Best New York Style Bagels in Somerville, MA

For true bagel lovers, nothing beats the taste of an authentic New York style bagel—chewy on the inside, golden and crisp on the outside. Now, you don’t need to travel to NYC to enjoy this iconic breakfast staple. Right here in Somerville, MA, residents and students can savor the real deal at Somerville Bagel Café, a local favorite that’s raising the standard for bagels across Greater Boston.

Every bagel at Somerville Bagel Café is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh throughout the day, ensuring every bite is packed with authentic flavor and texture. Whether you prefer a classic plain or everything bagel with cream cheese, a cinnamon raisin for a sweet morning treat, or a hearty bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich, you’ll always find the perfect option to start your day.

Conveniently located near Davis Square and Tufts University, the café is a go-to spot for students, professionals, and families looking for quick breakfasts, weekend brunches, and even catering for larger gatherings. With a reputation for freshness, variety, and warm service, Somerville Bagel Café has become the top destination for anyone craving the best New York style bagels in Somerville, MA.

Restaurant Details:

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

✅ Why Choose Our New York Style Bagels in Somerville, MA?

When you’re searching for the best New York style bagels in Somerville, MA, you expect more than just a quick bite—you want authentic taste, freshness, and convenience. Here’s why locals, students, and families choose Somerville Bagel Café time and time again:

🥯 Authentic New York Bagel Tradition
Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily—the true New York way. This ensures the perfect balance of a chewy interior and a crisp golden crust, delivering the flavor that bagel lovers crave.

🌱 Fresh Ingredients, No Shortcuts
We use high-quality flour, farm-fresh toppings, and all-natural spreads, with no artificial preservatives or frozen dough. Our commitment to freshness guarantees every bagel is soft, flavorful, and made to perfection.

🍳 Wide Variety of Flavors & Sandwiches
From plain, sesame, and everything bagels to lox with cream cheese, bacon-egg-cheese sandwiches, and veggie delights, our menu has something for everyone—whether you like sweet, savory, or classic.

🎓 Perfect for Students & Professionals
Located near Tufts University and Davis Square, we’re a popular stop for students grabbing a study snack, professionals needing a quick breakfast, and families enjoying weekend brunch.

🚴 Takeout, Delivery & Catering Available
Busy schedule? No problem. We offer fast takeout, reliable delivery, and catering services across Somerville and nearby neighborhoods, making it easy to enjoy bagels anytime, anywhere.

⭐ Trusted by the Local Community
With 5-star reviews from Somerville residents, Tufts students, and Boston commuters, Somerville Bagel Café has earned a reputation for authentic flavors, generous portions, and friendly service.

📍 New York Style Bagels in Somerville, MA & Nearby Cities

One of the reasons Somerville Bagel Café is considered a top spot for New York style bagels is our prime location near Davis Square, allowing us to deliver and serve customers across Somerville and Greater Boston. Here’s a breakdown of the cities and neighborhoods we proudly serve:

