Best New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

Jamaica Plain, known for its vibrant community, arts scene, and local charm, is also home to some of the most passionate food lovers in Boston. Among its many dining options, nothing satisfies quite like a true New York style bagel—crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, and bursting with authentic flavor. That’s exactly what we bring to Jamaica Plain every day.

Our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, honoring the classic New York tradition. Whether you prefer a plain bagel with cream cheese, an everything bagel stacked with lox and veggies, or something bold like our jalapeño cheddar bagel, we’ve got flavors to match every craving. Pair your bagel with one of our house-made cream cheese spreads, hearty sandwiches, or hot coffee for the perfect breakfast or lunch.

Conveniently located in the heart of Jamaica Plain, our shop has become a neighborhood favorite for families, students, and professionals. With dine-in seating, takeout, catering, and delivery, enjoying a fresh bagel is easy no matter your schedule. Whether it’s a weekday breakfast on the go or a weekend brunch with friends, we’re here to bring a little taste of New York to JP.

Restaurant Details

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🥯 Why Choose Us – New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

When it comes to bagels, Jamaica Plain deserves the best. Here’s why locals choose us as their go-to spot for authentic New York style bagels:

✅ 1. Authentic New York Style, Right in JP

Our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, just like the ones you’d find in Manhattan. The golden crust and chewy interior are proof of our dedication to tradition, bringing New York authenticity to Jamaica Plain.

✅ 2. Freshly Baked All Day Long

We don’t stop after the morning rush—bagels are baked in small batches throughout the day. Whether you grab breakfast at 7 AM or lunch at 1 PM, you’ll always enjoy a warm, fresh bagel.

✅ 3. Flavors for Every Craving

From plain and everything bagels to jalapeño cheddar and cinnamon raisin, our menu covers every taste. Add in house-made cream cheese spreads, sandwiches, and smoked salmon platters, and there’s something for everyone in JP.

✅ 4. Convenient for Busy Lifestyles

Whether you’re a student, commuter, or parent, we make eating well easy with takeout, delivery, and catering options. Our online ordering system ensures your meal is ready when you need it.

✅ 5. Perfect for Families & Groups

Hosting brunch, school events, or office meetings? Our bagel boxes, cream cheese tubs, and coffee packs make feeding groups simple and stress-free, while still keeping that homemade freshness.

✅ 6. A Local JP Favorite

We’re more than just a bagel shop—we’re part of the Jamaica Plain community. With friendly service, consistent quality, and flavors locals love, we’ve become a trusted stop for residents who want both comfort and authenticity.

📍 Nearby Cities We Serve – New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

Our Jamaica Plain shop proudly serves not only local residents but also nearby neighborhoods who crave authentic New York style bagels. Here’s how we bring bagel goodness to the surrounding areas:

🥯 Allston, MA

Allston students and young professionals love our budget-friendly bagel and coffee combos, perfect for fueling busy mornings and late study nights.

🥯 Cambridge, MA

With Harvard and MIT nearby, Cambridge orders often include lox platters, catering packages, and veggie cream cheese spreads for campus and office gatherings.

🥯 Brookline, MA

Brookline families enjoy our weekend dozens and coffee packs, making at-home brunches simple, delicious, and family-friendly.

🥯 Somerville, MA

Food lovers in Somerville order our jalapeño cheddar, everything bagels, and hearty sandwiches, often delivered fresh to Davis and Union Square.

🥯 Boston, MA

Boston commuters grab quick breakfast sandwiches and coffee specials, while families rely on our delivery service for relaxed weekend mornings.

🥯 Watertown, MA

Watertown businesses frequently order our bagel platters and smoked salmon trays for office meetings and catered events.

🥯 Arlington, MA

Arlington locals appreciate our fresh-baked bagels throughout the day and easy online ordering for takeout or delivery.

🥯 Medford, MA

Tufts students and residents love our affordable bagel sandwiches, avocado bagels, and iced coffee for quick, satisfying meals.

🥯 Newton, MA

Health-conscious Newton customers choose our whole wheat, multigrain, and veggie-packed options, perfect for family breakfasts or post-workout meals.

🥯 Belmont, MA

Belmont households often order bagel dozens and cream cheese tubs to make weekends more relaxed and stress-free.

🥯 Waltham, MA

Waltham residents and professionals love our lox bagels, catering packs, and all-day fresh baking that fits their busy schedules.

