Best New York Style Bagels in Watertown, MA

For anyone who has ever craved the authentic taste of a New York style bagel, you know it’s about more than just breakfast—it’s about tradition. In Watertown, MA, locals no longer have to travel to NYC to get the perfect chewy inside and crispy golden crust that makes a bagel truly unforgettable. Thanks to Watertown Bagel House, residents can enjoy bagels made fresh every morning using the classic New York method: hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked to perfection.

At Watertown Bagel House, every customer can find their favorite flavor—whether it’s a plain bagel with butter, an everything bagel loaded with cream cheese, or a smoked salmon sandwich with all the fixings. Beyond the classics, the café also offers hearty breakfast sandwiches, flavored cream cheese spreads, and bagel catering platters that make family brunches, office meetings, and community gatherings effortless and delicious.

Conveniently located near Arsenal Street, Watertown Bagel House has become a go-to destination for families, professionals, and students looking for quick takeout, reliable delivery, or sit-down breakfasts that feel like home. With a strong focus on freshness, flavor, and tradition, this café proudly brings the spirit of New York bagels to Watertown.

Restaurant Details:

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

✅ Why Choose Our New York Style Bagels in Watertown, MA?

When it comes to New York style bagels in Watertown, MA, customers want more than just a quick snack—they expect authenticity, freshness, and quality service. At Watertown Bagel House, we deliver all three and more. Here’s why we’re the local favorite:

🥯 Authentic New York Bagel Tradition
Our bagels are crafted using the time-honored New York method—hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh every day. This ensures that signature chewy interior and crisp golden crust that true bagel lovers crave.

🌱 Made with Fresh, High-Quality Ingredients
From locally sourced flour to fresh produce, every bagel and spread is prepared with care. We never use frozen dough or artificial preservatives—only wholesome, high-quality ingredients.

🍳 Delicious Variety for Every Taste
Whether you’re a fan of plain, sesame, or everything bagels, or prefer a loaded bacon-egg-cheese sandwich, our menu has something for everyone. We also offer flavored cream cheeses, lox platters, and sweet options like cinnamon raisin.

👨‍👩‍👧 Perfect for Families & Professionals
Conveniently located on Arsenal Street, we’re an easy breakfast stop for commuters, a weekend brunch spot for families, and a reliable option for professionals needing quick takeout.

🚴 Takeout, Delivery & Catering Services
From single orders to large gatherings, we make bagels accessible everywhere. Whether you want a fast takeout breakfast, reliable delivery in Watertown, or catering for an office meeting, we’ve got you covered.

⭐ Trusted by the Local Community
Our 5-star reviews from Watertown residents highlight not only the authenticity of our bagels but also our friendly staff, generous portions, and welcoming neighborhood vibe.

📍 New York Style Bagels in Watertown, MA & Nearby Cities

One of the reasons Watertown Bagel House is a local favorite is our prime location on Arsenal Street, which allows us to serve customers not only in Watertown but also across Greater Boston. Here’s a look at the cities and neighborhoods we proudly serve with our fresh New York style bagels:

