🥐 Best In-House Bakery in Jamaica Plain

Right off Centre Street and minutes from Jamaica Pond, NY Bagel & Coffee Co brings that warm, buttery bakery smell to JP every morning. Our pastries are made from scratch and baked in-house daily—no shortcuts, no frozen trays, no compromises.

From flaky croissants to gooey brownies and soft muffins packed with flavor, this is the real neighborhood bakery Jamaica Plain’s been craving. Whether you’re strolling through Arnold Arboretum, biking the Southwest Corridor, or catching up with friends, our fresh-baked goods are just what your day needs.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🍪 Why Jamaica Plain Loves Our In-House Bakery

• 100% In-House Baked

Every pastry is made from scratch and oven-fresh from our Jamaica Plain kitchen—no shortcuts, no outsourcing, just honest baking.

• Fresh Every Morning

We fire up the ovens before dawn so you can start your day with warm muffins, flaky croissants, and soft cookies, ready by 7:30 AM.

• Creative & Classic Options

Whether you’re in the mood for a buttery almond croissant, a chewy brownie, or a savory stuffed croissant, our rotating selection keeps things fun and flavorful.

• Locally Loved

A go-to spot for JP artists, dog walkers, commuters, and weekend park-goers—our pastries are part of the local routine.

• Coffee Pairings Ready

Match your chocolate chip cookie or banana muffin with a signature oat milk latte or cold brew—we’ve got your morning (or afternoon) covered.

Whether you’re fueling up for a walk around the Pond or grabbing a cozy treat to go, our JP bakery counter is the sweet stop you didn’t know you needed—until now.

🧁 Pastry Menu – Baked Fresh Daily in Jamaica Plain

🍥 Cinnamon Roll – $4.99

A pillowy-soft, buttery roll generously swirled with cinnamon sugar and baked to golden perfection. Finished with a rich, creamy vanilla icing glaze that melts into every warm bite. Pure comfort in pastry form.

🧁 French Toast Muffin – $4.99

Soft and buttery with cozy hints of cinnamon, nutmeg, and a touch of maple, this muffin captures the essence of classic French toast. Topped with a delicate sugar crust for extra warmth and sweetness.

🫐 Blueberry Muffin – $4.99

A moist, tender muffin packed with plump, fresh blueberries and just the right amount of natural sweetness. A timeless favorite that pairs perfectly with a hot cup of coffee.

🥐 Spinach Ricotta Savory Croissant – $5.25

A golden, flaky butter croissant filled with creamy ricotta cheese, tender spinach, and a light blend of herbs. Perfectly balanced for a savory breakfast or light lunch.

🍫 Chocolate Chip Muffin – $4.99

Soft and moist, this muffin is generously loaded with rich semi-sweet chocolate chips. Each bite delivers warm, gooey chocolate goodness wrapped in a fluffy muffin base.

🥐 Chocolate Croissant – $4.99

A traditional French pastry, delicately flaky and filled with smooth, melted dark chocolate. Light, buttery, and irresistibly rich—a Parisian café classic.

🍪 Monster Chocolate Chip Cookie – $4.99

Thick, chewy, and golden-brown, this oversized cookie is packed with chunks of semi-sweet chocolate chips for the ultimate chocolate lover’s dream.

🍏 Apple Chausson (Turnover) – $4.99

Layers of delicate puff pastry envelope a warm, sweet apple compote filling, subtly spiced with cinnamon. A flaky and fruity delight.

💚 Pistachio Muffin – $4.99

A moist, nutty muffin crafted with real ground pistachios and hints of almond extract. Topped with crushed pistachios for added texture and flavor.

🍌 Banana Walnut Muffin – $4.99

Made with ripe bananas and crunchy chopped walnuts, this moist and hearty muffin offers a perfect balance of sweetness and nuttiness.

🍫 Choco Gem Brownie – $4.99

A rich, fudgy brownie base topped with colorful chocolate candy gems. Soft, chewy, and loaded with chocolaty fun in every bite.

🍫 Chocolate Walnut Brownie – $4.99

Dense and decadent, this classic chocolate brownie is packed with chunks of crunchy walnuts for a satisfying texture contrast.

🥐 French Croissant – $3.99

A beautifully baked, traditional French croissant with a flaky exterior and soft, buttery center. Light, crisp, and freshly made every morning.

🥜 Grandmama’s Peanut Butter Cookie – $4.99

A nostalgic treat made with rich, creamy peanut butter, baked to golden perfection. Soft inside with a subtle crisp edge and deeply nutty flavor.

🍫🍥 Chocolate & Cinnamon Twist – $4.99

A flaky, twisted pastry layered with gooey chocolate and fragrant cinnamon sugar. Sweet, spiced, and perfect for sharing—or not!

🍥 Crunchy Cinnamon Swirl – $4.99

Crisp on the outside and swirled with rich cinnamon sugar, this golden pastry delivers crunch, sweetness, and warm spice in every bite.

🌰 Almond Croissant – $4.99

A buttery croissant filled with sweet almond cream and topped with lightly toasted sliced almonds. Rich, nutty, and indulgent.

