Best In-House Bakery in Coolidge Corner, MA

Nestled in the heart of Coolidge Corner, NY Bagel & Coffee Co is more than just your go-to coffee and bagel shop—it’s a true neighborhood bakery. We rise early to handcraft every croissant, muffin, cookie, and brownie from scratch, using real ingredients and no frozen shortcuts.

Whether you’re strolling over from Harvard Street, heading to work on the C Green Line, or grabbing a snack after a film at Coolidge Theatre, you’ll smell the warm, buttery goodness from the sidewalk. That’s because our oven’s always on, and everything is baked fresh, in-house, every day.

Order Now

📍 NY Bagel and Coffee Co.
Address: 111 Brighton Ave, Allston, MA 02134, United States

📞 Contact Number
Phone: +1 617 870 7937

📧 Email
info@nybagelandcoffeeco.com

🛒 Order Online
Order Now

🍪 Why Coolidge Corner Craves Our Bakery

🔥 In-House Daily Baking

Every croissant, muffin, cookie, and brownie comes from our own oven—not a factory. Our bakers start before dawn so your mornings start with warm, buttery perfection.

🍓 Crowd-Pleasing Variety

We offer more than just “the usual.” From sweet classics like cinnamon rolls to savory favorites like spinach ricotta croissants, plus seasonal surprises—there’s always something new to crave.

☕ Perfect for On-the-Go or Sit & Sip

In a rush? Grab a chocolate croissant and iced latte to-go. Got time to spare? Settle in with a warm muffin and hot tea. Our space is built for both speed and slow sips.

🍫 No Compromises—Only the Good Stuff

We bake with real butter, real chocolate, fresh fruit, and quality ingredients—never shortcuts, never fillers. You can taste the difference in every bite.

🏡 Community-Focused, Locally Loved

Whether you’re stopping in after school drop-off, taking a break between study sessions, or just strolling Coolidge Corner, our bakery is your neighborhood nook. We’re not here to impress the masses—we’re here to serve Brookline locals like you.

🧁 Coolidge Corner’s Bakery Menu – Baked Fresh Daily

🍥 Cinnamon Roll – $4.99

A pillowy-soft, buttery roll generously swirled with cinnamon sugar and baked to golden perfection. Finished with a rich, creamy vanilla icing glaze that melts into every warm bite. Pure comfort in pastry form.

🧁 French Toast Muffin – $4.99

Soft and buttery with cozy hints of cinnamon, nutmeg, and a touch of maple, this muffin captures the essence of classic French toast. Topped with a delicate sugar crust for extra warmth and sweetness.

🫐 Blueberry Muffin – $4.99

A moist, tender muffin packed with plump, fresh blueberries and just the right amount of natural sweetness. A timeless favorite that pairs perfectly with a hot cup of coffee.

🥐 Spinach Ricotta Savory Croissant – $5.25

A golden, flaky butter croissant filled with creamy ricotta cheese, tender spinach, and a light blend of herbs. Perfectly balanced for a savory breakfast or light lunch.

🍫 Chocolate Chip Muffin – $4.99

Soft and moist, this muffin is generously loaded with rich semi-sweet chocolate chips. Each bite delivers warm, gooey chocolate goodness wrapped in a fluffy muffin base.

🥐 Chocolate Croissant – $4.99

A traditional French pastry, delicately flaky and filled with smooth, melted dark chocolate. Light, buttery, and irresistibly rich—a Parisian café classic.

🍪 Monster Chocolate Chip Cookie – $4.99

Thick, chewy, and golden-brown, this oversized cookie is packed with chunks of semi-sweet chocolate chips for the ultimate chocolate lover’s dream.

🍏 Apple Chausson (Turnover) – $4.99

Layers of delicate puff pastry envelope a warm, sweet apple compote filling, subtly spiced with cinnamon. A flaky and fruity delight.

💚 Pistachio Muffin – $4.99

A moist, nutty muffin crafted with real ground pistachios and hints of almond extract. Topped with crushed pistachios for added texture and flavor.

🍌 Banana Walnut Muffin – $4.99

Made with ripe bananas and crunchy chopped walnuts, this moist and hearty muffin offers a perfect balance of sweetness and nuttiness.

🍫 Choco Gem Brownie – $4.99

A rich, fudgy brownie base topped with colorful chocolate candy gems. Soft, chewy, and loaded with chocolaty fun in every bite.

🍫 Chocolate Walnut Brownie – $4.99

Dense and decadent, this classic chocolate brownie is packed with chunks of crunchy walnuts for a satisfying texture contrast.

🥐 French Croissant – $3.99

A beautifully baked, traditional French croissant with a flaky exterior and soft, buttery center. Light, crisp, and freshly made every morning.

🥜 Grandmama’s Peanut Butter Cookie – $4.99

A nostalgic treat made with rich, creamy peanut butter, baked to golden perfection. Soft inside with a subtle crisp edge and deeply nutty flavor.

🍫🍥 Chocolate & Cinnamon Twist – $4.99

A flaky, twisted pastry layered with gooey chocolate and fragrant cinnamon sugar. Sweet, spiced, and perfect for sharing—or not!

🍥 Crunchy Cinnamon Swirl – $4.99

Crisp on the outside and swirled with rich cinnamon sugar, this golden pastry delivers crunch, sweetness, and warm spice in every bite.