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Allston, MA (4 miles away)
Allston’s student community loves grabbing our fresh bagels before class or late-night study sessions. Our everything bagel with cream cheese is especially popular with young professionals and college students.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Cambridge, MA (3 miles away)
With Harvard and MIT nearby, Cambridge residents often stop by for quick breakfast takeout. Our lox & bagel sandwich with scallion cream cheese is a favorite among students and faculty.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Brookline, MA (5 miles away)
Brookline families love our dozen bagel platters with assorted cream cheeses, perfect for weekend brunches and office meetings.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Somerville, MA (4 miles away)
Somerville foodies and Tufts students enjoy our loaded egg & cheese sandwiches for a hearty start to the day.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Boston, MA (6 miles away)
From Back Bay to Fenway, Boston professionals and commuters trust us for fresh bagels and coffee on busy mornings. Our catering platters are popular for office events.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Watertown, MA (local)
Right here at home, we’re the go-to bagel shop for families, professionals, and weekend brunch lovers who want authentic New York style bagels baked fresh daily.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA (5 miles away)
Arlington commuters often grab a sesame bagel with bacon, egg, and cheese on their way to work. Quick, filling, and always fresh.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Medford, MA (6 miles away)
Tufts University students in Medford rely on our affordable bagel-and-coffee combos to power through busy study schedules.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Newton, MA (5 miles away)
Newton families enjoy our bagel brunch boxes, which include a mix of bagels, cream cheese spreads, and drinks—ideal for Sunday mornings.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Belmont, MA (4 miles away)
Belmont locals love our poppy seed bagels with veggie cream cheese, a healthy and satisfying breakfast option.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Waltham, MA (6 miles away)
Brandeis University students and local professionals enjoy our mini bagel platters, perfect for group meetings and gatherings.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA (7 miles away)
JP residents enjoy sweet options like our cinnamon raisin bagels with honey walnut cream cheese, perfect for a morning treat.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Roslindale, MA (8 miles away)
Families in Roslindale love our assorted dozen bagels for weekend breakfasts. Fresh, chewy, and paired with creamy spreads, they make mornings easy.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Dorchester, MA (8 miles away)
Dorchester foodies enjoy our everything bagels and breakfast sandwiches, which are perfect for both weekday takeout and weekend brunch.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Chelsea, MA (7 miles away)
Chelsea professionals often order our lox & bagel catering platters for office meetings and special events.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Everett, MA (6 miles away)
Everett residents love our plain and sesame bagels with cream cheese, a classic New York breakfast that’s always satisfying.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Malden, MA (8 miles away)
Malden customers often go for our veggie-loaded bagel sandwiches, making healthy mornings tasty and filling.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Revere, MA (9 miles away)
Revere locals love taking our mini bagel platters to the beach—easy to share, portable, and delicious.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Quincy, MA (12 miles away)
Quincy commuters rely on our breakfast bagel sandwiches for quick and hearty meals before heading into Boston.

🥯 New York Style Bagels in Fenway-Kenmore, Boston, MA (5 miles away)
Students, baseball fans, and professionals in Fenway enjoy our bagels as the perfect pre-game snack or study fuel.

🍱 Popular New York Style Bagels at Watertown Bagel House

At Watertown Bagel House, we specialize in bringing the authentic taste of New York style bagels to the heart of Watertown, MA. Each bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, giving you that perfect balance of chewy interior and crisp golden crust. Here’s a look at our most popular items:

🥯 Classic Bagels – Hand-Rolled & Freshly Baked

Plain Bagel – $1.75
A timeless favorite. Chewy, warm, and perfect with butter, cream cheese, or made into your favorite sandwich.

Everything Bagel – $2.25
Loaded with sesame, poppy seeds, onion, garlic, and salt. Packed with flavor, this is the king of all bagels.

Sesame Bagel – $2.00
Nutty and toasty sesame seeds give this bagel a classic crunch that pairs beautifully with lox or cream cheese.

Poppy Seed Bagel – $2.00
Delicate crunch and nutty flavor make this a perfect choice for anyone who loves a traditional New York breakfast.

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel – $2.25
A slightly sweet favorite with chewy raisins baked in. Perfect when paired with honey walnut cream cheese.

Asiago Cheese Bagel – $2.50
Topped with golden melted Asiago cheese. Crispy on the outside, cheesy and savory with every bite.

🧀 Cream Cheese & Specialty Spreads

Plain Cream Cheese – $2.50 (add-on)
Freshly whipped daily, smooth, and creamy. A classic for any bagel lover.

Scallion Cream Cheese – $3.50 (add-on)
Creamy base blended with fresh scallions for a savory kick.

Veggie Cream Cheese – $3.75 (add-on)
Loaded with crunchy peppers, carrots, and celery—fresh, flavorful, and healthy.

Honey Walnut Cream Cheese – $3.95 (add-on)
A sweet, nutty spread that pairs beautifully with raisin or plain bagels.

Lox Spread – $4.50 (add-on)
A luxurious blend of smoked salmon and cream cheese. Rich, smoky, and indulgent—New York in a bite.

🍳 Breakfast Sandwiches

Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich – $5.99
Fluffy scrambled eggs with melted cheese on your choice of bagel. Simple, classic, and filling.

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel – $6.99
Crispy bacon layered with eggs and melted cheese. A hearty favorite for morning commuters.