🥯 Jamaica Plain, MA (Local)

Our home base—serving Jamaica Plain with hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels, sandwiches, and coffee for breakfast, lunch, and weekend brunch.

🥯 Roslindale, MA

Roslindale families often grab bagel boxes for school mornings and cream cheese spreads to make weekday breakfasts easier.

🥯 Dorchester, MA

Dorchester foodies enjoy our hearty pastrami bagels, turkey clubs, and sriracha egg & cheese sandwiches for satisfying takeout meals.

🥯 Chelsea, MA

Chelsea businesses depend on our fast catering deliveries—bagel boxes, spreads, and coffee packs for meetings that keep teams energized.

🥯 Everett, MA

Everett families often order weekend bagel dozens with tubs of cream cheese, making brunches stress-free and crowd-pleasing.

🥯 Malden, MA

Malden commuters love our bagel and coffee deals, while locals enjoy delivery of signature sandwiches for easy lunches.

🥯 Revere, MA

Revere beachgoers fuel up with lox bagels and iced coffee before heading out for a day by the ocean.

🥯 Quincy, MA

Quincy households enjoy our catering packages, smoked salmon trays, and bagel boxes, perfect for both family gatherings and work events.

🥯 Fenway-Kenmore, MA

Fenway students and Red Sox fans grab egg & cheese bagels and cold brew before class, games, or heading to work.

🥯 Popular Bagels & Menu Highlights – Jamaica Plain, MA

In Jamaica Plain, every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, ensuring the authentic taste New Yorkers swear by. Here’s a look at our most popular bagels, spreads, sandwiches, and combos:

🥯 Classic New York Bagels

Plain Bagel
The original favorite—chewy inside, golden crisp outside. Perfect with butter or cream cheese.
💲$1.95 each | 💲$17.50 (Dozen)

Sesame Bagel
Topped with roasted sesame seeds, giving a nutty crunch in every bite.
💲$2.25 each | 💲$19.00 (Dozen)

Everything Bagel
Coated with garlic, onion, sesame, poppy seeds, and sea salt—our most loved bagel in JP.
💲$2.50 each | 💲$20.00 (Dozen)

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
Sweet, chewy, and slightly spiced—pairs perfectly with strawberry cream cheese.
💲$2.50 each | 💲$20.00 (Dozen)

Multigrain Bagel
A hearty, fiber-packed choice that’s both healthy and delicious.
💲$2.25 each | 💲$19.00 (Dozen)

Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel
A bold mix of sharp cheddar and spicy jalapeños baked right in.
💲$2.75 each | 💲$22.00 (Dozen)

🧀 House-Made Cream Cheese Spreads

Plain Cream Cheese
Rich, smooth, and classic—our most popular spread.
💲$2.50 (Single) | 💲$5.00 (Tub)

Scallion Cream Cheese
Fresh scallions blended for a flavorful punch.
💲$3.25 (Single) | 💲$6.50 (Tub)

Veggie Cream Cheese
Packed with carrots, peppers, and onions—fresh and colorful.
💲$3.50 (Single) | 💲$7.00 (Tub)

Strawberry Cream Cheese
Sweet and fruity, perfect with cinnamon raisin bagels.
💲$3.50 (Single) | 💲$7.00 (Tub)

Lox Cream Cheese
Made with real smoked salmon for a savory, indulgent option.
💲$4.50 (Single) | 💲$9.00 (Tub)

🥪 Signature Bagel Sandwiches

Classic Lox & Cream Cheese Bagel
Smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onion, tomato, and capers—a true New York classic.
💲$12.49

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel
Crispy bacon, fluffy egg, and melted cheese—a JP breakfast favorite.
💲$8.49

Avocado Veggie Bagel
Fresh avocado, cucumber, tomato, and sprouts for a wholesome meal.
💲$9.25

Turkey Club Bagel
Roasted turkey, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a sesame bagel.
💲$9.99

Sriracha Egg & Cheese Bagel
Fluffy egg, cheddar cheese, and a spicy kick of sriracha.
💲$8.25

Pastrami & Swiss Bagel
Savory pastrami with melted Swiss cheese on an everything bagel.
💲$10.49

☕ Bagel & Coffee Combos

Morning Starter Combo
Plain bagel with cream cheese + hot coffee.
💲$5.99

Power Breakfast Combo
Everything bagel with egg & cheese + iced coffee.
💲$8.49

Weekend Brunch Combo
Any signature sandwich + cappuccino or latte.
💲$11.49

Bagel Box & Coffee Pack (Group Special)
12 assorted bagels + 2 cream cheese tubs + 10-cup coffee box.
💲$39.99

🚚 Delivery & Takeout – New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

We know Jamaica Plain is a lively, on-the-go community. That’s why our delivery and takeout options are designed to make enjoying authentic New York style bagels quick, simple, and stress-free. Here’s what makes us the go-to choice:

✅ 1. Freshly Prepared for Every Order

Each bagel is baked and sandwiches are assembled only when you order, never pre-packaged. This means whether you’re picking up a quick breakfast or ordering delivery for brunch, your food will always be hot, fresh, and full of flavor.