🍎 Heavenly Apple Caramel Cookie – $4.99

Soft and chewy with chunks of real apple and gooey pockets of caramel, this cookie delivers sweet, fall-inspired flavor in every bite.

💬 What JP Locals Are Saying

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Dana L. – Centre Street Commuter

“I stop here every morning before hopping on the Orange Line. Their chocolate croissant with an oat milk latte has become part of my routine. You can actually taste that everything is freshly baked in-house—which is so rare these days. Feels like a real bakery, not a chain.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Chris M. – Local Artist

“I live and paint in JP, and this place fuels my creativity. The banana walnut muffin hits the spot before I head into the studio. It’s soft, not too sweet, and you can tell it’s made with care. A calm, cozy space with real soul.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Aisha K. – JP Dog Walker

“After early morning loops around Jamaica Pond, this bakery is my reward. I tie up my pup out front and grab an almond croissant—always fresh, flaky, and buttery. It’s the perfect local stop for dog walkers like me!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Omar N. – Weekend Biker

“I bike the Southwest Corridor trail almost every Saturday, and this spot is my go-to pit stop. Their cinnamon roll is soft, gooey, and just sweet enough. Great post-ride treat—and there’s outdoor seating, too.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Marina T. – Vegan in JP

“As someone who eats mostly plant-based, it’s amazing to find a bakery that actually offers vegan cookies and muffins that taste incredible. Plus, the team is super friendly—they always remember my name and my order!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Leo F. – Remote Worker

“I work from here a few times a week—fast Wi-Fi, chill playlist, and ridiculously good brownies. It’s hard to focus anywhere else once you get used to the cozy atmosphere and baked smells wafting through the air.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Sophie Y. – JP Book Club Host

“Whenever I host our monthly book club, I bring a box of assorted muffins and scones from here. Everyone raves about them. It’s become a tradition—and I always grab a chai latte for myself, too.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Nathan R. – Sunday Brunch Regular

“I’m not even a big ‘pastry guy’ but this place converted me. Their pistachio muffin is wild—in a good way. My wife and I make it a point to stop here after our Sunday morning walk.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Emily B. – Preschool Mom

“This is my quiet window after drop-off. I grab a blueberry muffin and herbal tea and just enjoy the peace for 20 minutes. It’s one of the only bakeries I trust to have real ingredients—you can tell by the taste.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jared C. – JP Lifelong Resident

“I’ve lived here over 30 years and I can say: this is the best bakery JP has seen in a long time. Everything’s made on-site, no shortcuts. The brownies, croissants, cookies—they’re all dangerously good.”

❓ FAQs – Jamaica Plain Bakery Lovers Want to Know

1️⃣ Is everything really baked in-house?

Yes! Every croissant, muffin, cookie, and brownie is baked fresh right here at our Jamaica Plain location. We don’t truck anything in—we bake it all ourselves, daily.

2️⃣ What time are fresh pastries available?

Our ovens get going early, and most baked goods are ready by 7:30 AM. Some favorites—like our pistachio muffin or cinnamon roll—often sell out by mid-morning, so stop by early!

3️⃣ Do you offer vegan or gluten-free options?

Absolutely! We rotate in vegan muffins, cookies, and occasionally scones. We also have gluten-friendly options—just ask a team member for what’s available that day.

4️⃣ Can I order baked goods online?

Yes! Whether you’re planning ahead or just need to skip the line, our online ordering system lets you pre-select pastries for pickup or catering. Easy and efficient.

5️⃣ Do you offer bulk or catering trays?

We do! We can pack up assorted pastry boxes for your next office meeting, brunch gathering, or birthday treat table. Just call ahead or order online to customize your mix.

6️⃣ Is your Jamaica Plain location dog-friendly?

Yes! Our outdoor seating is pet-welcoming, and we love seeing locals stroll up with their pups. (Bonus: we often have treats for four-legged visitors!)

7️⃣ Do you sell bagels too?

Of course! We’re proud of our New York-style bagels, baked fresh daily. They pair perfectly with a pastry (or two) and a hot coffee.

8️⃣ Can I grab coffee with my pastry?

Definitely. From lattes and cappuccinos to cold brew and herbal tea, we’ve got your coffee cravings covered. It’s the perfect pairing with anything from a chocolate croissant to a savory muffin.

9️⃣ Do you offer seating or is it just grab-and-go?

We offer both! Our space is designed for cozy sit-downs with Wi-Fi, or quick takeout for those on the go. Come work, read, or catch up with a friend—coffee in hand.

🔟 What’s the vibe like at this location?

Laid-back and community-driven. Our Jamaica Plain spot is a favorite among families, dog walkers, artists, and remote workers. It’s the kind of place where everyone knows your order after a few visits.

🛍️ The JP Bakery Locals Count On—Every Single Day

From early morning coffee runs to post-pond walks, NY Bagel & Coffee Co in Jamaica Plain is your go-to spot for fresh, flavorful, house-made pastries.

🧁 Skip the supermarket sweets. Stop by for real-deal baking and local vibes.
🥐 Baked fresh daily. Right here in JP.