Sausage, Egg & Cheese Bagel – $6.99
Savory sausage paired with eggs and cheese—comfort food you’ll want every morning.

Ham, Egg & Cheese Bagel – $6.99
Smoky ham layered with eggs and cheese on a fresh bagel. Perfect for protein-packed mornings.

Veggie Breakfast Bagel – $6.50
A healthy mix of eggs, spinach, onions, and peppers inside your favorite bagel. Light, fresh, and satisfying.

Lox & Bagel Sandwich – $9.99
The classic New York experience: smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomatoes, capers, and red onion, all served on your bagel of choice.

🥗 Bagel Platters & Catering Specials

Dozen Bagels with Cream Cheese (2 spreads included) – $24.99
Choose from plain, sesame, everything, poppy seed, cinnamon raisin, and more. Comes with two tubs of fresh cream cheese.

Breakfast Sandwich Platter (6 Sandwiches) – $39.99
Mix & match your favorite breakfast sandwiches—great for offices, meetings, or family gatherings.

Lox & Bagel Platter (Serves 6) – $54.99
Includes assorted bagels, cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon, tomatoes, onions, and capers. A true brunch classic.

Mini Bagel Platter (24 bite-sized bagels) – $34.99
Miniature versions of our hand-rolled bagels, paired with spreads—perfect for parties and casual gatherings.

Family Brunch Bagel Box (Serves 4) – $29.99
Includes 8 bagels, 2 cream cheese spreads, and 4 bottled drinks. Convenient and affordable for family mornings.

🛵 New York Style Bagels – Delivery & Takeout in Watertown, MA

At Watertown Bagel House, we know mornings can be busy. That’s why we make it easy to enjoy authentic New York style bagels with our fast and convenient takeout and delivery services across Watertown and Greater Boston. Whether it’s a quick breakfast before work, a family brunch, or catering for your office, we’ve got you covered.

✅ Hot & Fresh Bagels Every Time

Our bagels are boiled and baked fresh throughout the day, so you’ll never get a stale bite. Delivery and takeout orders are prepared just like dine-in, ensuring your bagels are chewy inside, crispy outside, and packed with flavor.

✅ Secure & Eco-Friendly Packaging

We take care to package every order with sturdy, eco-friendly materials that keep your bagels warm and intact. No flattened sandwiches, no spills—just perfect bagels every time.

✅ Quick & Easy Takeout

Running late? No problem. Call ahead or order online, and your bagels will be ready for pickup when you arrive. Our location on Arsenal Street makes it easy for commuters and residents to swing by for grab-and-go breakfast or lunch.

✅ Reliable Delivery Across Watertown & Beyond

We proudly deliver not only in Watertown but also to Newton, Belmont, Waltham, Arlington, Boston, and nearby towns. Whether you’re at the office, at home, or on campus, your bagels arrive hot, fresh, and right on schedule.

✅ Catering for Meetings & Events

From office breakfasts to weekend family gatherings, our catering platters make feeding a group simple and stress-free. Choose from bagel assortments, cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon platters, or sandwich boxes—delivered directly to your event.

✅ Easy Online Ordering

Ordering your favorite bagels is just a click away. Visit our website, select your bagels, spreads, or catering items, and choose pickup or delivery. With secure payment and instant confirmation, it’s the fastest way to bring New York style bagels to your table.

🏆 Why Watertown Bagel House is the Best New York Style Bagel Shop in Watertown, MA

When it comes to enjoying authentic New York style bagels in Watertown, MA, locals know there’s one place that always delivers: Watertown Bagel House. Here’s what makes us stand out as the community’s favorite:

✅ 1. Authentic New York Style Preparation

We don’t just bake bagels—we honor tradition. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, following the classic New York recipe. This method gives our bagels the chewy texture and golden crust that true bagel lovers crave. Unlike supermarket bagels or chain shops, ours taste exactly the way bagels should—authentic and unforgettable.

✅ 2. Fresh, Quality Ingredients in Every Bite

At Watertown Bagel House, we believe fresh ingredients make the difference. From locally sourced flour to farm-fresh toppings, every bagel, spread, and sandwich is made with care. Our cream cheeses are whipped daily, our sandwiches are built to order, and we never use frozen dough or artificial preservatives. Every bite is wholesome, hearty, and full of flavor.

