Best New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA

There’s nothing like starting your morning with a warm, fresh bagel—the kind that’s crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside, and baked the authentic New York way. Luckily, you don’t need to head to Manhattan to enjoy this iconic breakfast staple. Right here in Arlington, MA, locals can savor New York style bagels made fresh daily with traditional techniques that guarantee flavor and texture in every bite.

Our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked to perfection, ensuring that every order captures the authenticity that has made New York bagels world-famous. Whether you prefer a classic plain bagel with cream cheese, an everything bagel loaded with toppings, or a hearty breakfast sandwich filled with eggs, bacon, and cheese, our menu has something for everyone.

Perfect for busy commuters, families, and students, our bagels are available for dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering. From quick grab-and-go breakfasts to large catering platters for meetings or weekend brunches, we’ve become a trusted spot for quality, freshness, and unbeatable taste.

With friendly service and consistently rave reviews, we’re proud to bring the best New York style bagels to Arlington, MA, one delicious bite at a time.

Restaurant Details

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

 

🥯 Why Choose Us – New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA

Arlington residents have plenty of breakfast and coffee options, but when it comes to authentic New York style bagels, we stand out. Here’s why customers choose us again and again:

✅ 1. Authentic New York Bagel Tradition

We follow the classic New York method: every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked daily. This ensures the perfect chewy inside with a crispy golden crust—a true bagel experience you can’t find at chain cafés or supermarkets.

✅ 2. Freshly Baked Throughout the Day

Our bagels are never mass-produced or frozen. Instead, we bake in small batches all day long, so whether you stop by in the morning rush or afternoon snack time, you’ll always enjoy a fresh, warm bagel straight from the oven.

✅ 3. Wide Variety of Flavors & Toppings

From classic plain and everything bagels to favorites like jalapeño cheddar, cinnamon raisin, and whole wheat, we offer something for every taste. Pair your bagel with house-made cream cheese spreads, avocado, hummus, or smoked salmon for a meal that’s as simple or as bold as you like.

✅ 4. Convenient for Commuters & Families

Located right on Massachusetts Ave in Arlington, we’re easily accessible for commuters heading to Boston or Cambridge, as well as families looking for a quick and delicious breakfast. With affordable combos and fast service, we’re the perfect stop for busy mornings.

✅ 5. Takeout, Delivery & Catering Options

Whether you want to sit and relax with a coffee, grab a bagel on the go, or order delivery straight to your door, we make it easy. We also offer catering platters for office meetings, school events, and weekend brunch gatherings.

✅ 6. Trusted by the Arlington Community

With consistent five-star reviews and a loyal customer base, we’ve become Arlington’s go-to destination for bagels. Our commitment to authenticity, freshness, and friendly service keeps customers coming back.

 

📍 Nearby Cities We Serve – New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA

Our central Arlington location makes it easy to bring the authentic taste of New York bagels to communities across Greater Boston. Whether you’re commuting, studying, or planning brunch with family, here’s how we proudly serve each nearby city:

🥯 Allston, MA

With Boston University just around the corner, Allston students and young professionals love our bagel + coffee combos for busy mornings and late-night study sessions.

🥯 Cambridge, MA

Home to Harvard and MIT, Cambridge residents enjoy our lox bagels, avocado veggie sandwiches, and catering platters for campus meetings and group brunches.

🥯 Brookline, MA

Brookline families often order our dozen bagel boxes and smoked salmon spreads for relaxed weekend brunches at home.

🥯 Somerville, MA

From Davis Square to Assembly Row, Somerville foodies rely on our delivery service for everything bagels, egg sandwiches, and hot coffee to fuel their day.

🥯 Boston, MA

Commuters, office workers, and tourists in downtown Boston love grabbing our classic bacon, egg & cheese bagels before heading to work or sightseeing.

🥯 Watertown, MA

Watertown residents frequently choose our bagel catering platters for family gatherings, office lunches, and school events.

🥯 Arlington, MA (Local)

Right here in Arlington, we’ve become a neighborhood favorite, serving everyone from busy commuters to families looking for a quick, delicious breakfast.

🥯 Medford, MA

Tufts University students and Medford locals love our budget-friendly bagels for breakfast, study breaks, and late-night delivery.

🥯 Newton, MA

Families in Newton often enjoy our cinnamon raisin bagels with strawberry cream cheese—a sweet and wholesome treat for weekend mornings.

🥯 Belmont, MA

Belmont customers appreciate our whole wheat and multigrain bagels, often paired with veggie cream cheese for a healthier breakfast option.

🥯 Waltham, MA

With a large student and professional community, Waltham residents love our affordable lunch bagel sandwiches and coffee combos.