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Allston, MA (3 miles away)
College students and young professionals in Allston love our bagels for breakfast-on-the-go. Everything bagels with cream cheese and lox are weekend favorites.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Cambridge, MA (2 miles away)
With Harvard and MIT close by, our bagels are a must-have for students and professors looking for a quick, filling, and affordable meal between classes.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Brookline, MA (5 miles away)
Families in Brookline often order our bagel platters for brunch. From plain to sesame, our freshly baked bagels make weekend mornings extra special.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Somerville, MA (local)
Right here at home, we’re the go-to café for Tufts students, Davis Square locals, and families craving authentic New York style bagels every morning.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Boston, MA (4 miles away)
From Fenway to Back Bay, Boston residents rely on us for fresh bagels, cream cheese spreads, and catering platters for both breakfast and office meetings.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Watertown, MA (5 miles away)
Watertown residents love our bagels for family brunches. Our assorted dozen with veggie cream cheese is one of the most popular catering orders.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA (3 miles away)
Perfect for commuters and families, Arlington foodies enjoy our bacon, egg & cheese bagel sandwiches as a hearty start to their mornings.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Medford, MA (2 miles away)
Tufts University students in Medford rely on us for budget-friendly bagels and coffee combos, ideal for late-night study sessions or early morning classes.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Newton, MA (7 miles away)
Newton families often order our catering platters for Sunday brunch or community events. Fresh bagels with cream cheese and lox are always a hit.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Belmont, MA (4 miles away)
Belmont residents appreciate our sesame and poppy seed bagels paired with fresh lox—bringing the New York tradition straight to their tables.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Waltham, MA (8 miles away)
Students at Brandeis University and local professionals in Waltham love our affordable breakfast sandwiches and everything bagels for busy mornings.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA (6 miles away)
Our cinnamon raisin bagels are a JP favorite, often enjoyed with honey walnut cream cheese for a sweet start to the day.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Roslindale, MA (8 miles away)
Roslindale locals enjoy ordering bagel platters for weekend family breakfasts—fresh, chewy, and baked to perfection every morning.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Dorchester, MA (6 miles away)
Dorchester foodies love our everything bagels and hearty sandwiches, perfect for both quick takeout breakfasts and catered office lunches.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Chelsea, MA (5 miles away)
Chelsea residents often order our bagel catering platters for weekend parties or office gatherings. Our lox platter is especially popular.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Everett, MA (4 miles away)
Everett bagel lovers count on our fast delivery service, enjoying plain and sesame bagels with cream cheese for easy breakfasts.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Malden, MA (5 miles away)
Malden locals appreciate our fresh bagels paired with veggie cream cheese, making them a healthy and tasty breakfast choice.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Revere, MA (6 miles away)
Revere residents often grab bagels before heading out for a beach day. Our mini bagel platters are perfect for sharing with friends.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Quincy, MA (10 miles away)
Quincy commuters love our bagels for breakfast on the go. From plain bagels with butter to loaded sandwiches, we keep mornings easy and filling.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, Boston, MA (3 miles away)
Students, baseball fans, and professionals in Fenway-Kenmore love grabbing our bagels before class, work, or a Red Sox game at Fenway Park.

🍱 Popular New York Style Bagels at Somerville Bagel Café

At Somerville Bagel Café, every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh throughout the day, bringing authentic New York flavors to Somerville, MA. Here are some of our customer favorites:

🥯 Classic Hand-Rolled Bagels

Plain Bagel – $1.75
The ultimate classic. Soft, chewy, and golden brown on the outside. Perfect with butter, cream cheese, or as the base of your favorite sandwich.

Everything Bagel – $2.25
Packed with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and a touch of salt. A savory, bold flavor profile that pairs beautifully with cream cheese or smoked salmon.

Sesame Bagel – $2.00
Toasted sesame seeds add a nutty crunch to this New York staple. A customer favorite for breakfast or a mid-day snack.

Poppy Seed Bagel – $2.00
Light, crunchy, and slightly nutty. The ideal pairing for lox and cream cheese—classic and timeless.

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel – $2.25
Sweet, chewy, and dotted with plump raisins. A kid-friendly favorite that also shines with honey walnut cream cheese.

Asiago Cheese Bagel – $2.50
Topped with melted Asiago cheese, this bagel is savory, cheesy, and irresistible when toasted.

🧀 Signature Cream Cheese Spreads

Plain Cream Cheese – $2.50 (add-on)
Smooth, creamy, and freshly whipped daily—the perfect pairing for any bagel.

Scallion Cream Cheese – $3.50 (add-on)
Savory and refreshing, with fresh-cut scallions blended into our creamy base.

Veggie Cream Cheese – $3.75 (add-on)
Loaded with crisp bell peppers, carrots, and celery. A flavorful, crunchy spread that’s both healthy and delicious.

Honey Walnut Cream Cheese – $3.95 (add-on)
A sweet and nutty favorite. Perfect for cinnamon raisin or plain bagels as a morning treat.

Lox Spread – $4.50 (add-on)
Rich, smoky salmon whipped into our signature cream cheese for an indulgent New York classic.

🍳 Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches

Classic Egg & Cheese Bagel – $5.99
Fluffy scrambled eggs with melted American cheese on your choice of bagel. A quick, satisfying breakfast.

