Best New York Style Bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, MA

Bagel lovers in Fenway-Kenmore no longer need to travel to New York for the real bagel experience. At our shop, we bring the authentic taste of New York style bagels right to the heart of Boston. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked on stone decks, giving you the classic golden crust and chewy texture that defines a true New York bagel.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite before a Red Sox game at Fenway Park, picking up breakfast on the way to work, or ordering catering for a group at Boston University or Northeastern, we’ve got you covered. Our menu includes all the classics—Plain, Sesame, and Everything Bagels—as well as specialties like Asiago Cheese, Jalapeño Cheddar, Cinnamon Raisin, and Blueberry. Pair them with our house-made cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon, or fresh deli sandwiches, and complete your meal with a hot coffee or refreshing iced drink.

Conveniently located near Fenway-Kenmore, our bagel shop is a favorite among students, professionals, families, and sports fans alike. With dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering options, we make it easy for you to enjoy fresh, authentic bagels any time of day.

Restaurant Details

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

✅ Why Choose Our New York Style Bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, MA?

In Fenway-Kenmore, where students, professionals, and sports fans are always on the go, finding food that’s both fresh and satisfying is essential. Here’s why our bagel shop stands out as the top choice for authentic New York style bagels in the neighborhood:

🥯 Authentic New York Style, Right in Boston

Our bagels aren’t just baked—they’re crafted using the traditional New York method: hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and stone-baked. This creates the signature crisp crust and chewy interior that’s impossible to replicate with shortcuts.

🌅 Fresh Baked Daily for Maximum Flavor

Every morning, we bake bagels in small, fresh batches, ensuring each bite is warm, flavorful, and never stale. Whether you’re stopping by before class or after a Red Sox game, you’ll always get bagels at their best.

🧀 House-Made Spreads & Toppings

We take pride in preparing creamy whipped spreads and premium toppings in-house. From classic plain cream cheese to savory scallion and smoked salmon spreads, plus fresh veggies and deli meats, you’ll find endless flavor combinations.

🥪 All-Day Breakfast & Signature Sandwiches

Students and professionals in Fenway love our all-day breakfast sandwiches, while sports fans enjoy hearty bagel melts and deli favorites before or after the game. Options like our lox sandwich, turkey & Swiss melt, and avocado veggie bagel are customer favorites.

🚚 Fast Delivery & Easy Takeout

Located in the heart of Boston, we know convenience is key. That’s why we offer quick delivery to Fenway apartments, college campuses, and offices, as well as a speedy grab-and-go counter for those rushing to class or work.

👨‍👩‍👧 Loved by Students, Families & Fans

From college students grabbing a filling breakfast, to families enjoying weekend brunch, to fans heading to Fenway Park, our shop has something for everyone. Fair pricing, hearty portions, and authentic flavor make us a trusted favorite in Fenway-Kenmore.

📍 New York Style Bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, MA & Nearby Areas

Our Fenway-Kenmore location makes it easy to serve Boston neighborhoods, colleges, and nearby towns with freshly baked New York style bagels. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast before class, fueling up before a Red Sox game, or catering for an office meeting, our bagels are always fresh, authentic, and ready when you need them.

🥯 Fenway-Kenmore, MA – Our home neighborhood, serving students, sports fans, and locals with hot, fresh bagels daily.

🥯 Boston, MA – From Back Bay to Downtown, we deliver bagels to offices, apartments, and schools throughout the city.

🥯 Allston, MA – A favorite for students and young professionals craving affordable, filling bagel sandwiches.

🥯 Brookline, MA – Families and foodies alike enjoy our artisanal bagels and house-made spreads.

🥯 Cambridge, MA – Harvard and MIT students rely on us for quick, hearty breakfasts and late-morning brunches.

🥯 Somerville, MA – Popular for takeout and weekend bagel platters for friends and family gatherings.

🥯 Watertown, MA – Known for offices and schools that order catering platters and coffee boxes.

🥯 Arlington, MA – A go-to spot for commuters and families who love freshly baked bagels on busy mornings.

🥯 Medford, MA – Tufts students and staff love our affordable, filling bagel sandwiches.

🥯 Newton, MA – Families here enjoy our healthier options like whole wheat and multigrain bagels.

🥯 Belmont, MA – Perfect for commuters who want bagels and coffee before heading into Boston.

🥯 Waltham, MA – Popular for office breakfast catering and student-friendly lunch options.

🥯 Jamaica Plain, MA – Residents love our vegetarian and vegan options, especially the avocado veggie bagel.

