Fresh Breakfast Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

There’s nothing quite like starting your day with a warm, fresh bagel, and in Jamaica Plain, MA, locals know just where to go—NY Bagel & Coffee Co. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite on the way to work, a hearty breakfast sandwich to power through your morning, or a comforting coffee-and-bagel combo for a relaxed weekend, our menu has you covered.

At NY Bagel & Coffee Co., we’re proud to bring authentic New York–style bagels to the Jamaica Plain community. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, giving you that perfect chewy center and golden crust that bagel lovers crave. From classics like Plain and Everything Bagels to flavorful favorites like Asiago, Cinnamon Raisin, and Multigrain, there’s a bagel for every mood.

Our menu goes far beyond bagels—we also serve breakfast sandwiches, vegan and vegetarian options, and even breakfast pizzas for those who want something extra hearty. Paired with freshly brewed coffee or a specialty latte, every visit promises a delicious start to your day.

If you’re searching for the best breakfast bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA, NY Bagel & Coffee Co. is the neighborhood favorite ready to serve you fresh, fast, and with a smile.

Restaurant Info

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

✅ Why Choose Us for Fresh Breakfast Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

🥯 1. Freshly Baked Bagels, Every Single Day

In Jamaica Plain, our customers deserve nothing less than the best. That’s why we bake our bagels fresh daily, using traditional New York–style methods—hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and oven-baked. The result is a bagel with the perfect chewy bite and golden crust every time.

☕ 2. More Than Just Bagels – A Complete Breakfast Experience

We don’t stop at bagels. Our menu includes hearty breakfast sandwiches, vegan and vegetarian specialties, and even breakfast pizzas for when you’re craving something unique. Pair your choice with freshly brewed coffee, and you’ll have a complete meal to fuel your day.

🌱 3. Options for Every Lifestyle

Jamaica Plain is home to a diverse, health-conscious community, and we proudly reflect that in our menu. From multigrain and whole wheat bagels to vegan spreads, plant-based sandwiches, and classic favorites, there’s something for every diet and preference.

👨‍👩‍👧 4. A Go-To Spot for Families, Students & Professionals

Whether you’re a family heading out for weekend breakfast, a student grabbing a quick bite, or a professional needing coffee and a sandwich before work, our location and service make it easy. We’re built for speed, convenience, and comfort.

🚗 5. Quick Takeout & Reliable Delivery in Jamaica Plain

Life moves fast, but that doesn’t mean you should sacrifice flavor. Our streamlined takeout service and dependable delivery ensure you enjoy hot, fresh bagels without the wait. From breakfast at home to office orders, we bring great taste right to you.

⭐ 6. Trusted Quality Loved by Locals

What sets us apart is consistency. Jamaica Plain residents know they can count on us for the same fresh taste, friendly service, and quality ingredients every visit. That’s why so many of our first-time guests become loyal regulars.

🗺️ Serving Nearby Cities

Allston, MA
Right in the heart of Allston, we’re the go-to spot for fresh bagels, sandwiches, and coffee. Perfect for students, professionals, and families craving quick, delicious breakfasts.

Cambridge, MA
From Harvard to MIT, Cambridge locals love our New York–style bagels and hearty breakfast sandwiches. Fresh, fast, and satisfying for busy mornings or late-night study sessions.

Brookline, MA
Brookline residents count on us for wholesome bagels, vegan sandwiches, and breakfast pizzas. A great choice for quick breakfasts, family brunches, or grab-and-go meals.

Somerville, MA
Somerville’s foodies and students enjoy our wide selection of bagels, sandwiches, and coffee. Always fresh, always ready—perfect for early mornings or busy afternoons.

Boston, MA
From downtown to Back Bay, Boston professionals and families love our bagels and breakfast pizzas. A quick, reliable stop for anyone needing flavor and freshness on the go.

Watertown, MA
Watertown locals enjoy our freshly baked bagels, hearty breakfast sandwiches, and coffee. Whether for morning commutes or weekend brunch, we’re a neighborhood favorite.

Arlington, MA
In Arlington, our bagels are a daily ritual. From sesame to cinnamon raisin, plus vegan options and breakfast pizzas, there’s something for every appetite.

Medford, MA
Close to Tufts University, Medford students and residents count on us for bagels, sandwiches, and coffee that keep them energized through busy schedules.

Newton, MA
Newton families and professionals love our multigrain bagels, smoked salmon sandwiches, and fresh coffee. A reliable choice for healthy, filling breakfasts.

Belmont, MA
Belmont locals savor our variety—from plain bagels to indulgent breakfast pizzas. Perfect for weekday mornings, weekend gatherings, or late-night bites.