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel – $6.99
Crispy bacon layered with eggs and cheese on a fresh-baked bagel. A hearty New England morning favorite.

Sausage, Egg & Cheese Bagel – $6.99
Savory sausage patty, eggs, and melted cheese—served hot and packed with flavor.

Ham, Egg & Cheese Bagel – $6.99
Smoky ham, fluffy eggs, and gooey cheese, tucked inside a warm, chewy bagel.

Veggie Delight Bagel Sandwich – $6.50
Scrambled eggs with spinach, peppers, and onions. A healthy option that doesn’t compromise on taste.

Lox & Cream Cheese Bagel Sandwich – $9.99
Smoked salmon layered with cream cheese, capers, fresh tomato, and red onions—served on your bagel of choice.

🥗 Bagel Platters & Catering

Dozen Bagels (With 2 Cream Cheeses) – $24.99
Choose from a variety of flavors—plain, sesame, everything, poppy seed, or cinnamon raisin. Comes with two fresh cream cheese tubs.

Breakfast Sandwich Platter (6 Sandwiches) – $39.99
Mix and match your favorite breakfast sandwiches—perfect for office meetings or family brunch.

Lox & Bagel Platter (Serves 6) – $54.99
Includes assorted bagels, cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon, fresh tomatoes, onions, and capers. A true New York brunch classic.

Assorted Mini Bagel Platter (24 pieces) – $34.99
Bite-sized bagels paired with cream cheese spreads. Great for parties, events, or study groups.

Family Brunch Bagel Box (Serves 4) – $29.99
Includes 8 bagels, 2 spreads of your choice, and 4 bottled drinks. An easy way to feed the whole family.

🛵 New York Style Bagels – Delivery & Takeout in Somerville, MA

At Somerville Bagel Café, we know that cravings don’t wait. That’s why we make it easy to enjoy fresh, chewy, New York style bagels wherever you are in Somerville or Greater Boston. Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast on your way to class, enjoying a weekend brunch at home, or catering for a large group, our takeout and delivery services are fast, reliable, and convenient.

✅ Hot & Fresh Bagels Every Time

Our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked throughout the day to ensure freshness. When you order delivery or takeout, you can trust that your bagels, sandwiches, and spreads will taste just as good at home as they do in our café.

✅ Secure & Eco-Friendly Packaging

We package every order in sturdy, eco-friendly boxes and spill-proof containers to keep your bagels intact. Whether it’s a single egg sandwich or a large catering platter, your food will arrive neat, fresh, and ready to enjoy.

✅ Quick & Easy Takeout

Pressed for time? Call ahead or order online, and we’ll have your bagels packed and waiting. Our location near Davis Square makes it convenient for both locals and commuters to grab breakfast or lunch on the go.

✅ Reliable Delivery Across Somerville & Beyond

We deliver across Somerville, Cambridge, Medford, Arlington, Boston, and nearby neighborhoods, ensuring your bagels reach you hot and on time. Whether you’re at the office, at home, or on campus, we’ve got you covered.

✅ Catering for Groups & Events

From office breakfasts to family gatherings, our catering menu includes bagel platters, cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon trays, and breakfast sandwich boxes. Large orders can be delivered right to your event—fresh and hassle-free.

✅ Easy Online Ordering

Skip the line and place your order online through our website or delivery apps. Choose your favorite bagels, sandwiches, and spreads, select pickup or delivery, and enjoy a seamless ordering experience with just a few clicks.

🏆 Why Somerville Bagel Café is the Best New York Style Bagel Shop in Somerville, MA

When it comes to finding authentic New York style bagels in Somerville, MA, locals and visitors alike know that Somerville Bagel Café stands out from the rest. Here’s what makes us the top choice for bagel lovers in Davis Square, Tufts University, and across Greater Boston:

✅ 1. True New York Bagel Tradition

We don’t cut corners. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, just like in New York. This process gives our bagels their signature chewy texture inside and golden crisp outside—something chain bagel shops can’t match.

✅ 2. Fresh Ingredients & Wholesome Recipes

From locally sourced flour to farm-fresh toppings, everything we serve is made with quality in mind. Our cream cheese spreads are whipped fresh every day, and our sandwiches are crafted to order. No preservatives, no shortcuts—just honest, wholesome food.