✅ 2. Eco-Friendly & Secure Packaging

We use sturdy, eco-conscious packaging to ensure bagels stay warm, sandwiches remain intact, and spreads are sealed tight. No spills, no soggy bread—just perfect bagels, exactly as they left our kitchen.

✅ 3. Fast Local Delivery Across JP & Nearby Areas

Our delivery service covers not just Jamaica Plain but also Roslindale, Brookline, Dorchester, and Boston. Most orders arrive within 30–40 minutes, making it easy to enjoy bagels at home, in the office, or even in the park.

✅ 4. Easy Online Ordering & Scheduling

With our online ordering system, customers can browse the full menu, customize bagels and sandwiches, and even schedule orders ahead of time. Perfect for busy JP residents who want their food ready right when they need it.

✅ 5. Catering & Group Orders Made Simple

Planning a school event, office meeting, or family brunch? Our bagel boxes, smoked salmon trays, cream cheese tubs, and coffee packs are designed for groups and can be delivered directly to your door or picked up with zero hassle.

✅ 6. Quick & Convenient Takeout Options

For locals on the go, we offer call-ahead pickup and curbside service. Whether you’re running errands on Centre Street or heading to work downtown, your order will be hot and ready when you arrive—no waiting in line.

🏆 Why We’re the Best in Jamaica Plain, MA

Bagel lovers across JP agree—our shop isn’t just another breakfast spot. Here’s why we’re considered the #1 destination for New York style bagels in Jamaica Plain:

✅ 1. Authentic New York Bagel Tradition

We stay true to the classic process—hand-rolling, kettle-boiling, and oven-baking every batch. This dedication gives our bagels the unmistakable crispy crust and chewy center that makes New York bagels famous. JP residents don’t need to travel far to enjoy the real thing.

✅ 2. Freshly Baked Throughout the Day

Unlike shops that bake once in the morning, we bake in small batches all day long. This ensures every bagel you pick up—whether at 7 AM or 2 PM—tastes warm, fresh, and straight out of the oven.

✅ 3. Wide Variety to Please Every Taste

From plain, sesame, and everything bagels to bold flavors like jalapeño cheddar and cinnamon raisin, we have something for every craving. Add in house-made cream cheeses, signature sandwiches, and catering trays, and JP foodies always have options.

✅ 4. Designed for Busy JP Lifestyles

With easy takeout, fast delivery, and online ordering, we make it convenient for commuters, parents, and students to enjoy quality meals without the wait. Our catering options also make office lunches and family brunches stress-free.

✅ 5. A Trusted Part of the JP Community

We’re more than just a bagel shop—we’re part of the Jamaica Plain neighborhood fabric. Locals trust us for consistency, friendly service, and flavors that bring comfort and community together over every bagel.

✅ 6. Perfect for Every Occasion

Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast, fueling up before work, or hosting a group brunch, our menu works for every occasion. From single bagels with coffee to full catering packages, we deliver quality and reliability every time.