Waltham, MA
Right nearby, Waltham customers enjoy bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and pizzas baked fresh daily. A trusted stop for flavor, quality, and convenience.

Jamaica Plain, MA
JP’s vibrant community loves our plant-based options, classic bagels, and coffee. Perfect for quick breakfasts or relaxed weekend mornings with friends.

Roslindale, MA
Roslindale families and professionals choose us for hot, fresh bagels and hearty breakfast pizzas. A favorite for both dine-in and takeout mornings.

Dorchester, MA
Dorchester locals love our authentic bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast pizzas. Always fresh, always satisfying—perfect for any time of day.

Chelsea, MA
Chelsea customers enjoy our classic bagels, vegan options, and loaded sandwiches. A convenient spot for breakfast, lunch, or late-night cravings.

Everett, MA
Everett residents turn to us for hearty bagels, sandwiches, and coffee that’s always fresh. Quick, reliable, and full of flavor for busy mornings.

Malden, MA
In Malden, our bagels and breakfast sandwiches are a daily staple. Nutritious, delicious, and perfect for families, students, and commuters.

Revere, MA
Revere locals know us for hot, chewy bagels and rich coffee. Whether plain, sesame, or everything bagels, we’ve got your cravings covered.

Quincy, MA
Quincy residents enjoy our bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast pizzas made fresh daily. Quick service and consistent flavor make us a trusted choice.

Fenway-Kenmore, MA
From students to sports fans, Fenway-Kenmore customers love our bagels, sandwiches, and vegan options. Perfect before a Red Sox game or after classes.

🥯 Menu Highlights – Fresh Breakfast Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

🥯 Freshly Baked Bagels

Plain Bagel – $3.10
The classic New York–style bagel done right. Boiled and baked fresh every morning, it delivers the perfect chewy inside with a golden-brown crust. In Jamaica Plain, it’s a customer favorite topped with cream cheese, butter, or any spread you like—simple, timeless, and satisfying.

Everything Bagel – $3.10
A flavor-packed choice loaded with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and sea salt. The “everything in one bite” bagel is a Jamaica Plain favorite for breakfast sandwiches, cream cheese pairings, or layered with smoked salmon for a gourmet twist.

Sesame Bagel – $3.10
Lightly toasted sesame seeds give this bagel a nutty aroma and gentle crunch. JP locals enjoy it as a snack with hummus, or as a full meal stacked with avocado, egg, and cheese for a hearty breakfast.

Asiago Bagel – $3.10
Cheese lovers rejoice! This bagel is baked with savory Asiago cheese that melts into a crispy, golden top while keeping the inside soft and chewy. A popular Jamaica Plain pick with butter, spreads, or in a breakfast sandwich.

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel – $3.10
A sweet and wholesome favorite. Warm cinnamon blended with plump raisins makes this bagel taste like dessert for breakfast. Delicious toasted with cream cheese, honey, or butter—perfect for cozy mornings in Jamaica Plain.

Onion Bagel – $3.10
Bold, savory, and aromatic. Our Onion Bagel is topped with baked onion pieces that add flavor to every bite. JP residents love it as the base for hearty sandwiches, where its robust taste elevates the fillings.

Whole Wheat Bagel – $3.10
A healthy choice for those who want flavor and nutrition together. Made with whole grains, this bagel is rich in fiber yet soft and chewy. Pair it with veggie spreads or lean proteins for a guilt-free breakfast.

Multigrain Bagel – $3.10
Nutty, seedy, and packed with wholesome grains, this bagel fuels your day the right way. It’s an energizing option for Jamaica Plain’s health-conscious community, often topped with avocado, fresh veggies, or light spreads.

🥯 Signature Bagel Sandwiches – Breakfast Favorites

1 Gordon Street: Bagel & Cream Cheese – $5.45
A timeless classic: a freshly baked bagel with smooth, creamy cream cheese. Simple, comforting, and always satisfying—a favorite for Jamaica Plain locals who love tradition.

2 Chester Street: Make Your Own Breakfast Sandwich – $9.99
Build your perfect bite. Choose your favorite bagel, eggs, cheese, and proteins to create a sandwich made just for you. A JP bestseller for customers who want breakfast their way.

3 Braintree Street: Egg White, Avocado & Veggies – $10.25
Light, fresh, and packed with flavor. Cage-free egg whites, creamy avocado, cucumber, tomato, and sprouts come together with Parmesan Peppercorn dressing—a nutritious hit in Jamaica Plain.