🥯 Roslindale, MA – Families order assorted bagel dozens for weekend brunches and celebrations.

🥯 Dorchester, MA – A busy hub where locals enjoy delivery for breakfast and lunch on the go.

🥯 Chelsea, MA – Residents enjoy reliable delivery service for bagels, spreads, and sandwiches.

🥯 Everett, MA – A nearby city where bagel lovers order quick breakfasts and coffee combos.

🥯 Malden, MA – Known for catering orders for schools, offices, and large gatherings.

🥯 Revere, MA – A favorite stop for bagels and iced coffee before heading to Revere Beach.

🥯 Quincy, MA – Families and professionals rely on us for fresh bagels, coffee, and weekend catering platters.

🍽 Popular Bagels & Menu Highlights – Fenway-Kenmore, MA

In the heart of Boston’s Fenway-Kenmore, our bagels are made fresh daily using the authentic New York method—hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and stone-baked. Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast before class, fueling up for a Red Sox game, or enjoying brunch with friends, here are some customer favorites:

🥯 Classic Bagels

Plain Bagel – The original classic: golden crust, soft chewy center. Perfect with any spread or as a sandwich base.
💲$1.75 each | $14.99 dozen
Sesame Bagel – Toasted sesame seeds add a nutty crunch, making it a timeless favorite.
💲$1.95 each | $16.99 dozen
Everything Bagel – Packed with sesame, poppy seeds, onion, garlic, and sea salt for a bold, savory bite.
💲$2.25 each | $18.99 dozen
Poppy Seed Bagel – Lightly crunchy with earthy flavor, best paired with plain or chive cream cheese.
💲$1.95 each | $16.99 dozen

🧀 Specialty Bagels

Asiago Cheese Bagel – Topped with melted Asiago cheese that bakes into a crispy, flavorful crust.
💲$2.75 each | $22.99 dozen
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel – Sweet and chewy, with cinnamon swirls and plump raisins. Delicious toasted with butter.
💲$2.25 each | $18.99 dozen
Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel – Spicy jalapeños and gooey cheddar baked into the crust for a bold kick.
💲$2.75 each | $22.99 dozen
Blueberry Bagel – Studded with juicy blueberries, lightly sweet, and perfect with strawberry cream cheese.
💲$2.25 each | $18.99 dozen

🥗 House-Made Cream Cheese Spreads

Plain Cream Cheese – Smooth, rich, and whipped fresh daily.
💲$3.50 (single) | $5.99 (tub)
Chive & Scallion Cream Cheese – Fresh herbs blended in for a savory, tangy flavor.
💲$4.25 (single) | $7.99 (tub)
Lox Spread – Cream cheese mixed with smoked salmon for a deli-style favorite.
💲$5.50 (single) | $9.99 (tub)
Strawberry Cream Cheese – Sweet, fruity, and made with real strawberries.
💲$4.25 (single) | $7.99 (tub)

🥪 Signature Bagel Sandwiches

Classic Lox & Bagel – Smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, red onion, and capers on your choice of bagel.
💲$11.99
Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich – Fluffy eggs with melted cheese on a toasted bagel. Add bacon, sausage, or turkey for 💲+2.00.
💲$7.99
Turkey & Swiss Bagel Melt – Roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard, served warm.
💲$9.99
Avocado Veggie Bagel – Creamy avocado, cucumber, sprouts, tomato, and chive cream cheese on multigrain.
💲$8.99

☕ Coffee & Beverages

Fresh Brewed Coffee (Hot/Iced) – Bold, smooth, and brewed fresh all day.
💲$2.99 (12 oz) | $3.99 (16 oz)
Latte / Cappuccino – Espresso paired with steamed milk and frothy foam.
💲$4.50 (12 oz) | $5.50 (16 oz)
Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice – Refreshing and natural, perfect with breakfast.
💲$4.99 (12 oz)
Iced Tea & Lemonade – Light, crisp, and perfect for hot days in Fenway.
💲$3.50 (16 oz)

🚚 Delivery & Takeout – New York Style Bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, MA

In Fenway-Kenmore, where mornings start early and nights run late, we know convenience is everything. That’s why our delivery and takeout services are designed to get you the freshest bagels, sandwiches, and coffee exactly when you need them. Whether you’re a student at BU, a professional heading to the Longwood Medical Area, or a Red Sox fan craving a snack before the game, we’ve got you covered.