✅ 3. Wide Variety of Flavors & Options

We offer something for everyone. From classics like plain, sesame, and everything bagels to sweet favorites like cinnamon raisin and savory specialties like Asiago cheese, there’s a flavor for every craving. Add in our signature cream cheese spreads, breakfast sandwiches, and catering platters, and you’ve got endless options to satisfy families, students, and professionals alike.

✅ 4. Convenient Takeout, Delivery & Catering

We make bagels easy and accessible for everyone in Watertown and Greater Boston. Whether you’re stopping by for quick takeout on Arsenal Street, ordering delivery for a work-from-home day, or scheduling catering for an office meeting or weekend brunch, our team ensures your bagels arrive hot, fresh, and right on time.

✅ 5. Trusted by the Watertown Community

Our customers say it best. With 5-star reviews from families, professionals, and students, we’ve built a reputation as the go-to bagel shop in Watertown. Locals love our generous portions, fast service, and authentic flavors. For many, visiting Watertown Bagel House isn’t just about breakfast—it’s a tradition.

⭐ Customer Testimonials – Best New York Style Bagels in Watertown, MA

At Watertown Bagel House, our community is the heart of everything we do. Here’s what our happy customers are saying about their bagel experience with us:

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Emily R. – Watertown, MA
“I’ve been coming here every Saturday with my kids, and it’s become our family tradition. The bagels are chewy, fresh, and baked to perfection. My kids love the cinnamon raisin with honey walnut cream cheese, while I go for the lox and bagel platter—always generous and flavorful.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
James K. – Newton, MA
“As a commuter, I rely on Watertown Bagel House for quick breakfast takeout before work. Their bacon, egg & cheese bagel keeps me full until lunch, and the staff always greets me with a smile. Convenient, fresh, and way better than chain bagel shops.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Priya S. – Belmont, MA
“I hosted a brunch and ordered their dozen bagel platter with cream cheeses. Everyone raved about how fresh and authentic they tasted. It was such an easy way to entertain without spending hours in the kitchen. Delivery was on time and perfectly packaged.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
David L. – Boston, MA
“Finally, a place outside of New York that makes real bagels! The chewiness, the crust, the flavor—it’s all spot on. I especially love the Asiago cheese bagel, toasted with veggie cream cheese. It’s my guilty pleasure every weekend.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Samantha W. – Watertown, MA
“Whenever I have friends visiting from out of town, I bring them here. Everyone agrees these bagels taste just like the ones in Manhattan. The staff is friendly, the café is cozy, and the food is consistently excellent.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Brian C. – Waltham, MA
“I order catering for my office at least once a month, and Watertown Bagel House never disappoints. The platters arrive fresh, neatly arranged, and always impress my colleagues. The lox platter is a favorite at every meeting.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Olivia M. – Cambridge, MA
“As a grad student, I’m always on the lookout for affordable but filling meals. Their egg & cheese bagel sandwiches are perfect—delicious, budget-friendly, and ready fast. It’s my go-to breakfast spot before long study days.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tom H. – Arlington, MA
“The mini bagel platter is a lifesaver for family gatherings. Everyone gets to pick their favorite without fighting over flavors. The spreads are fresh, the bagels stay warm, and it makes hosting stress-free. Highly recommend!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel D. – Watertown, MA
“This is the kind of place that remembers your name and your order. The staff makes you feel like family, and the bagels are out of this world. My personal favorite is the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese—it’s unbeatable.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Mark S. – Quincy, MA
“I ordered delivery, and the bagels arrived hot and perfectly packaged. No spills, no mess—just authentic, flavorful bagels that reminded me of growing up in New York. Watertown Bagel House is truly the real deal.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – New York Style Bagels in Watertown, MA

At Watertown Bagel House, we know our customers love to learn more about how we prepare and serve authentic New York style bagels. Here are answers to some of the most common questions we receive:

1. Do you offer delivery in Watertown, MA?

✅ Yes! We provide fast and reliable bagel delivery across Watertown and nearby towns including Belmont, Newton, Waltham, and Boston. Orders arrive fresh, warm, and neatly packaged to preserve quality. Delivery typically takes 30–45 minutes, depending on your location and order size. Whether it’s a weekday breakfast, a family brunch, or a large catering order, we make sure your bagels arrive on time and ready to enjoy.