4 Ashford Street: Ham, Turkey & Veggie Delight – $10.99
Savory ham and roasted turkey layered with fresh veggies, feta cheese, and cage-free eggs. A hearty sandwich JP residents love for its balanced flavors and satisfying portions.

5 Adamson Street: Turkey, Bacon & Honey Dijon – $10.45
Smoky bacon, roasted turkey, sharp cheddar, Swiss, and cage-free eggs, finished with tangy honey Dijon. A bold Jamaica Plain favorite for mornings when you need something extra.

6 Alcott Street: Bacon, Roast Beef & BBQ Sauce – $10.45
This sandwich packs a punch—bacon, roast beef, eggs, cheese, and BBQ sauce combine for a smoky, savory bite. JP locals rave about it as a filling meal on the go.

7 Everett Street: Sausage, Ham & Chipotle Mayo – $10.45
A smoky and savory delight with sausage, ham, provolone cheese, and chipotle mayo. Bold and flavorful, it’s a top choice for those who like a little spice with breakfast.

8 Alcorn Street: Spicy Sausage & Jalapeños – $10.45
Turn up the heat with this fiery combo of sausage, bacon, sharp cheddar, jalapeños, and sweet-spicy sauce. Jamaica Plain spice lovers can’t get enough.

9 Kelton Street: Smoked Salmon Classic – $13.45
A true deli-style favorite. Smoked salmon layered with cream cheese, tomato, cucumber, onions, sprouts, and capers for a fresh, gourmet breakfast experience.

10 Armington Street: Smoked Salmon Spread – $14.99
Double the salmon flavor. Featuring Acme smoked salmon, salmon spread, crisp veggies, and peppercorn dressing, this sandwich is a luxurious JP choice.

11 Cambridge Street: Build Your Egg & Cheese – $8.45
A flexible classic—choose your bagel, eggs, and cheese, then add extra toppings to build your ideal breakfast sandwich. A hit with busy JP commuters.

11a Yellow River White Fish Salad Sandwich – $13.99
Creamy white fish salad paired with tomato, onion, capers, and pepper. Fresh, savory, and a favorite among JP seafood lovers.

11b Amur River Tuna Salad Sandwich – $13.99
Tuna salad with mozzarella, onions, tomato, and chili paste, served on a fresh bagel. A protein-packed sandwich that works for both breakfast and lunch.

🥯 Vegan Bagel Sandwiches

12 Franklin Street – $12.99
Avocado, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, vegan cheddar, mustard, and vegan spread. A vibrant, plant-based sandwich loved in Jamaica Plain.

13 Fuller Street – $11.99
Vegan sausage, cheddar, jalapeños, onions, peppers, and sweet-spicy sauce for a smoky, bold breakfast option.

14 Holman Street – $11.99
Fresh and light: hummus, avocado, tomato, lettuce, and sprouts. Perfect for JP’s health-conscious foodies.

15 Holmes Street – $12.99
Vegan sausage, cheddar, BBQ sauce, hummus, and veggies. A hearty, smoky choice with bold flavors.

16 Mansfield Street – $12.99
Sweet indulgence—French fig jam, vegan cream cheese, berries, and vegan honey. A unique breakfast treat in Jamaica Plain.

17 Holton Street – $12.99
Decadent Vegan Nutella with cream cheese and berries, dusted with sugar. Sweet, rich, and a must-try vegan dessert sandwich.

🥯 Vegetarian Bagel Sandwiches

18 Ridgemont Street – $12.99
Provolone, cream cheese, cucumber, peppers, lettuce, tomato, and ranch. A refreshing veggie-packed sandwich.

19 Riverdale Street – $13.99
Loaded with Gouda, Havarti, Provolone, and Parmesan, plus plant-based sausage and chipotle mayo. Cheesy and bold.

20 Wilton Street – $12.99
Avocado, Havarti cheese, jalapeños, lettuce, and crunchy potato chips. Creamy, tangy, and crunchy all in one bite.

21 Windom Street – $12.99
An Italian-inspired favorite with mozzarella, pesto, tomato, lettuce, and balsamic vinaigrette. Fresh and flavorful.

22 Arthur Street – $12.99
Havarti cheese, avocado, veggies, and parmesan peppercorn dressing. Wholesome and filling for JP’s veggie lovers.

🍕 Breakfast Pizza Specials

Simple Egg & Cheese – $13.99
A comforting favorite with tomato base, mozzarella, scrambled eggs, and parmesan.

Classic Bacon & Egg – $14.99
Blue cheese sauce, eggs, bacon, mozzarella, and oregano for a smoky, savory start.