✅ 3. Variety for Every Craving

Our menu goes beyond plain bagels. We offer everything bagels, cinnamon raisin favorites, Asiago cheese bagels, loaded breakfast sandwiches, smoked salmon platters, and vegan-friendly options. Whether you’re craving sweet, savory, or healthy, there’s something for everyone.

✅ 4. Convenient Takeout, Delivery & Catering

Located near Davis Square and Tufts University, we’re a popular stop for both commuters and students. With fast takeout, reliable delivery across Somerville and Boston, and catering platters for offices or family brunches, enjoying bagels has never been easier.

✅ 5. Loved by the Local Community

Somerville residents, Tufts students, and Boston commuters consistently rate us as one of the best bagel shops in Massachusetts. Our 5-star reviews highlight not just our bagels, but also our friendly service, generous portions, and welcoming neighborhood vibe.

⭐ Customer Testimonials – Best New York Style Bagels in Somerville, MA

At Somerville Bagel Café, we’re proud to be the neighborhood favorite for authentic New York style bagels. Here’s what our happy customers from Somerville and nearby cities have to say:

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Megan T. – Somerville, MA
“I live near Davis Square, and this café is my morning ritual. Their everything bagel with scallion cream cheese is the best I’ve had since moving from NYC. The texture is perfect—chewy, crisp, and baked fresh every single day.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Alex R. – Medford, MA
“As a Tufts student, I depend on Somerville Bagel Café for quick, affordable breakfasts before class. Their egg & cheese bagel sandwiches keep me full through lectures. Fast service and always fresh—it’s my go-to spot.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Priyanka S. – Cambridge, MA
“I ordered a dozen bagels with veggie cream cheese for a brunch with friends, and everyone loved them. The bagels were warm, soft, and flavorful. Delivery was right on time, and the packaging kept everything fresh.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
David L. – Boston, MA
“This is hands down the best bagel shop outside of New York. I got the lox and cream cheese bagel, and it was loaded with salmon, capers, and onions. It felt like eating breakfast in Manhattan without leaving Boston.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sarah W. – Arlington, MA
“Our family loves grabbing bagels here on weekends. The kids love cinnamon raisin with honey walnut cream cheese, while my husband and I go for sesame with lox. It’s the perfect family breakfast spot.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Brian C. – Allston, MA
“I work nights and often crave something hearty in the morning. Their bacon, egg & cheese bagel is always hot and filling. The staff is welcoming, and the portions are generous—worth every penny.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel K. – Somerville, MA
“I had friends visiting from New York, and they were blown away by how authentic these bagels are. They couldn’t believe they were eating them in Somerville and not Manhattan. That says it all!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tom H. – Watertown, MA
“I order catering for my office regularly, and their bagel platters are a big hit. Freshly baked bagels with assorted cream cheeses always make our team breakfasts special. Reliable service every time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Olivia D. – Newton, MA
“The Asiago cheese bagel is my absolute favorite. Crispy, cheesy, and so flavorful when toasted. Pair it with their homemade coffee, and you’ve got the perfect start to the day.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Mark A. – Quincy, MA
“I hosted a brunch and ordered their lox & bagel platter—it was incredible. Fresh salmon, capers, onions, and an assortment of bagels that tasted straight out of NYC. My guests were so impressed.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – New York Style Bagels in Somerville, MA

At Somerville Bagel Café, we want every customer to have the best experience possible. Here are answers to some of the most common questions about our bagels, delivery, takeout, and catering:

1. Do you offer bagel delivery in Somerville, MA?

✅ Yes! We provide fast and reliable bagel delivery throughout Somerville, as well as nearby areas including Cambridge, Medford, Arlington, and Boston. All orders are baked fresh, packaged securely, and delivered hot and ready to enjoy. Most deliveries arrive within 30–45 minutes, depending on your location and order size. Whether you’re at Tufts University, working in Davis Square, or relaxing at home, you can count on us for fresh, authentic New York style bagels at your doorstep.