🥯 Jamaica Plain, MA

JP locals enjoy our specialty jalapeño cheddar and sriracha egg bagels, bringing bold flavors to a creative neighborhood.

🥯 Roslindale, MA

Roslindale families often grab our bagel dozen deals with cream cheese tubs, making it easy to feed a crowd.

🥯 Dorchester, MA

Dorchester customers rave about our hearty bagel sandwiches, especially the turkey club and pastrami & Swiss options.

🥯 Chelsea, MA

Chelsea professionals count on our fast delivery service to bring hot bagels and coffee straight to their offices.

🥯 Everett, MA

Everett locals love ordering our weekend bagel boxes—perfect for sharing with friends and family at brunch.

🥯 Malden, MA

Malden students and families appreciate our affordable pricing, variety of bagels, and speedy delivery.

🥯 Revere, MA

Revere residents often order our lox bagel sandwiches and iced coffee, perfect for mornings by the beach or on the go.

🥯 Quincy, MA

Offices and families in Quincy frequently order bagel catering packs for work meetings, school events, and gatherings.

🥯 Fenway-Kenmore, MA

With Fenway Park nearby, locals and Red Sox fans grab our egg & cheese bagels and cold brew coffee before games or after late nights.

 

🥯 Popular Bagels & Menu Highlights – Arlington, MA

Our menu is designed to deliver the authentic New York bagel experience right here in Arlington. From simple classics to loaded sandwiches, there’s something for everyone.

🥯 Classic New York Style Bagels

Plain Bagel
Golden crust with a soft, chewy interior—a true staple. Perfect with butter, cream cheese, or as the base for any sandwich.
💲$1.95 each | 💲$17.50 (Dozen)

Sesame Bagel
Toasted sesame seeds add a nutty crunch to this New York classic. Great with plain cream cheese or avocado spread.
💲$2.25 each | 💲$19.00 (Dozen)

Everything Bagel
Packed with sesame, poppy seeds, onion, garlic, and sea salt for a flavor explosion in every bite.
💲$2.50 each | 💲$20.00 (Dozen)

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
Sweet, chewy, and full of raisins with a hint of cinnamon—pairs perfectly with strawberry cream cheese.
💲$2.50 each | 💲$20.00 (Dozen)

Whole Wheat Bagel
Nutty, hearty, and wholesome. A healthier choice without sacrificing authentic taste.
💲$2.25 each | 💲$19.00 (Dozen)

Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel
Cheesy, spicy, and bold—made with real cheddar and jalapeño baked into the dough.
💲$2.75 each | 💲$22.00 (Dozen)

🧀 Cream Cheese Spreads & Toppings

Plain Cream Cheese
Smooth, creamy, and timeless—the perfect partner for any bagel.
💲$2.50 (Single) | 💲$5.00 (Tub)

Scallion Cream Cheese
Fresh scallions add a zesty, savory twist to classic cream cheese.
💲$3.25 (Single) | 💲$6.50 (Tub)

Veggie Cream Cheese
Loaded with crunchy diced carrots, peppers, and onions for a fresh, colorful spread.
💲$3.50 (Single) | 💲$7.00 (Tub)

Strawberry Cream Cheese
Sweet, fruity, and indulgent—delicious with cinnamon raisin bagels.
💲$3.50 (Single) | 💲$7.00 (Tub)

Lox Cream Cheese
Creamy, smoky, and luxurious with real smoked salmon blended in.
💲$4.50 (Single) | 💲$9.00 (Tub)

🥪 Signature Bagel Sandwiches

Classic Lox & Cream Cheese Bagel
Smoked salmon layered with cream cheese, tomato, onion, and capers on your choice of bagel.
💲$12.49

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel
A New England favorite—crispy bacon, fluffy egg, and melted cheese on a fresh bagel.
💲$8.49

Avocado Veggie Bagel
Fresh avocado, cucumber, tomato, and sprouts stacked on a multigrain bagel. Healthy and hearty.
💲$9.25

Turkey Club Bagel
Oven-roasted turkey breast, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and light mayo on a sesame bagel.
💲$9.99

Sriracha Egg & Cheese Bagel
Egg, melted cheddar, and a kick of sriracha for spice lovers.
💲$8.25

Pastrami & Swiss Bagel
Hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, and mustard on an everything bagel. Perfect for lunch.
💲$10.49

☕ Bagels & Coffee Combos

Morning Starter Combo
Plain bagel with cream cheese + a fresh-brewed coffee.
💲$5.99

Power Breakfast Combo
Everything bagel with egg & cheese + iced coffee.
💲$8.49

Weekend Brunch Combo
Choice of signature bagel sandwich + latte or cappuccino.
💲$11.49

Bagel Box & Coffee Pack (For Groups)
A dozen assorted bagels + 2 cream cheese tubs + a 10-cup coffee box.
💲$39.99

 

🚚 Delivery & Takeout – New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA

Craving the perfect bagel but don’t have time to sit down? We make it easy for Arlington locals and nearby communities to enjoy authentic New York style bagels with our convenient delivery and takeout options.