⭐ Customer Testimonials – New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Olivia M. – Jamaica Plain Resident
“I love that I can walk down Centre Street and grab a warm bagel that tastes like it came straight from New York. The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese is my favorite—it’s always baked fresh and packed with flavor. It’s become a weekend tradition for my family.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Ryan P. – College Student in Boston
“As a student living in JP, I’m always on the lookout for affordable, filling meals. Their bacon, egg, and cheese bagel is perfect for mornings before class. I also love that I can order ahead online—it saves me so much time during busy weeks.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Samantha L. – Local Mom of Three
“My kids adore the cinnamon raisin bagels with strawberry cream cheese. We usually order a dozen for the weekend, and it makes family breakfasts so easy. The bagels are always soft, chewy, and fresh, and the staff are wonderful with children.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Daniel R. – Small Business Owner in JP
“I often order catering for my shop meetings, and it’s always a hit. The bagel boxes are generous, the cream cheese tubs are flavorful, and the coffee packs keep everyone fueled. It’s a simple way to impress employees and clients without breaking the bank.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Maya T. – Brookline Visitor
“I stopped by while visiting a friend in JP and was blown away by the lox bagel sandwich. The salmon was fresh, the toppings were balanced, and the bagel had that authentic chewiness. I’ve since ordered delivery a few times—it’s just that good.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Kevin J. – JP Commuter
“Every morning before I catch the T, I stop here for a plain bagel with lox cream cheese and coffee. The staff know my order by heart now, which makes it feel like a true neighborhood spot. Consistency like this keeps me coming back daily.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Priya S. – Roslindale Resident
“I hosted brunch at home and ordered a bagel box with cream cheese spreads and a coffee pack. Everything arrived fresh and perfectly packed. My guests couldn’t stop complimenting the quality. It was one of the easiest hosting experiences I’ve ever had.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Marcus D. – JP Local Artist
“I often work late nights and sometimes pick up bagels for lunch the next day. Even in the afternoon, their bagels are warm and fresh—proof that they bake all day long. My favorite is the jalapeño cheddar bagel with veggie cream cheese. Delicious every time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Claire H. – Boston Professional
“I was looking for a quick but hearty lunch while working remotely in JP, and this shop hit the spot. The turkey club bagel was filling and fresh, and the coffee was strong enough to power me through the day. Definitely one of my go-to lunch spots now.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Anthony W. – Jamaica Plain Resident
“This shop feels like a part of the neighborhood. The staff are friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and the food is consistently excellent. From quick solo breakfasts to catering for family events, they’ve become my trusted bagel place in JP.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

1. Do you deliver bagels in Jamaica Plain?

✅ Yes! We provide fast delivery across Jamaica Plain and surrounding neighborhoods like Roslindale, Brookline, and Dorchester. Most deliveries arrive in 30–40 minutes, and everything is packed securely to keep your bagels warm and fresh.

2. What makes your bagels “New York style”?

✅ Our bagels are made the traditional way: hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and oven-baked fresh daily. This method creates the crispy outside and chewy inside that makes New York bagels famous, and we bring that authenticity right to JP.

3. Do you bake bagels all day long?

✅ Absolutely! Unlike shops that only bake in the morning, we prepare bagels in small batches throughout the day. Whether you come in at 7 AM or 2 PM, you’ll still get a bagel that tastes fresh out of the oven.

4. Do you have vegan or vegetarian options?

✅ Yes. Many of our bagels—including plain, sesame, and everything—are vegan-friendly. For vegetarians, we offer veggie cream cheese, avocado sandwiches, and fresh veggie-loaded bagels that are both wholesome and satisfying.

5. Are gluten-free bagels available?

✅ We do offer gluten-free bagels in select flavors. While they are baked in the same kitchen, we take extra precautions to reduce cross-contact. Many gluten-sensitive customers in JP enjoy them without issue.

6. Can I order catering for a group or event?

✅ Definitely! Our bagel boxes, smoked salmon platters, cream cheese tubs, and coffee packs are perfect for office meetings, school events, and family gatherings. We also deliver catering orders directly to your home or workplace in Jamaica Plain.

7. What are your most popular bagels in JP?

✅ Local favorites include the everything bagel, cinnamon raisin, and jalapeño cheddar. For sandwiches, our lox & cream cheese bagel and bacon, egg & cheese are the top choices among Jamaica Plain customers.

8. How do I place an order for takeout or delivery?

✅ Orders can be placed online, by phone, or through delivery apps. We also offer call-ahead ordering and curbside pickup, so busy JP residents can grab their food quickly without waiting in line.

9. Do you offer student or commuter specials?

✅ Yes! With many students and commuters in JP, we provide affordable bagel and coffee combos designed for a quick and filling meal. Our breakfast deals are perfect for anyone catching the T or heading to class.

10. What are your hours of operation?

✅ We open early at 6:30 AM daily, making it easy for commuters and early risers to grab breakfast before work or school. We close at 3:00 PM, but you can place orders in advance online to make sure your favorites are ready.

📞 Visit or Order Today – New York Style Bagels in Jamaica Plain, MA

There’s nothing like starting your day with a warm, authentic New York style bagel—crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and baked fresh every morning. Whether you’re craving a quick breakfast, planning a family brunch, or ordering catering for the office, our Jamaica Plain shop has you covered.

📍 JP Bagel Co.

NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States