2. Are your bagels made fresh daily?

✅ Absolutely! Our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh every single day using the traditional New York method. We bake in small batches throughout the morning and afternoon, ensuring that every customer gets a bagel that’s soft, chewy, and golden-crusted. Unlike supermarket bagels or chain cafés, ours are never frozen or reheated. Freshness and authenticity are at the heart of everything we serve.

3. What types of bagels do you offer?

✅ We have a wide variety of bagel flavors to satisfy every craving. Classics include plain, sesame, poppy seed, and everything bagels, while favorites like cinnamon raisin and Asiago cheese add a twist. Our menu also features specialty spreads such as scallion cream cheese, veggie cream cheese, and honey walnut, along with loaded breakfast sandwiches and smoked salmon platters. No matter your taste—sweet, savory, or hearty—we’ve got you covered.

4. Do you have vegetarian or vegan options?

✅ Yes! Many of our bagels, including plain, sesame, and everything, are naturally vegan. We also offer toppings like hummus, avocado, and veggie spreads that are plant-based. For vegetarians, our menu includes a wide range of egg & cheese sandwiches, veggie bagel sandwiches, and flavored cream cheeses. Whether you’re vegan, vegetarian, or simply health-conscious, you’ll find plenty of satisfying options on our menu.

5. Can I customize my bagel sandwich?

✅ Definitely! We love when customers personalize their bagels. Start with your favorite bagel flavor, then add spreads like plain cream cheese, scallion, or lox. You can also build a hearty sandwich with eggs, bacon, sausage, ham, veggies, or smoked salmon. For catering platters, we offer mix-and-match assortments so everyone at your event can enjoy their favorite combination.

6. How long does takeout usually take?

✅ Takeout orders are typically ready in 10–15 minutes, depending on the size and complexity of your order. A single bagel with cream cheese may be ready in under 10 minutes, while larger catering boxes or platters may take longer. Ordering online or calling ahead ensures that your food is prepared and waiting for you when you arrive. Our convenient Arsenal Street location makes takeout simple for Watertown commuters and families.

7. Do you provide catering for offices and events?

✅ Yes! Our catering services are one of our most popular offerings. We provide bagel platters, cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon trays, and breakfast sandwich boxes—all perfect for offices, family gatherings, or weekend brunches. Orders are packaged securely and can be delivered directly to your event. With generous portions and fresh ingredients, we make catering stress-free and delicious.

8. Do you offer gluten-free options?

✅ We understand the need for gluten-free alternatives and do our best to provide them. Select gluten-free bagel options are available on request. While we bake them separately to minimize cross-contamination, we recommend highly sensitive individuals speak with our staff before ordering. Many of our toppings, spreads, and proteins are naturally gluten-free, allowing you to create a bagel combination that fits your dietary needs.

9. Can I schedule my order ahead of time?

✅ Yes! With our advance ordering option, you can schedule takeout, delivery, or catering for a specific time. This is especially popular for busy commuters who want a ready-to-go breakfast, as well as families and offices planning weekend brunches or morning meetings. Pre-scheduled orders guarantee your bagels are fresh, packaged, and waiting when you need them—making mornings smoother and events more enjoyable.

10. What makes Watertown Bagel House different from other bagel shops?

✅ Unlike chain shops or grocery store bagels, Watertown Bagel House stays true to New York tradition. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked in-house for authentic texture and flavor. We go beyond just plain bagels—offering specialty spreads, hearty sandwiches, catering platters, and even sweet options like cinnamon raisin with honey walnut cream cheese. Combined with our Arsenal Street convenience, fast delivery, and 5-star local reviews, we’re proud to be Watertown’s trusted bagel destination.

📞 Visit or Order Today

Craving the authentic taste of New York style bagels in Watertown, MA? Whether you’re starting your morning with a plain bagel and cream cheese, enjoying a lox sandwich for lunch, or catering brunch for family and colleagues, Watertown Bagel House is your local destination for freshly baked, hand-rolled bagels.