✅ Always Fresh, Never Stale

We bake in small batches all day long, so your order is prepared fresh, not reheated. Whether you grab takeout or schedule delivery, you’ll always get a warm, chewy bagel made the traditional New York way.

✅ Reliable Packaging for Quality

Every bagel, sandwich, and spread is packed with care using eco-friendly, durable packaging. Sandwiches stay hot, cream cheese tubs stay sealed, and coffee arrives in spill-proof cups—ensuring your order reaches you exactly how it should.

✅ Fast Delivery Across Arlington & Beyond

Our delivery service covers all of Arlington, East Arlington, and Arlington Heights, as well as neighboring towns like Cambridge, Belmont, Medford, and Somerville. Most deliveries arrive in 30–40 minutes, making it easy to enjoy fresh bagels without the wait.

✅ Easy Online Ordering

Our online ordering system lets you customize your bagel—choose your base, spreads, and toppings—then schedule for pickup or delivery. Busy morning? Place your order ahead of time and swing by to grab it without standing in line.

✅ Perfect for Groups & Catering

Planning an office meeting, school event, or family brunch? We offer catering options including dozen bagel packs, smoked salmon platters, cream cheese tubs, and coffee boxes. Schedule in advance for stress-free delivery right to your home or workplace.

 

🏆 Why We’re the Best Bagel Shop in Arlington, MA

Arlington may be a small town, but when it comes to big bagel flavor, we deliver the best of New York right to your neighborhood. Here’s why locals say we’re the top bagel spot in town:

✅ 1. Authentic New York Style Recipes

We stick to the traditional New York method—hand-rolling, kettle-boiling, and baking every bagel fresh daily. This process creates the perfect crispy crust with a soft, chewy interior that makes our bagels stand out from store-bought or chain cafés.

✅ 2. Fresh Ingredients, Baked All Day

Our commitment to freshness is unmatched. We bake in small batches throughout the day, use locally sourced produce, and prepare spreads in-house. That means every bite tastes authentic, wholesome, and flavorful—never mass-produced.

✅ 3. Convenient Location & Service

Located right on Massachusetts Ave, we’re easy to access for commuters, students, and families. Whether you’re grabbing takeout on the way to Boston, enjoying breakfast in Arlington Heights, or scheduling delivery to Belmont or Medford, we’ve got you covered.

✅ 4. Options for Everyone

We pride ourselves on offering something for every appetite—classic plain and sesame bagels, bold flavors like jalapeño cheddar, vegetarian options like avocado veggie bagels, and even gluten-free choices. Pair them with premium spreads or smoked salmon for endless possibilities.

✅ 5. Catering & Group Orders Made Simple

From office breakfasts to school events and weekend brunches, we’re Arlington’s go-to for catering. Our bagel boxes, cream cheese tubs, smoked salmon platters, and coffee packs make feeding a crowd easy, affordable, and stress-free.

✅ 6. Trusted by the Arlington Community

We’re proud of our loyal customer base. Locals consistently give us 5-star reviews for authenticity, freshness, and friendly service. Over the years, we’ve become not just a bagel shop, but a part of Arlington’s daily breakfast routine.

 

⭐ Customer Testimonials – Best New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA

Here’s what our happy customers in Arlington and beyond are saying about their experiences with our authentic New York style bagels:

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Karen L. – Arlington Resident
“I stop here every morning on my way to work, and I’m always impressed with the freshness. The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese is my go-to, and it never disappoints. Staff are super friendly, and they remember my order, which makes it feel like a neighborhood staple.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Mark D. – Medford Commuter
“As someone who drives through Arlington daily, this has become my breakfast stop. The bagels are authentic—crispy outside, chewy inside, just like the New York bagels I grew up with. The bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich is the perfect fuel before work.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Emily S. – Belmont Mom
“My kids love the cinnamon raisin bagels with strawberry cream cheese, and I can’t get enough of their jalapeño cheddar bagel. We often grab a dozen for family brunches, and they stay fresh even the next day. Arlington finally has a bagel shop that gets it right.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Jason P. – College Student in Cambridge
“I usually order delivery to my apartment near Porter Square, and it’s always quick. The avocado veggie bagel is my favorite—it’s healthy, filling, and delicious. Way better than chain cafés, and the prices are student-friendly too.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Linda M. – Arlington Heights
“I appreciate that they bake bagels throughout the day, not just in the morning. Even when I stop by in the afternoon, I can get a fresh, warm bagel. Their coffee is strong, the sandwiches are generous, and the service is consistently great.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Anthony G. – Somerville Professional
“My office orders catering from here, and it’s always a hit. The smoked salmon platter with a dozen assorted bagels is a client favorite. Everything arrives on time, neatly packaged, and ready to serve. Reliable and delicious—that’s why we keep coming back.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rachel W. – Arlington Center
“I love that they offer so many cream cheese options. The veggie cream cheese is loaded with flavor, not just bland like other places. Every bagel I’ve tried so far has been top quality, and the atmosphere inside is cozy and welcoming.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
David B. – Boston Visitor
“I was visiting a friend in Arlington and stopped by for breakfast. Honestly, these bagels rival the best spots in New York. The lox bagel was loaded with salmon, and the flavors were spot on. I’ll definitely be back next time I’m in town.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sophie C. – Watertown Resident
“Delivery is always smooth and fast. The bagels arrive warm, and the coffee is still hot when it gets to me. I love ordering the weekend brunch combo—it’s affordable, filling, and perfect for lazy Saturdays.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tom H. – Longtime Arlington Local
“I’ve lived in Arlington for 20 years, and this is exactly the kind of bagel shop we needed. The staff are welcoming, the food is consistently fresh, and the variety of flavors keeps me coming back. This place has become part of my weekend tradition.”

 

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA

1. Do you deliver bagels in Arlington and nearby towns?

✅ Yes! We deliver across all of Arlington, Arlington Heights, and East Arlington, and also serve nearby towns like Belmont, Medford, Somerville, and Cambridge. Delivery typically takes 30–40 minutes, so you can enjoy a hot bagel without leaving your home or office.

2. How can I place an order for pickup or delivery?

✅ You can order easily through our online platform or by phone. Customize your bagel, choose your spreads or toppings, and select pickup or delivery. We also allow you to schedule orders ahead of time, which is perfect for busy mornings or planned gatherings.

3. Are your bagels really made the New York way?

✅ Absolutely. Each bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, exactly like traditional New York bagels. This technique gives them the signature chewy inside and golden crust that chain bakeries or frozen options just can’t replicate.

4. Do you offer vegetarian and vegan-friendly options?

✅ Yes, we have plenty! Our plain, sesame, everything, and whole wheat bagels are vegan-friendly. For spreads, you can try hummus, avocado, or veggie-loaded sandwiches. Vegans and vegetarians love our Avocado Veggie Bagel for a healthy, hearty meal.

5. Do you provide gluten-free bagels?

✅ We do! Gluten-free bagels are available in select flavors. While they are baked in the same facility as traditional bagels, we take extra care to minimize cross-contact. Many of our gluten-sensitive customers enjoy them safely—just let us know when ordering.

6. Can I order catering for events in Arlington?

✅ Yes! We offer catering packages perfect for office meetings, school events, and weekend brunches. Options include dozen bagel assortments, cream cheese tubs, smoked salmon platters, and coffee boxes. Everything is neatly packaged and ready to serve.

7. How far in advance should I place catering orders?

✅ For small orders, same-day requests are often possible. But for larger gatherings of 12+ bagels or full platters, we recommend placing your order at least 24 hours in advance. This helps us guarantee variety and freshness for your group.

8. What makes your bagels different from other bakeries in Arlington?

✅ Unlike many cafés or grocery store bagels, ours are never frozen or mass-produced. They’re crafted daily using traditional methods, fresh ingredients, and in-house spreads. That’s why our bagels have the authentic flavor and texture Arlington locals rave about.

9. Do you offer student discounts or affordable combos?

✅ Yes! Arlington is close to Tufts University, Lesley University, and nearby Boston colleges, so we’ve created student-friendly pricing and combos. Our bagel + coffee combo is especially popular with students looking for a filling breakfast on a budget.

10. Can I order early in the morning?

✅ Definitely. Our shop opens early, and with online pre-scheduling, you can set your order to be ready when you need it. Whether you’re catching a bus to Boston, heading to work, or starting a busy school day, we’ll have your bagels hot and waiting.

 

📞 Visit or Order Today – Fresh New York Style Bagels in Arlington, MA

There’s no better way to start your day than with a warm, fresh, and authentic New York style bagel—crispy on the outside, soft and chewy inside, and baked fresh every morning. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast on the go, ordering delivery for the office, or planning a family brunch, our bagels are the perfect choice.

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now