2. How can I order bagels online?

✅ Ordering online is quick and hassle-free. Simply visit our official website or delivery partner apps, browse our menu of bagels, spreads, sandwiches, and catering options, and customize your order. You can choose your bagel flavor, select add-ons like cream cheese or lox, and schedule pickup or delivery. Secure payment options and instant confirmation make the process easy. Many customers also love the option to pre-schedule orders for early morning pickups or weekend brunch.

3. Are your bagels made fresh daily?

✅ Absolutely! Every bagel at Somerville Bagel Café is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh throughout the day. We never serve frozen dough or pre-baked bagels. Instead, we bake in small batches to ensure quality and flavor. This means whether you visit us early in the morning or late in the afternoon, you’re always getting a chewy, golden-crusted bagel that tastes like it came straight from New York. Freshness is our promise to every customer.

4. Do you have vegetarian or vegan options?

✅ Yes! Many of our bagels are naturally vegan, including plain, sesame, poppy seed, and everything bagels. We also offer dairy-free spreads and toppings like avocado and hummus, making it easy for vegan customers to enjoy authentic bagels. For vegetarians, our menu includes egg & cheese sandwiches, veggie cream cheese spreads, and loaded veggie bagel sandwiches. Whether you’re vegan, vegetarian, or just health-conscious, you’ll find plenty of flavorful options on our menu.

5. Can I customize my bagel order?

✅ Definitely! We love when customers make their bagels their own. You can choose your favorite bagel base—plain, sesame, everything, cinnamon raisin, or Asiago—and pair it with spreads like plain cream cheese, scallion, veggie, or lox. For sandwiches, you can build your own with eggs, bacon, sausage, ham, veggies, or salmon. For catering platters, we allow mix-and-match assortments so everyone at your event can enjoy their preferred bagel.

6. How long does takeout usually take?

✅ Takeout orders are typically ready in 10–15 minutes, depending on order size and customization. Smaller orders, like a single bagel with cream cheese, may be ready in less than 10 minutes. Larger catering orders, such as a dozen bagels with spreads or a lox platter, may require additional preparation time. We recommend calling ahead or ordering online for faster service. Our goal is to ensure that every bagel leaves the café hot, fresh, and perfectly packaged for you.

7. Do you offer catering for offices and events?

✅ Yes! Our catering services are popular with local offices, universities, and families hosting gatherings in Somerville and nearby towns. We offer catering platters that include assorted bagels, cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon, and breakfast sandwiches. All catering orders are carefully prepared, packaged securely, and can be delivered directly to your event. Whether it’s an office meeting, a birthday brunch, or a weekend party, we make hosting simple and delicious.

8. Are there gluten-free options available?

✅ While traditional New York style bagels are made with wheat flour, we understand the need for gluten-free options. We offer limited gluten-free bagels in select flavors. These are baked separately to minimize cross-contamination, though we do recommend that highly sensitive individuals check with our staff before ordering. Many of our toppings and spreads, like cream cheese, lox, and veggie fillings, are naturally gluten-free, making it easy to customize your order.

9. Can I schedule my order in advance?

✅ Yes! Our advance ordering option is ideal for busy mornings or planned events. You can schedule both takeout and delivery through our website or by phone. Many customers pre-schedule office breakfasts, family brunches, and even weekend catering orders. This ensures your bagels are ready exactly when you need them—fresh, hot, and packaged to go. Advance ordering also helps us prepare larger catering requests with care and precision.

10. What makes Somerville Bagel Café different from other bagel shops?

✅ Unlike chain bakeries or grocery store bagels, we focus exclusively on authentic New York style preparation. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked on-site, giving it the unique chew and crisp that true bagel lovers expect. Beyond that, we offer a wide range of flavors, freshly made spreads, hearty sandwiches, and catering platters. Our convenient location near Davis Square and Tufts University, combined with fast delivery and 5-star reviews from the local community, make us the most trusted bagel shop in Somerville.

📞 Visit or Order Today

Craving the authentic taste of New York style bagels in Somerville, MA? Whether you’re starting your morning with a plain bagel and cream cheese, enjoying a lox & bagel sandwich for lunch, or catering a weekend brunch, Somerville Bagel Café is your neighborhood destination for fresh, hand-rolled bagels baked daily.