✅ Hot & Fresh Delivery

Our bagels are baked fresh every morning and delivered while still warm and chewy. Whether you’re ordering a breakfast sandwich before class, a dozen bagels for your office, or a catering package for an event, your order will arrive on time and oven-fresh—never soggy, never stale.

✅ Secure, Spill-Proof Packaging

We know how important it is for bagels and spreads to arrive in perfect condition. That’s why we use eco-friendly packaging that keeps everything fresh, intact, and mess-free. Sandwiches are wrapped securely, spreads are sealed, and coffee boxes stay hot until you’re ready to pour.

✅ Quick & Easy Takeout

In a rush to catch the T or get to class? Our grab-and-go counter makes pickup simple. Place your order online or by phone, and we’ll have it ready in minutes. Many Fenway locals swing by for bagels and coffee before heading to the office, while students love quick takeout between lectures.

✅ Catering for Offices, Events & Game Days

From office breakfasts near Longwood to game day platters for Fenway tailgates, our catering menu has everything: assorted bagel dozens, cream cheese tubs, sandwich trays, and coffee boxes. Perfect for feeding groups of any size, with labeling and packaging that makes serving effortless.

✅ Easy Online Ordering

With just a few clicks, you can browse our full menu, customize your bagels, and schedule pickup, delivery, or catering. You can even pre-order for the next morning, so your bagels are ready right when you need them—whether that’s before an early class or a Saturday brunch.

🏆 Why We’re the Best in Fenway-Kenmore, MA

Fenway-Kenmore is one of Boston’s busiest neighborhoods, home to students, professionals, families, and sports fans. Here’s why our bagel shop has become a top destination for authentic New York style bagels in the area:

✅ 1. True New York Tradition

Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and stone-baked, giving it the golden crust and chewy inside that defines a real New York bagel. While other spots may cut corners, we stick to time-honored methods that guarantee authenticity in every bite.

✅ 2. Fresh Daily, Never Frozen

We bake fresh batches throughout the day, so your bagel is always warm, soft, and full of flavor. Whether you grab breakfast before class at BU, a sandwich on your way to work in the Longwood Medical Area, or a quick bite before a Red Sox game, freshness is guaranteed.

✅ 3. Variety for Every Taste

From classic Plain, Sesame, and Everything bagels to specialties like Asiago Cheese, Jalapeño Cheddar, and Cinnamon Raisin, we offer something for every craving. Plus, our house-made spreads and signature sandwiches mean endless flavor combinations.

✅ 4. Convenient Delivery & Takeout

Living in a busy neighborhood means you don’t always have time to dine in. That’s why we offer fast delivery across Fenway, Back Bay, and Kenmore, plus a grab-and-go counter for quick takeout. Perfect for students, professionals, and sports fans on the move.

✅ 5. Perfect for Students & Professionals

With several colleges nearby—BU, Northeastern, Berklee—and a busy medical district, our shop is a favorite among students needing affordable meals and professionals looking for hearty breakfasts or lunches. We serve portions that fill you up without breaking the budget.

✅ 6. A Trusted Local Favorite

From longtime residents to game-day visitors at Fenway Park, our shop has earned a loyal following. Customers rave about our quality, consistency, and service—making us one of the most trusted food spots in Fenway-Kenmore.

⭐ Customer Testimonials – Best New York Style Bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, MA

We’re proud to be a local favorite in the Fenway-Kenmore neighborhood. Here’s what our customers have to say:

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel M. – Boston University Student
“As a BU student, I’m always on the go, and this bagel shop is a lifesaver. The bagels are always fresh and chewy, and I can grab breakfast before class in minutes. The avocado veggie bagel is my favorite—it keeps me full until the afternoon.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
James K. – Fenway Resident
“I’ve lived near Fenway for years, and this shop quickly became part of my morning routine. Their coffee is bold, the Everything Bagel with scallion cream cheese is unbeatable, and the staff are always friendly. It feels like a neighborhood staple.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sophie L. – Northeastern University Student
“Between classes, I love ordering delivery here—it’s fast, reliable, and always packaged neatly. The lox bagel tastes exactly like the ones I used to get back home in New York. Honestly, this place has become my comfort food in Boston.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Michael P. – Fenway Park Visitor
“I stopped by before a Red Sox game, and it was the best decision. The Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel with egg and cheese had just the right kick, and it was quick enough to grab before heading to the park. Definitely my new game-day tradition.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Linda C. – Longwood Medical Worker
“Working long shifts means I rely on takeout often, and this shop never disappoints. The bagels stay fresh even during delivery, and the turkey & Swiss bagel melt is my go-to lunch. Consistency and quality every single time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Andrew T. – Fenway-Kenmore Resident
“My family orders catering from here all the time—dozens of bagels, tubs of cream cheese, and coffee boxes. Everything is labeled, organized, and fresh. It makes hosting so much easier, and our guests always ask where we got the bagels from.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Caroline H. – Berklee College of Music Student
“Late-night studying means I need good food nearby, and their takeout is perfect. The cinnamon raisin bagel toasted with strawberry cream cheese is my sweet treat after long practice sessions. Always fresh, never disappointing.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Ethan R. – Back Bay Office Worker
“Our office in Back Bay orders bagel platters regularly, and this shop has been the most reliable. Everything arrives on time, packaged securely, and still warm. It’s become our team’s favorite Friday breakfast tradition.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Jessica F. – Fenway Parent
“My kids love the blueberry bagels, and I’m a fan of the multigrain with veggie cream cheese. It’s hard to find food that makes both parents and kids happy, but this shop delivers every time. Affordable, delicious, and family-friendly.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Chris D. – Boston College Fan
“On game days, nothing beats grabbing a bagel sandwich here before heading into Fenway. The portions are big, the flavors are authentic, and the energy in the shop is always buzzing. It’s become part of the Boston sports experience for me.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – New York Style Bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, MA

1. Do you deliver bagels in Fenway-Kenmore?

✅ Yes, we provide fast delivery across Fenway, Kenmore, Back Bay, and Longwood. Whether it’s a single sandwich before class, a dozen bagels for brunch, or catering for your office, we’ll deliver your order fresh, warm, and on time.

2. Can I order bagels online for pickup or delivery?

✅ Absolutely. Our online ordering system allows you to customize bagels, choose spreads, and schedule either pickup or delivery. You can even pre-order for the next day, which is popular among students and professionals with busy mornings.

3. Are your bagels baked fresh daily?

✅ Yes! We bake small batches every morning using the New York method—hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and stone-baked. Unlike chain cafés, we never serve frozen or day-old bagels. Every bite is fresh, chewy, and flavorful.

4. Do you offer vegetarian and vegan options?

✅ Yes, we cater to plant-based customers with vegan-friendly bagels (Sesame, Everything, Multigrain) and dairy-free cream cheese options. Our Avocado Veggie Bagel is especially popular among health-conscious and vegan customers in Fenway.

5. Do you have gluten-free or healthier bagel options?

✅ We offer whole wheat, multigrain, and gluten-friendly bagels to meet different dietary needs. These options are great for students and families who want to enjoy authentic flavor while sticking to lighter or gluten-conscious diets.

6. How long does delivery usually take in Fenway?

✅ Delivery typically takes 30–40 minutes, depending on time of day and location. For larger catering orders, we recommend ordering a few hours in advance. Our packaging ensures your bagels, spreads, and sandwiches arrive hot and intact.

7. Can I grab bagels quickly before a Red Sox game?

✅ Definitely! Our grab-and-go takeout counter is designed for speed. Many fans stop in before heading to Fenway Park for a sandwich or coffee, and we keep service quick so you won’t miss first pitch.

8. Do you provide catering for colleges and offices in Fenway?

✅ Yes, we serve Boston University, Northeastern, Berklee, and nearby offices with catering packages. Choose from assorted bagel platters, cream cheese tubs, sandwich trays, and coffee boxes—perfect for meetings, events, and campus gatherings.

9. Can I pre-order for the next morning?

✅ Yes, pre-ordering is available for both pickup and delivery. Many professors, medical workers, and families pre-schedule their orders so fresh bagels and coffee are ready exactly when they need them, whether it’s at 7 a.m. or noon.

10. What makes your Fenway-Kenmore bagel shop different?

✅ Unlike generic coffee chains, we focus solely on authentic New York style bagels. Every bagel is made fresh daily, served with house-made spreads, and offered at fair prices. Combine that with reliable delivery, friendly staff, and local love, and you’ll see why we’re Fenway’s favorite.

📞 Visit or Order Today

Craving the authentic taste of New York style bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, MA? Whether you’re a student grabbing a quick breakfast, a professional looking for a hearty lunch, or a Red Sox fan fueling up before the game, we’ve got the perfect bagel for you. From our classic kettle-boiled bagels and house-made spreads to our signature sandwiches and fresh coffee, every bite is baked with care and flavor you can trust.

📍 New York Style Bagels – Fenway-Kenmore, MA

NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States