Sausage Sunrise – $14.99
A creamy white base with sausage, onions, parsley, and eggs—hearty and satisfying.

Chicken & Mozzarella Morning – $14.99
Ranch base with chicken, eggs, mozzarella, and tomato. A protein-packed favorite.

The Works Breakfast Pizza – $15.99
Fully loaded with sausage, bacon, chicken, eggs, peppers, and truffle oil.

Spicy Bacon & Sausage – $14.99
Chipotle marinara topped with bacon, sausage, eggs, mozzarella, and jalapeños.

Chicken Florentine – $14.99
White sauce with chicken, spinach, feta, and mozzarella for a fresh, savory twist.

Maple Bacon Bliss – $14.99
Olive oil base with eggs, bacon, pesto, and a maple drizzle. Sweet meets savory.

Loaded Meat Lovers Morning – $15.99
Bacon, sausage, chicken, eggs, mozzarella, and parmesan—perfect for big appetites.

BBQ Chicken Breakfast Pizza – $14.99
Ranch base topped with chicken, eggs, onions, mozzarella, and BBQ sauce.

Veggie & Meat Medley – $16.99
Sausage, bacon, mushrooms, tomatoes, peppers, eggs, and mozzarella with garlic olive oil.

🚗 Delivery & Takeout – Fresh Breakfast Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

✅ Freshly Baked, Packed with Care

Every bagel and sandwich is baked fresh and prepared to order. We use eco-friendly, secure packaging so that your bagels arrive just as warm, chewy, and flavorful as they left our oven. No soggy bread, no loss of freshness.

✅ Breakfast Without the Wait

Mornings in Jamaica Plain are busy, so we’ve made takeout simple. Order ahead online or by phone, and your bagel, coffee, or sandwich will be ready for pickup—perfect for commuters heading into Boston or students rushing to class.

✅ Reliable Delivery Across Jamaica Plain

Whether you’re working from home, relaxing on Centre Street, or enjoying time with family, our delivery service brings your favorites straight to your doorstep. Always hot, always on time, and always satisfying.

✅ Options That Fit Every Lifestyle

From classic bagels to vegan sandwiches and hearty breakfast pizzas, our menu caters to all diets. Delivery and takeout make it easy for Jamaica Plain’s diverse community to enjoy breakfast that feels made just for them.

✅ Open Late for Cravings Anytime

Not just a morning stop—our kitchen runs until 2:00 AM daily. Whether you want a plain bagel at sunrise or a smoky breakfast pizza after a night out, we’re here to serve Jamaica Plain day and night.

✅ Community Favorite for Quick, Tasty Meals

We’ve become a local go-to because we balance speed with quality. Families, students, and professionals in Jamaica Plain trust us for meals that are quick to grab but never feel rushed or mass-produced.

🏆 Why We’re the Best for Fresh Breakfast Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

🥯 1. Neighborhood Vibes with Big-City Flavor

Jamaica Plain is known for its community feel, and we embrace that spirit by serving bagels that taste just like the best New York bakeries—but with the warmth and friendliness JP locals expect from a neighborhood favorite.

🧑‍🍳 2. Authentic Recipes with a Modern Twist

Our bagels are hand-rolled and kettle-boiled the traditional way, but we don’t stop there. From vegan spreads to breakfast pizzas, we’ve modernized the menu to match Jamaica Plain’s diverse, food-loving community.

☕ 3. Perfect Pairings for Every Craving

It’s not just about the bagels. From specialty lattes and iced coffees to hearty sandwiches and breakfast pizzas, every item is designed to complement your bagel experience. JP residents know they can enjoy a complete meal, not just a snack.

🌱 4. Inclusive Menu for a Diverse Community

Jamaica Plain is home to families, professionals, students, and health-conscious foodies. That’s why our menu includes vegan, vegetarian, and whole-grain options alongside classic favorites—so nobody has to compromise.

🚴 5. Fast Service Without Cutting Corners

Whether you’re grabbing takeout before work, ordering delivery at home, or stopping by after a workout in Jamaica Plain, you’ll always get fresh, high-quality food prepared quickly. Convenience never means sacrificing flavor.

⭐ 6. Consistently Trusted by JP Locals

We’ve earned a loyal following in Jamaica Plain because we deliver the same quality every time. Whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth, you’ll enjoy the same chewy bagels, fresh ingredients, and friendly service.