🌰 Almond Croissant – $4.99

A buttery croissant filled with sweet almond cream and topped with lightly toasted sliced almonds. Rich, nutty, and indulgent.

🍎 Heavenly Apple Caramel Cookie – $4.99

Soft and chewy with chunks of real apple and gooey pockets of caramel, this cookie delivers sweet, fall-inspired flavor in every bite.

💬 What Coolidge Corner Locals Are Saying

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jessica R. – Preschool Mom

“After school drop-off, this place is my little sanctuary. I grab a pistachio muffin and a cappuccino, and suddenly my morning feels like a treat. The space is cozy, the staff is warm, and everything tastes like it was just pulled from the oven.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Noah D. – Remote Tech Worker

“I work from the café a few days a week—great Wi-Fi, calm vibe, and the cinnamon roll is next level. It’s flaky on the outside, gooey in the center, and always fresh. Perfect fuel for a workday.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Eli W. – BU Grad Student

“Trust me—I’ve taste-tested just about every muffin within a 2-mile radius of BU, and this place wins. The blueberry muffin is perfection: moist, studded with fruit, and just sweet enough. It’s become my study snack of choice.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Sandra M. – Brookline Resident

“You can tell instantly that everything is baked in-house. The pastries have that homemade soul—nothing dry, nothing overly sweet, just real ingredients and great balance. It’s the kind of place you brag to your friends about.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Derek H. – Coolidge Theatre Regular

“Came in after a matinee at the Coolidge Theatre and grabbed a chocolate chip cookie—it was still warm! Now I stop in almost every weekend. This bakery is part of my Saturday routine.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Priya K. – Vegan Pastry Seeker

“As someone who’s always hunting for vegan options, I appreciate how they always have something for me—vegan muffins, cookies, even drinks with oat and almond milk. And the best part? You’d never know they’re vegan—they’re just delicious.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Martin G. – Retired Teacher

“I’ve lived in Brookline for over 40 years, and this bakery reminds me of the kind of neighborhood spots we used to have growing up. Real baking, real people, and unbeatable brownies. It’s my go-to for a nostalgic treat.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Lila S. – College Prep Tutor

“Between back-to-back tutoring sessions, I need a spot that’s both peaceful and energizing. This bakery nails it. The almond croissant is beautifully layered, and their cold brew gives me the perfect afternoon boost. Plus, the space is always tidy and welcoming.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jordan F. – Weekend Cyclist

“I bike through Brookline every Saturday morning and this place is my first pit stop. I love grabbing a banana muffin and an iced Americano—quick, filling, and way better than chain cafés. Bonus: they always treat cyclists with a smile!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Alina M. – Young Mom & Local Foodie

“I’m super picky about pastries, and this bakery never disappoints. The spinach ricotta croissant is my guilty pleasure, and my toddler devours the oatmeal cookies. It’s hard to find spots that cater to both kids and food lovers—this one does it effortlessly.”

❓ FAQs – In-House Bakery in Coolidge Corner

1️⃣ Do you bake everything in-house?

Yes! Every croissant, muffin, cookie, and pastry is made from scratch right here in Coolidge Corner each morning. We never use frozen dough or mass-produced mixes—just quality ingredients and in-house baking expertise.

2️⃣ What time are pastries available?

Our bakers get an early start, so most pastries are ready by 7:30 AM, with fresh batches coming out through the morning. Come early for your favorites—they sell out fast on weekends!

3️⃣ Are there vegan or gluten-free options?

Definitely! We regularly offer vegan muffins and cookies, and select gluten-free baked goods. Just ask our team what’s fresh today or check the online menu for dietary-friendly choices.

4️⃣ Do you offer bulk orders or catering trays?

Yes! We’re happy to put together assorted pastry trays for office breakfasts, family brunches, or events. Pre-order online or call ahead for custom options, including mini muffins, croissant boxes, and bagel bundles.

5️⃣ Can I dine in or work from the café?

Absolutely. Our Coolidge Corner café features indoor seating, strong Wi-Fi, and a laid-back vibe—perfect for studying, remote work, or coffee catch-ups.

6️⃣ Is this location family-friendly?

Yes! We welcome kids and families. From oversized cookies to cozy seating and high chairs, we’ve got everything you need for a relaxed family outing.

7️⃣ Where exactly are you located?

We’re just off Harvard Street, a short walk from the Coolidge Corner Green Line stop, right near Trader Joe’s and the Coolidge Theatre—perfect for locals and visitors alike.

8️⃣ What’s your best-selling pastry?

Our cinnamon roll and spinach ricotta croissant are customer favorites, but the French toast muffin and monster cookie are top contenders too!

9️⃣ Can I reserve items in advance?

Yes! Use our online ordering platform to reserve pastries, bagels, or coffee for pickup. It’s the easiest way to guarantee your favorites, especially during busy mornings.

🔟 Do you sell anything besides pastries?

Yes—we also offer freshly brewed coffee, espresso drinks, teas, and a full bagel sandwich menu featuring everything from egg & cheese to lox and cream cheese.

🛍️ Pastries Made Fresh for Coolidge Corner

Whether you’re sipping a latte or stocking up for Sunday brunch, everything at NY Bagel & Coffee Co in Coolidge Corner is made in-house, from scratch, daily. You can taste the difference in every flaky layer, melty chip, and crunchy edge.

📍 Swing by today or order online—your next favorite pastry is just a block away.
🥐 Real baking. Real local. Real good.