croissant, muffin, cookie, and cinnamon roll is mixed, shaped, and baked fresh on-site at our Brookline location daily. We don’t use frozen dough, third-party suppliers, or shortcuts—just high-quality ingredients and early morning hustle.

2️⃣ When are baked goods available?

Our ovens start early, and most pastries are fresh out by 7:30 AM, warm and ready to serve. For fan-favorites like the almond croissant or cinnamon roll, we recommend stopping by early—they tend to sell out fast, especially on weekends!

3️⃣ Do you offer gluten-free or vegan pastries?

Yes! We make vegan muffins and bagels, plus gluten-free muffins and cookies that are thoughtfully crafted for flavor, texture, and satisfaction—never just to check a box. You won’t believe they’re GF or vegan until you ask.

4️⃣ Can I pre-order pastries?

Definitely. Whether it’s a quick breakfast pickup or a box of muffins for a meeting, you can call ahead or order online to reserve your favorites. Pre-orders are perfect for brunches, birthdays, school treats, or office catering.

5️⃣ What’s your most popular item?

It’s tough to pick just one! The cinnamon roll (ooey-gooey with cinnamon swirls) and the spinach ricotta croissant (savory and flaky) are top sellers. But we also rotate in seasonal pastries—so there’s always something new to discover.

6️⃣ Can I dine in?

Yes—we offer comfortable indoor seating with a cozy neighborhood vibe, plus a few outdoor tables near Coolidge Corner for sunny mornings. Perfect for sipping coffee, catching up with friends, or getting some work done over a fresh pastry.

7️⃣ Do you sell bagels too?

Of course! We’re New York Bagel & Coffee Co after all. Our hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels are baked fresh every morning and come with a variety of signature spreads or served as part of our artisan breakfast sandwiches.

8️⃣ Where exactly are you located in Brookline?

We’re just off Harvard Street, steps from Coolidge Corner and the C Line on the Green Line. Whether you’re a commuter, local, or just exploring the area, we’re a convenient and delicious stop.

9️⃣ Do you offer catering or bulk orders?

Yes! We prepare pastry trays with cookies, muffins, and more for meetings, events, and special gatherings. Just give us 24–48 hours’ notice, and we’ll bake everything fresh just for your group.

🔟 Do you have drinks that pair well with pastries?

Absolutely. Try our iced matcha with a blueberry muffin, or a rich espresso with a chocolate croissant. Our coffee and tea menu is curated to bring out the best in our pastries—and we’re always happy to recommend the perfect pairing!

📦 Fresh Brookline Bakes, Daily

Whether you’re a local regular or just passing through, NY Bagel & Coffee Co in Brookline is your daily destination for authentic in-house baking. Every croissant, cookie, and muffin is made here, by us—for you.

📍 Stop by today, or place your order online for pickup.
🥐 Fresh pastries. Local flavor. Real baking.