⭐ Customer Testimonials – Fresh Breakfast Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Laura P. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“I love starting my mornings with their Everything Bagel and a latte. The bagels are always fresh, chewy, and flavorful. It feels like having a true New York bagel shop right here in JP.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Marcus D. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“The Cinnamon Raisin Bagel is my favorite—it’s sweet, warm, and comforting. I usually grab one after my morning run in JP, and it gives me the perfect energy boost to start my day.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel S. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“As a vegan, I’m thrilled to finally have real options in JP. The Franklin Street vegan sandwich with avocado and veggies is delicious and filling. Their plant-based menu makes me feel included.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tom B. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“I ordered delivery on a busy workday, and my breakfast pizza arrived hot and fresh. The packaging kept everything perfect. Definitely the best delivery breakfast I’ve had in Jamaica Plain.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Angela M. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“Their Plain Bagel with cream cheese is simple, but it’s the best in town. I grew up eating bagels in New York, and this place brings back that same authentic taste every single time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Samantha W. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“My kids love the Asiago Bagel and the Egg & Cheese sandwiches. It’s become our weekend ritual to stop by for bagels after the farmers’ market. Friendly service and consistently great food.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
James L. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“I tried the Smoked Salmon Classic, and it was outstanding—fresh salmon, crisp veggies, and a perfectly toasted bagel. It feels like a gourmet meal without the gourmet price tag.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Olivia R. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“Their coffee pairs perfectly with the Multigrain Bagel. I appreciate that they have healthy options too. This shop has quickly become my go-to spot before heading into Boston for work.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Daniel F. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“I’m a night owl, and having them open until 2 AM is a game-changer. The Maple Bacon Bliss breakfast pizza is my late-night guilty pleasure. JP needed a place like this.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Priya K. – Jamaica Plain, MA
“The service is always friendly, and the food is always top-notch. Whether I get takeout or dine in, I know I’ll get the same great quality. It’s truly a gem in Jamaica Plain.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – Fresh Breakfast Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

Do you offer delivery in Jamaica Plain?
✅ Yes! We provide reliable delivery across Jamaica Plain and nearby neighborhoods. Every order is baked fresh, carefully packaged, and arrives hot so you can enjoy bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast pizzas at home, in the office, or on campus.
What are your opening hours in Jamaica Plain?
✅ We’re open daily from 6:00 AM to 2:00 AM, making us one of the few breakfast spots in JP with such extended hours. Whether you need an early-morning bagel and coffee or a late-night pizza, we’ve got you covered.
Do you have vegan and vegetarian bagel options?
✅ Absolutely! Our menu features vegan sandwiches, dairy-free spreads, and vegetarian favorites like pesto bagels and veggie-loaded sandwiches. Jamaica Plain’s health-conscious and plant-based community has plenty to enjoy here.
Can I customize my breakfast sandwich in Jamaica Plain?
✅ Yes! With our “Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich” option, you can pick your bagel, eggs, cheese, and proteins to create the perfect combination. JP locals love this because it’s tailored exactly to their tastes.
Do you offer catering services for Jamaica Plain events?
✅ Yes, we cater for office meetings, birthday parties, student groups, and family gatherings. Our catering menu includes fresh bagels, spreads, sandwiches, and breakfast pizzas—delivered on time and ready to impress your guests.
Are there healthy bagel options on the menu?
✅ Definitely! We bake Whole Wheat and Multigrain Bagels fresh every day. These are popular with Jamaica Plain customers who want nutritious, fiber-rich choices without giving up the chewy, flavorful bagel experience.
How can I order online for pickup or delivery?
✅ Ordering is quick and convenient through our online platform. Simply choose your favorites, select pickup or delivery, and your food will be ready fast. Many JP residents love this option for busy mornings or lunch breaks.
Do you serve more than just bagels?
✅ Yes! While bagels are our specialty, we also serve hearty breakfast sandwiches, vegan and vegetarian options, breakfast pizzas, and freshly brewed coffee. Jamaica Plain customers can enjoy complete meals, not just snacks.
Can I get breakfast late at night in Jamaica Plain?
✅ Yes! Unlike most breakfast spots, we’re open until 2:00 AM daily. That means you can grab a plain bagel at sunrise, a sandwich for lunch, or a loaded breakfast pizza after a late-night outing in JP.
What makes NY Bagel & Coffee Co. the best in Jamaica Plain?
✅ It’s our mix of authentic New York–style bagels, inclusive menu options, and community-focused service. Jamaica Plain locals trust us for quality, consistency, and convenience, making us their go-to spot for bagels and more.

📞 Visit or Order Today – Fresh Breakfast Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

Start your morning right or satisfy late-night cravings with the best bagels in Jamaica Plain. From Plain and Everything Bagels to hearty sandwiches, vegan favorites, and breakfast pizzas, NY Bagel & Coffee Co. is here to serve fresh flavors all day long.